Rookie's

16129 Forest Rd, Forest
(434) 841-8172

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Niki Maynard

I LOVE ROOKIE'S! Tragically, I live 2,443 miles away, but perhaps that's a good thing because I would be broke and my doctor would be pretty unhappy with my health. But truly, I love this place. The staff are always the best and the ice cream is such a delight. I made an ice cream cookie sandwich with triple chocolate and brown sugar cookies and a scoop of Crack. SO GOOD! You have to try this flavor. Kiersten, the employee working when we were there last, was so patient and answered all of my questions, allowing me plenty of time to decide my perfect flavor combo. And it's only like $5???? Incredible. LOVE IT HERE! Would 10000% recommend!! (P.S. Rookie's, if you're seeing this, please call me asap if you ever decide to open a SoCal location!)

Robert Rafano

Great ice cream

Jacob Hancock

Rookie’s is a perfect vibe and the treats are great! Service is great! Highly recommend!

Austin Budhram

Great cookies and cream ice cream.

Joe Warren

Ice cream and cookie. I don't think it requires more to be said.

Sophia Victoria

Great ice cream! Great people! Great location! Great hours!

I'm lactose intolerant when it comes to processed diary, personally, but I can eat Rookie's with no problem. I think because they get their milk from Homestead Creamery, a good (and local!) farm/source. They don't always have vegan/non-diary ice cream, from my experience, although they've made a lot of new changes, so maybe they do have it consistently now. But either way, their ice cream is delicious and comes from ethical places and the service is amazing!

It's one of my favorite places to go for an occasional special treat with friends or just by myself after work to chill and relax and treat myself. Rookie's never fails to deliver the best spot for a spontaneous late night summer adventure with friends either, since they are open late (11 or 11:30 I think). During the warm summer months I could not wait until the end of the week when I got paid on Friday and Rookie's was open to go and treat myself. God bless this place! Rookie's has become very dear to my heart with many fond memories having been made here.❤

(Seen on the pictures is their lemon ice cream and sugar cookie)

Last time I went there with my husband, they had a delicious selection! I wish I could remember what we got. (I didn't take any pictures, either.) I know I got some kind of a coffee/espresso drink with icecream in it. I hope that's something they're still offering - it was delicious!!!

Darren Smith

Great place to stop in for ice cream. However, don’t be in a rush if there is any bit of a line. Service is is not very efficient.

Jennifer Bullock

First timers who were staying in town with future Liberty University students and loved our experience at Rookies. Matthew was the most friendly person we had experienced in all of our trip. We got some recommendations and enjoyed warm cookies with creamy ice cream. This was a great once in a while treat and it looked like sometimes there are other food/drink trucks open. Though they were closed during our stay we could imagine how amazing it would be.

Terrence Mulleano-Battle (TwizzyT)

Just got back from a summer camp and hadn’t had any ice cream in ages! Decided to go and try rookies out for my first time. Homemade peanut butter cookie on a skillet with cookies and cream on top was the best thing I’ve ever tasted! Chowed it down in a minute. I’m definitely coming back, good. customer service!

A P

Out of towner and I will be back! I got the cookie skillet with a scoop on top and it was amazing. So good. I still think about it 🤣

Noelle Brueck

Super good!!

Dylan Minervini

Wouldn't let me buy ice cream at an event I paid to be at, really unfortunate because I liked this place guess Mr. Goodies is better. I was also treated with attitude and disrespect again really sad but I guess all good companies forget where they're built off of. As well with this I am a type one diabetic and I am supposed to pre-bolus for this and now have been fighting hypoglycemia ever since this incident.

Dylan Hudson

The raspberry cheesecake is quite possibly the best ice cream I’ve ever had, the service is super friendly, and the environment is cozy. It’s a must try!

Leah Hughes

The cookies and ice cream are so good!! And it has the cutest outdoor seating for the whole family!

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free cookies and vegan ice cream!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan, Craft Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Michael Kyrychenko

Delicious and with great prices. Fabulous sweet treat that was well worth the calories.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...