Normally love mellow but this last experience was fairly negative. Ordered 4 pizzas to go and they were cold. They forgot the ranch on my Buffalo pizza as well as the two sides of beer cheese that I ordered. When I called the person answering the phone acted like it was our fault for not checking for the sides of beer cheese. Overall did not meet expectations. ---- REVISED owner reached out to apologize and discounted our order. Would eat here again but will probably be in the restaurant and not to go.
Raphael
First time to this Mellow Mushroom, but I’ve been to others. We did carry out. It was pretty good. If you sign up online you get free pretzel bites.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Jamie Soulshine
OMG the pizza was so good. So we're the pretzel bites, brownie and chocolate chip cookie. We had to take a cheesy picture with the statue.
We ordered 30 pizzas, a mix of cheese, pepperoni, and a bunch of specialty pizzas (Funky Q, Mighty Meaty, Veggie), and as usual, the pizza was amazing and the service was excellent. The pizzas were hot and ready to go. People keep coming back to this same event again and again probably in part large because we’re serving Mellow!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie S.
Seriously some of the best pizza I've ever had. We ordered take out and after the 15% tip my order was a little over $100 for 2 large pizzas, 22 wings & pretzel bites with beer cheese. Considering location I knew the prices would be higher than I'm used to but I am certain I would pay the price again. The Mighty Meaty Pizza & Parmesan Garlic wings were SO GOOD!!! The only thing I wouldn't order again is the pretzel bites. The beer cheese was not the greatest.
Rachael Kennedy
I've been a Mellow fan since the late 80s! It's consistently delicious. I only rated the atmosphere 4 because for some odd reason the music was this dreary singer-so writer stuff. I wanted to sleep. Noooo. Please bring back the funkadelic tunes that Mellow is known for!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
michelle logreco
The thincrust was a nice option ( I’d like to see the regular if this is thin)I thought it was dry.My mushroom soup came out lukewarm warm, had to get it microwaved.It was ok, really rich.I had to ask for silverware.I sat at the bar, Sunday evening, only one other person at the bar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Alexandra Novogradac
There gf pizza is very expensive for what it is. It's pretty good, but small and a lot of sauce.Dietary restrictions: Gf pizza crust
Joseph C. Scott
Great spot for food, drinks, and football watching!
I love that there are unique combinations and the pizza was a great size! Just needs a little more seasoning but overall satisfying!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Craig Massie
Let’s talk atmosphere, this place has mellow mushrooms and you can’t really go wrong with that. The service was lacking as far as quickness goes, still everyone was nice and they looked happy working there. I’m ranking food a 4 for having too much on one pizza. I ordered the Holy Shiitake Pie and it had to many competing flavors. If they left out the aioli sauce and some of the herbs, I think it would have been better. But the crust was great and it wasn’t a bad pizza. I did try the pizza cold for leftovers and it was much better. I will be bringing my young kids because I think they would enjoy all the hidden mushrooms in the artwork.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Noreen R.
Ordered the veggie pizza, meatball app and a salad. The pizza was soggy. The meatballs were meh and the salad was really bad. Mostly lettuce but a lot of spines (many w brown patches) almost no tomatoes and a ton of white onion and black olives. They must have been the cheapest item to add. Anyway, that's the last time for me! Edit: This was Sunday the 3rd.
Kelly Kostuik
Great pizza and a nice beer selection. Service was ok until our server Jacob ran my card, gave himself a 19% tip by adding it to the food & drink amount and then brought me a credit card slip with a blank tip amount to be filled in.
Normally love mellow but this last experience was fairly negative. Ordered 4 pizzas to go and they were cold. They forgot the ranch on my Buffalo pizza as well as the two sides of beer cheese that I ordered. When I called the person answering the phone acted like it was our fault for not checking for the sides of beer cheese. Overall did not meet expectations. ---- REVISED owner reached out to apologize and discounted our order. Would eat here again but will probably be in the restaurant and not to go.
First time to this Mellow Mushroom, but I’ve been to others. We did carry out. It was pretty good. If you sign up online you get free pretzel bites.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
OMG the pizza was so good. So we're the pretzel bites, brownie and chocolate chip cookie. We had to take a cheesy picture with the statue.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Maui Wowie Pizza, Pretzel Bites
Great food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pretzels, Pepperoni Pizza
We ordered 30 pizzas, a mix of cheese, pepperoni, and a bunch of specialty pizzas (Funky Q, Mighty Meaty, Veggie), and as usual, the pizza was amazing and the service was excellent. The pizzas were hot and ready to go. People keep coming back to this same event again and again probably in part large because we’re serving Mellow!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seriously some of the best pizza I've ever had. We ordered take out and after the 15% tip my order was a little over $100 for 2 large pizzas, 22 wings & pretzel bites with beer cheese. Considering location I knew the prices would be higher than I'm used to but I am certain I would pay the price again. The Mighty Meaty Pizza & Parmesan Garlic wings were SO GOOD!!! The only thing I wouldn't order again is the pretzel bites. The beer cheese was not the greatest.
I've been a Mellow fan since the late 80s! It's consistently delicious. I only rated the atmosphere 4 because for some odd reason the music was this dreary singer-so writer stuff. I wanted to sleep. Noooo. Please bring back the funkadelic tunes that Mellow is known for!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The thincrust was a nice option ( I’d like to see the regular if this is thin)I thought it was dry.My mushroom soup came out lukewarm warm, had to get it microwaved.It was ok, really rich.I had to ask for silverware.I sat at the bar, Sunday evening, only one other person at the bar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
There gf pizza is very expensive for what it is. It's pretty good, but small and a lot of sauce.Dietary restrictions: Gf pizza crust
Great spot for food, drinks, and football watching!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Super kid friendly. Great salads and pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love that there are unique combinations and the pizza was a great size! Just needs a little more seasoning but overall satisfying!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Let’s talk atmosphere, this place has mellow mushrooms and you can’t really go wrong with that. The service was lacking as far as quickness goes, still everyone was nice and they looked happy working there. I’m ranking food a 4 for having too much on one pizza. I ordered the Holy Shiitake Pie and it had to many competing flavors. If they left out the aioli sauce and some of the herbs, I think it would have been better. But the crust was great and it wasn’t a bad pizza. I did try the pizza cold for leftovers and it was much better. I will be bringing my young kids because I think they would enjoy all the hidden mushrooms in the artwork.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ordered the veggie pizza, meatball app and a salad. The pizza was soggy. The meatballs were meh and the salad was really bad. Mostly lettuce but a lot of spines (many w brown patches) almost no tomatoes and a ton of white onion and black olives. They must have been the cheapest item to add. Anyway, that's the last time for me! Edit: This was Sunday the 3rd.
Great pizza and a nice beer selection. Service was ok until our server Jacob ran my card, gave himself a 19% tip by adding it to the food & drink amount and then brought me a credit card slip with a blank tip amount to be filled in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1