Fantastic food! Service wasn't the best but also not the norm. Both food and service are usually outstanding.
Dana
 Our meal was amazing. We shared the 14 ounce ribeye with mashed potatoes and asparagus and mushroom gravy. All of it was too perfection. We also had salad salads, a beef salad and a Caesar salad that were wonderful. The drinks were off the chain. We could have taken a pass on the sweet potato bread pudding.
Sam
Our dinner at Sisters was pleasant. There were not enough wait staff to see all guests in an expedient manner, delaying our receipt of drinks and appetizer. Everyone was quite friendly, and the food was tasty. The food lacked a certain wow factor. The meats on the entrees were great, but the accompanying grains and sides were satisfactory. We would come here again, especially if we plan to attend another production at the Barter Theatre!
Hilary
We are return customers and we always enjoy special dinners at Sister's. Gina is our favorite waitress. The food is always delicious. The atmosphere is usually very nice but we did not like the oldies 1970s-80s pop music that was playing on Thursday October 23rd. We would prefer something more mellow and classic, such as jazz, show tunes, classical music or popular music from the 1940s and 50s. Sister's is a destination restaurant for us. We drive all the way to Abingdon from Winchester, Tennessee to see a play at the Barter and dine at Sister's. Please play music that befits the elegance of the setting. Thank you.
Lisa
Server was nice but not very attentive. She forgot to bring me my dessert until it was cold and hard.
Michael
We were disappointed with the food. It was mediocre at best. Our Server, Nikita, was quite pleasant. The dining room and Inn in general was very historic and interesting. We loved all of the pictures on the walls and the wide veranda looking out onto Main Street. We were glad that we went, but do not plan to return.
Sara Puckett
My girl friends and I had the best dinner at Sisters. We came to see a play at the Barter Theater across the street. The food was FANTASTIC and our witness Amy was the highlight of our dinner. So personable and hilarious. Best place in Abington to eat.
Rachael
Our server (Amy) made our visit so much more enjoyable. She had us laughing the entire time and was very helpful with menu suggestions.
Wayne
We enjoyed the choices we had for our dinner. The food was cooked as requested and delicious The wait person was very helpful in making a change for my wife. We look forward to our next visit whether we stay at the hotel or not.
Jackie Graham
I brought family from Arizona to the restaurant on Labor Day and they fell in love with the restaurant and the food. We each ordered things that were shared with the table, giving each person a broader vision of the dishes. Alisha was our server and she gave wonderful suggestions and answered questions about the different menu items. Her help was greatly appreciated, she is a great representative of Sisters at the Martha. Thank you to Alisha and the kitchen staff for such a wonderful dining experience!
I brought family from Arizona to the restaurant on Labor Day and they fell in love with the restaurant and the food. Alisha was our server and she gave wonderful suggestions and answered questions about the different menu items. Her help was greatly appreciated, she is a great representative of Sisters at the Martha. Thank you to Alisha and the kitchen staff for such a wonderful dining experience!
Athena Kingma
Alychia was our Server - she did an outstanding job. She was very friendly, engaging, and well informed regarding the menu. I recommend Sister‘s American Grill. We enjoyed a wonderful family dinner in a warm and welcoming dining area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madison Apel
I went to sisters for dinner and we ended up sitting at the bar, our bartender Nikita was fantastic! Definitely will be coming back!
Noah Dorton
Had a date night at Sister’s the other night, our bartender Nikita was amazing! She was great and made our experience that much better!
Aaron Hill
Marissa was an excellent server - very personable and genuinely wants you to have a great time! The food and wine was all excellent - highly recommend the Surf & Turf if it’s on the specials along with the Salted Caramel gelato for dessert!
Fantastic food! Service wasn't the best but also not the norm. Both food and service are usually outstanding.
 Our meal was amazing. We shared the 14 ounce ribeye with mashed potatoes and asparagus and mushroom gravy. All of it was too perfection. We also had salad salads, a beef salad and a Caesar salad that were wonderful. The drinks were off the chain. We could have taken a pass on the sweet potato bread pudding.
Our dinner at Sisters was pleasant. There were not enough wait staff to see all guests in an expedient manner, delaying our receipt of drinks and appetizer. Everyone was quite friendly, and the food was tasty. The food lacked a certain wow factor. The meats on the entrees were great, but the accompanying grains and sides were satisfactory. We would come here again, especially if we plan to attend another production at the Barter Theatre!
We are return customers and we always enjoy special dinners at Sister's. Gina is our favorite waitress. The food is always delicious. The atmosphere is usually very nice but we did not like the oldies 1970s-80s pop music that was playing on Thursday October 23rd. We would prefer something more mellow and classic, such as jazz, show tunes, classical music or popular music from the 1940s and 50s. Sister's is a destination restaurant for us. We drive all the way to Abingdon from Winchester, Tennessee to see a play at the Barter and dine at Sister's. Please play music that befits the elegance of the setting. Thank you.
Server was nice but not very attentive. She forgot to bring me my dessert until it was cold and hard.
We were disappointed with the food. It was mediocre at best. Our Server, Nikita, was quite pleasant. The dining room and Inn in general was very historic and interesting. We loved all of the pictures on the walls and the wide veranda looking out onto Main Street. We were glad that we went, but do not plan to return.
My girl friends and I had the best dinner at Sisters. We came to see a play at the Barter Theater across the street. The food was FANTASTIC and our witness Amy was the highlight of our dinner. So personable and hilarious. Best place in Abington to eat.
Our server (Amy) made our visit so much more enjoyable. She had us laughing the entire time and was very helpful with menu suggestions.
We enjoyed the choices we had for our dinner. The food was cooked as requested and delicious The wait person was very helpful in making a change for my wife. We look forward to our next visit whether we stay at the hotel or not.
I brought family from Arizona to the restaurant on Labor Day and they fell in love with the restaurant and the food. We each ordered things that were shared with the table, giving each person a broader vision of the dishes. Alisha was our server and she gave wonderful suggestions and answered questions about the different menu items. Her help was greatly appreciated, she is a great representative of Sisters at the Martha. Thank you to Alisha and the kitchen staff for such a wonderful dining experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I brought family from Arizona to the restaurant on Labor Day and they fell in love with the restaurant and the food. Alisha was our server and she gave wonderful suggestions and answered questions about the different menu items. Her help was greatly appreciated, she is a great representative of Sisters at the Martha. Thank you to Alisha and the kitchen staff for such a wonderful dining experience!
Alychia was our Server - she did an outstanding job. She was very friendly, engaging, and well informed regarding the menu. I recommend Sister‘s American Grill. We enjoyed a wonderful family dinner in a warm and welcoming dining area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went to sisters for dinner and we ended up sitting at the bar, our bartender Nikita was fantastic! Definitely will be coming back!
Had a date night at Sister’s the other night, our bartender Nikita was amazing! She was great and made our experience that much better!
Marissa was an excellent server - very personable and genuinely wants you to have a great time! The food and wine was all excellent - highly recommend the Surf & Turf if it’s on the specials along with the Salted Caramel gelato for dessert!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...