I can't believe I waited so long to try one of these pies! We got the cherry one and it was amazing, but we're sitting on the edge of our seat waiting for the seasonal flavors to come around so we can give those a try too. I'm afraid to mention how phenomenal the bread and butter pickles are because I'm scared you'll sell out before I get over there to get some more if other folks hear how delicious they are. If I could give more than 5 stars I would.
BLU CHRUSH MEGA TRUCK
Called looking for a pie and received 3 within 16 hours from jump and they look spectacular. I will update later on taste but atmosphere on the phone call was amazing like I was speaking to my sister. Thank you Carla, check these pies outPecan , lemon meringue and sweet potato piesOK this is my honest opinionThe Pecan is exactly what I like crunchy filling with a Pecan crust. The sweet potato I ordered with spice and its more of a pumpkin pie I would say , next time I will try without the spiceSo delicious, well worth the minimal expense for a home cooked pie for my wife's bday. Still waiting to cut into the lemon meringueStay tuned
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Rutt
Hands down! Best pies around! ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Meringue, Danishes, Strawberry Pie, Pecan Pie, Apple Pie
Brett Corle
Carla should be world famous! Her baked goods are exquisite! If you have not experienced her creations, you have not fully lived! Carla made hundreds of custom cupcakes for my daughter’s wedding…..all I can say is WOW!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nelson Parrish
Boy o boy are these pies good and the customer service is superb. This place needs to be talked about way more because for a popular as pauls bakery is i believe the sweets here are so much
Food: 5
Andrew Szynal
Amazing all around. My wife, Jamie, ordered a cake for my MIL. The cake was not only big and heavy but delicious. Very detailed and we all loved the butter cream. My wife said that Ms Patton was not only incredibly kind, generous, but sweet just like her pastries!Thank you again, Ms. Patton. May God continue to bless your business. We will be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Marino
As I sit here this evening, I’m enjoying a slice of Carla’s Apple Crumb Pie! There isn’t a single thing we’ve ordered from Patton Pie Company that hasn’t been exceptional. Carla is a master at the art of old school baking and canning. Her jams and jellies are so incredibly flavorful. Her pickles remind me of the fresh ones I used to pull out of the barrels in NYC delis when I was growing up. Everything on her menu is made to order so you can’t just show up, but believe me no matter what you order it is worth the wait. And Carla herself is the kindest most pleasant person you’ll ever meet. Give her a call or send a text and try something, I promise you’ll be back for more!
Katelynn Tullis
One of the best peach pies I have ever had! They were able to make it same day as I ordered, along with an extra treat. The owner is a doll and was extremely kind. Would recommend 100% and we can’t wait to order another!
Phill
We purchased two pies for our oldest daughter's birthday, an apple and blueberry pie.The best pie I have had, better than my mothers even.We will be asking for desserts from Patton Pie Company for all our future special events.
Eric H
Found this company by chance in a last minute search for pumpkin pie for a birthday. They were so kind to do this for us with 24 hour notice. The pie was absolutely amazing. By far the best pumpkin pie we have got from any local place. We can’t wait to try others. A must try!!
Just happen to come across this company in a last minute search for pumpkin pie. They were so kind as to bake pie for the following day for our son’s birthday. The pie was OUT of this world!!! Delicious!!! We just found our new spot for future cakes/pies.
Amber W
The Strawberries & Cream pie was amazing! It was the perfect balance of sweet and tart. The pie crust was great. The owner was very friendly and responsive. The home based bakery was easy to find. I can’t wait to try other desserts from this bakery.
Jose Chang-Rodriguez
I can eat the pies Carla makes in about 2 days. I hope that's a testimony of how delicious her pies are. Thank you Carla!!
Lindy Bushnell
I had Patton Pie Company make our vegan dessert for my wedding and it was absolutely delicious! We definitely enjoyed it, and highly recommend anything she makes!
Lynda Russell
Carla makes the most yummy desserts and sweets! Not only are they completely delicious but they are beautiful as well! Thank you for all of the ones that you made for us! ?
I can't believe I waited so long to try one of these pies! We got the cherry one and it was amazing, but we're sitting on the edge of our seat waiting for the seasonal flavors to come around so we can give those a try too. I'm afraid to mention how phenomenal the bread and butter pickles are because I'm scared you'll sell out before I get over there to get some more if other folks hear how delicious they are. If I could give more than 5 stars I would.
Called looking for a pie and received 3 within 16 hours from jump and they look spectacular. I will update later on taste but atmosphere on the phone call was amazing like I was speaking to my sister. Thank you Carla, check these pies outPecan , lemon meringue and sweet potato piesOK this is my honest opinionThe Pecan is exactly what I like crunchy filling with a Pecan crust. The sweet potato I ordered with spice and its more of a pumpkin pie I would say , next time I will try without the spiceSo delicious, well worth the minimal expense for a home cooked pie for my wife's bday. Still waiting to cut into the lemon meringueStay tuned
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down! Best pies around! ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Meringue, Danishes, Strawberry Pie, Pecan Pie, Apple Pie
Carla should be world famous! Her baked goods are exquisite! If you have not experienced her creations, you have not fully lived! Carla made hundreds of custom cupcakes for my daughter’s wedding…..all I can say is WOW!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Boy o boy are these pies good and the customer service is superb. This place needs to be talked about way more because for a popular as pauls bakery is i believe the sweets here are so much
Food: 5
Amazing all around. My wife, Jamie, ordered a cake for my MIL. The cake was not only big and heavy but delicious. Very detailed and we all loved the butter cream. My wife said that Ms Patton was not only incredibly kind, generous, but sweet just like her pastries!Thank you again, Ms. Patton. May God continue to bless your business. We will be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As I sit here this evening, I’m enjoying a slice of Carla’s Apple Crumb Pie! There isn’t a single thing we’ve ordered from Patton Pie Company that hasn’t been exceptional. Carla is a master at the art of old school baking and canning. Her jams and jellies are so incredibly flavorful. Her pickles remind me of the fresh ones I used to pull out of the barrels in NYC delis when I was growing up. Everything on her menu is made to order so you can’t just show up, but believe me no matter what you order it is worth the wait. And Carla herself is the kindest most pleasant person you’ll ever meet. Give her a call or send a text and try something, I promise you’ll be back for more!
One of the best peach pies I have ever had! They were able to make it same day as I ordered, along with an extra treat. The owner is a doll and was extremely kind. Would recommend 100% and we can’t wait to order another!
We purchased two pies for our oldest daughter's birthday, an apple and blueberry pie.The best pie I have had, better than my mothers even.We will be asking for desserts from Patton Pie Company for all our future special events.
Found this company by chance in a last minute search for pumpkin pie for a birthday. They were so kind to do this for us with 24 hour notice. The pie was absolutely amazing. By far the best pumpkin pie we have got from any local place. We can’t wait to try others. A must try!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Just happen to come across this company in a last minute search for pumpkin pie. They were so kind as to bake pie for the following day for our son’s birthday. The pie was OUT of this world!!! Delicious!!! We just found our new spot for future cakes/pies.
The Strawberries & Cream pie was amazing! It was the perfect balance of sweet and tart. The pie crust was great. The owner was very friendly and responsive. The home based bakery was easy to find. I can’t wait to try other desserts from this bakery.
I can eat the pies Carla makes in about 2 days. I hope that's a testimony of how delicious her pies are. Thank you Carla!!
I had Patton Pie Company make our vegan dessert for my wedding and it was absolutely delicious! We definitely enjoyed it, and highly recommend anything she makes!
Carla makes the most yummy desserts and sweets! Not only are they completely delicious but they are beautiful as well! Thank you for all of the ones that you made for us! ?