Used to go here all the time, it's not the best pizza but it's definitely the best value and it's still pretty good
Chelsea Marie
The person who took our order was having a profanity-laced cell phone conversation while we were trying to order AND openly drinking a beer. There was another person--unclear if they were an employee- blasting music over the sound system. The cook making the pizza seemed to be the only person actually working but was eating a lollipop and holding the wet lollipop in her hand touching the dough which was yuck. It took 30 minutes to for 2 slices to come out. Last visit.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Steve S.
Friendly staff and ridiculously delicious and HUGE slices of pizza Highly recommended
S
I was here on June 9th and just received the best service. You could tell the pizza chef loved making these massive pizza pies and was excited for the new move to the store closer to campus. The food was great. Service was stellar. I love going to all the Benny's and this one is definitely top tier
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ralf Mann
Ok. 28" pie is one thing. But a 28" pie that is some of the tastiest pizza I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Trevis Wood
I had waited almost a year to eat here. As I was waiting for my slices and emergency call came over my radio so I had to leave. I came back about 30 min later and they still had my slices ready. 1 year and 30 mins wait. Totally worth it. I'll eat here again.
Aidan Donahue
Poor service. I went to the bathroom for a couple minutes and they threw out an entire beer I only had taken a few sips from, as well as the rest of my pizza. I am seriously disappointed.
Kaylie Powell
This pizza is amazing! Not only does it taste great, but the price you pay includes great entertainment for the size of the pizza. This pizza will be sure to deliver happy grins from the great taste to the bulging eyes of how it even made it out of the door, into the car and through the door frame at home. Giggles will be heard at the size of the box, pie and slice! Worth every penny!
Alexander Zummo
If you want the biggest slice of delicious pizza you've ever seen, this is the place to go!
Haven't been here in a couple years. Fond memories of grabbing a whole pizza and heading across the street to the brewery. I was expecting the prices to be higher, as they were, but the pizza just wasn't the same. Ordered a couple different slices and had to send them back to finish cooking. Still a little doughy inside but starting burn on the bottom. Benny's never was cheese-heavy, but cheese was barely noticeable visually or taste-wise. Hoping it was just a bad day. Heard there might be a new brewery across the street and would like to relive the past.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Farzana Yasmin Ahmad
The place seems aesthetic to me in a different way. It looks like my grandparents home back in Bangladesh.Pizza was awesome. They were fresh. We took two garlic mushroom pizza slices. They were too big for us. Worth it. Will visit there again.
Natascha K.
Amazing thin crust NY style giant pizza! Friendly service! Cool spot! Excited to try other locations too!
Andrew Choffel
Ordered a pizza around lunchtime. Seemed to be one person working and one customer inside. However, customer service is not where my issues begin. The pizza quite frankly is terrible and not worth anywhere near the price. Thank god I used an online coupon to lower the price of the pizza. The pizza both literally and figuratively stinks, I’m not sure what cheese they use, but they should change it immediately because it smells and tastes almost sour. It’s disgusting. I can see why they have a challenge for eating their pizza because it was a challenge for me to eat even a bite of this terrible tasting pizza. The pizza smells and tastes just weird. I can assume the only reason they’re in business is rich college kids buying a 28 inch pizza for their drunk buddies as a neat gimmick. Customer service is fine, but the pizza is honestly disgusting and I feel like I should be the one paid to eat it.Parking: Parking sucks so you either have to walk here, use the 15 parking, or pay for tuition to UVA so you can be drunk enough to enjoy the pizza.
Ellie K
Delicious pizza but everytime I go I'm met with coldness by staff. I'm sorry if you don't like your job or are struggling but it does put me off when I'm actually excited to be there.
Omg why are they closed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Used to go here all the time, it's not the best pizza but it's definitely the best value and it's still pretty good
The person who took our order was having a profanity-laced cell phone conversation while we were trying to order AND openly drinking a beer. There was another person--unclear if they were an employee- blasting music over the sound system. The cook making the pizza seemed to be the only person actually working but was eating a lollipop and holding the wet lollipop in her hand touching the dough which was yuck. It took 30 minutes to for 2 slices to come out. Last visit.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Friendly staff and ridiculously delicious and HUGE slices of pizza Highly recommended
I was here on June 9th and just received the best service. You could tell the pizza chef loved making these massive pizza pies and was excited for the new move to the store closer to campus. The food was great. Service was stellar. I love going to all the Benny's and this one is definitely top tier
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok. 28" pie is one thing. But a 28" pie that is some of the tastiest pizza I've had in a long time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I had waited almost a year to eat here. As I was waiting for my slices and emergency call came over my radio so I had to leave. I came back about 30 min later and they still had my slices ready. 1 year and 30 mins wait. Totally worth it. I'll eat here again.
Poor service. I went to the bathroom for a couple minutes and they threw out an entire beer I only had taken a few sips from, as well as the rest of my pizza. I am seriously disappointed.
This pizza is amazing! Not only does it taste great, but the price you pay includes great entertainment for the size of the pizza. This pizza will be sure to deliver happy grins from the great taste to the bulging eyes of how it even made it out of the door, into the car and through the door frame at home. Giggles will be heard at the size of the box, pie and slice! Worth every penny!
If you want the biggest slice of delicious pizza you've ever seen, this is the place to go!
Restaurantji Recommends
Haven't been here in a couple years. Fond memories of grabbing a whole pizza and heading across the street to the brewery. I was expecting the prices to be higher, as they were, but the pizza just wasn't the same. Ordered a couple different slices and had to send them back to finish cooking. Still a little doughy inside but starting burn on the bottom. Benny's never was cheese-heavy, but cheese was barely noticeable visually or taste-wise. Hoping it was just a bad day. Heard there might be a new brewery across the street and would like to relive the past.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
The place seems aesthetic to me in a different way. It looks like my grandparents home back in Bangladesh.Pizza was awesome. They were fresh. We took two garlic mushroom pizza slices. They were too big for us. Worth it. Will visit there again.
Amazing thin crust NY style giant pizza! Friendly service! Cool spot! Excited to try other locations too!
Ordered a pizza around lunchtime. Seemed to be one person working and one customer inside. However, customer service is not where my issues begin. The pizza quite frankly is terrible and not worth anywhere near the price. Thank god I used an online coupon to lower the price of the pizza. The pizza both literally and figuratively stinks, I’m not sure what cheese they use, but they should change it immediately because it smells and tastes almost sour. It’s disgusting. I can see why they have a challenge for eating their pizza because it was a challenge for me to eat even a bite of this terrible tasting pizza. The pizza smells and tastes just weird. I can assume the only reason they’re in business is rich college kids buying a 28 inch pizza for their drunk buddies as a neat gimmick. Customer service is fine, but the pizza is honestly disgusting and I feel like I should be the one paid to eat it.Parking: Parking sucks so you either have to walk here, use the 15 parking, or pay for tuition to UVA so you can be drunk enough to enjoy the pizza.
Delicious pizza but everytime I go I'm met with coldness by staff. I'm sorry if you don't like your job or are struggling but it does put me off when I'm actually excited to be there.