I was visiting the Hampton area to medically oversee a boxing match and had had a strenuous day sitting in the blazing sun for 6 hours watching sites. I was exhausted a quiet cool place to calm down and eat. I randomly picked the Mill St Tavern and what a lucky pick. It's a small, nondescript building out of town. I went in and immediately felt better! It was kinda dark and cool. The hostess was adorable and courteous. I had steak bits as an appetizer which was a steak cut up into cubes. It was very tender and perfectly cooked. Entree was a triple decker club and tater tots. GREAT!!! Prices were reasonable, food was great, service and atmosphere was wonderful!!! I'd go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Braaten
Great little dive bar beer was 3.25 August 2025
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Ciaran Maguire
After scouring Google Maps for 30 minutes looking up various dive bars, I ended up gambling on Mill Creek Tavern.
Best decision ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toni Centrella
This place has things that you would not know to eat at dinner time which is pretty healthy I was very surprised. Always pretty much a great atmosphere and prices not bad for this time of year
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Live Luv SAIL
Very friendly service food was good, we had wings, sliders with sweet potato fries, Cucumber salad and a fish sandwich. No mixer drinks just beer and wine
The restaurant is one level with an outside patio... Local hangout people knew each other.
Accepts cash and credit.
Salads available for vegetarians
Anita Rapp
Welcoming small town style bar, where everyone knows each other. Great food. Beer and wine level alcohol, no liquor.
Boat Whisperer
Good food, good prices, down home atmosphere.
Sam N Jackie Nelson
We took a large group of out of town guests there for lunch during a bike ride between Fort Monroe and Buckroe. MillCreek was so accommodating and the food was great (as usual) Burgers, Wings, chicken sliders, onion rings! Great experience of impressing our friends with a super friendly side of Hampton! 😁
Ramona Hercules
Good food - reasonable prices - welcoming atmosphere
MAD MARY BURGER!!! Had this burger and it is a hamburger on top of POUTINE, covered in cheese and bacon. Friendly staff. Good simple menu with great options.
Sarah Black
If you are a local you will love it! It’s a place where they know your name and what you drink! Staff was awesome and food as crazy good! It’s a place you feel like you’re family.
Brian Monahan Jr.
Amazing staff. Friendly, courteous, knowledgeable, and attentive. The cooks are amazing, especially Brian. The food specials are next level! Highly recommended!!
I was visiting the Hampton area to medically oversee a boxing match and had had a strenuous day sitting in the blazing sun for 6 hours watching sites. I was exhausted a quiet cool place to calm down and eat. I randomly picked the Mill St Tavern and what a lucky pick. It's a small, nondescript building out of town. I went in and immediately felt better! It was kinda dark and cool. The hostess was adorable and courteous. I had steak bits as an appetizer which was a steak cut up into cubes. It was very tender and perfectly cooked. Entree was a triple decker club and tater tots. GREAT!!! Prices were reasonable, food was great, service and atmosphere was wonderful!!! I'd go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little dive bar beer was 3.25 August 2025
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
After scouring Google Maps for 30 minutes looking up various dive bars, I ended up gambling on Mill Creek Tavern.
Best decision ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has things that you would not know to eat at dinner time which is pretty healthy I was very surprised. Always pretty much a great atmosphere and prices not bad for this time of year
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Very friendly service food was good, we had wings, sliders with sweet potato fries, Cucumber salad and a fish sandwich. No mixer drinks just beer and wine
The restaurant is one level with an outside patio... Local hangout people knew each other.
Accepts cash and credit.
Salads available for vegetarians
Welcoming small town style bar, where everyone knows each other. Great food. Beer and wine level alcohol, no liquor.
Good food, good prices, down home atmosphere.
We took a large group of out of town guests there for lunch during a bike ride between Fort Monroe and Buckroe. MillCreek was so accommodating and the food was great (as usual) Burgers, Wings, chicken sliders, onion rings! Great experience of impressing our friends with a super friendly side of Hampton! 😁
Good food - reasonable prices - welcoming atmosphere
The perfect dive bar
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place to eat and socialize.
Great place to get a burger and beer!
MAD MARY BURGER!!! Had this burger and it is a hamburger on top of POUTINE, covered in cheese and bacon. Friendly staff. Good simple menu with great options.
If you are a local you will love it! It’s a place where they know your name and what you drink! Staff was awesome and food as crazy good! It’s a place you feel like you’re family.
Amazing staff. Friendly, courteous, knowledgeable, and attentive. The cooks are amazing, especially Brian. The food specials are next level! Highly recommended!!
Loading...