Elkton Goodfellas

$ • Pizza

Hours today·

About Elkton Goodfellas

Elkton Goodfellas is a restaurant known for its amazing overall experience and great vibes. The menu offers delicious food, with the Stromboli being a standout favorite - an inside-out pizza stuffed with various meats and vegetables, and reviewers say it is huge with melted, stringy cheese and a great dipping sauce. The Lasagna is also excellent, adding to the variety, and the baked Ziti is praised for its creamy ricotta cheese in a delicious sauce. Pepperoni pizza with a thin crust and lots of cheese is also a favorite. Portions are larger than expected, providing good value for money, and the pizza is affordable. The service is friendly, cheerful, and attentive, with staff making sure drinks stay full even during busy times, and the old school sit-down feel is a charm. It can get very busy, so parking can be a challenge, and more seating would be beneficial as the place fills up quickly during lunch and dinner, though the small size makes for a cozy atmosphere. Elkton Goodfellas is a kid-friendly place where everyone is welcomed and loved, making it a great stop for those visiting the Elkton, VA area and Shenandoah NP.

Menu

Add a Menu
Elkton Goodfellas Menu
Elkton Goodfellas Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Elkton Goodfellas
Elkton Goodfellas
View All Photos

Elkton Goodfellas Reviews

4.6
229 ratings
5
82%
4
11%
3
1%
1
6%
Food
4.6
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.8

Share your opinion about Elkton Goodfellas

Great food and even better service.
Stopped there last evening on the way home and glad we did.

Keep up the great work... ❤️
Best place to eat! 😊😊😊😊😊😊
Nice little Italian place. My friends pepperoni pizza was thinking crust, lots of cheese. He really liked it. The stromboli was huge. But the melted cheese was good and stringy. Full of meats. Great dipping sauce.
The lasagna my 3rd friend got was good she said. I got the baked Ziti was delicious. It had ricotta cheese in it. So creamy. In a delicious sauce.

Read All Reviews(225)

Hours

Monday 11AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 11AM - 9:30PM
Friday 11AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 11AM - 9:30PM
Sunday 11AM - 9:30PM
Updated on: