17 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“We were spending the night in Middletown and decided to The Italian Touch. It was delicious. I can't say it was the best I've ever had, but it was close.
I had the baked ziti, which is Plenty for two people. It came with a nice side salad and knot rolls that were so so good.
My husband got the lasagna and he said it was also good.
If we are ever back this way, I'd stop in again.“

“Had Easter dinner at Carrabba's/ 0226. Food was delicious and server (Janette C) did an outstanding job. She hustles and is focused on service, glad we were seated in her section.“

“Great Italian food, homemade pastas and wonderful list of red wines! Love Love the Spanish octopus, aioli, crushed potatoes!“

“Today my husband and I went to Romas and the food was wonderful as usual! Our waitress, Kelsey, was so sweet , genuine, and attentive, making our rare eating out an even more enjoyable time! Thank you Kelsey!“

“steak and cheese sub was a top 3 ever for me.“

“We’re accustomed to authentic Italian cuisine, and this place did not disappoint! We ordered the manicotti, baked ziti, chicken parmesan, and their meatballs — every dish was delicious, and the sauce was absolutely perfect. The salads were fresh, and everything came out at just the right time.

Our server, Ian, was helpful, attentive, and made the experience even better.

We’re disappointed we don’t live closer since we’re from out of town, but this restaurant is truly a hidden gem that we’ll remember. Highly recommend to anyone who loves genuine Italian food done right!“

“The food is excellent, everything on the menu is just wonderful. The music from the ceiling speakers could be turned DOWN a good bit.“

“Ive been going to Olive Garden for many years and have never had a better experience than as this olive garden. Our waiter Cam was outstanding. Honestly this review is primarily because of him and not the restaurant. He's that good! But overall great olive garden. Very large and it just looks nice inside. Food was great. Really enjoying that new calabrian pasta dish. Hope they can keep that full time on the menu. Don't worry, the picture on my review is not how it comes. I just got to excited when I got it, started eating it and forgot to take a picture. I ate about half of the dish at that point. Ask for Cam if you can, TRUST Me.“

“I've only eaten lunch here, but the pizza by the slice was delicious and my favorite lunch order is the Caesar salad with grilled chicken. Their grilled chicken is so flavorful and it's really grilled. It compliments the salad so well. I often crave that salad...and a salad is typically not something I would normally crave.“

“Was delighted to discover this little haven. Quality surpassed most other local Italian eateries yet prices were very fair! We'll be back!“

“The sauce was awesome and the gluten free pizza was delicious“

“Didn’t expect to find such great pizza when our truck broke down in the middle of who knows where. The kindest waitress and a fantastic pizza.“

“Quickly delivered an amazing pizza to the Marriott. Would recommend trying if you are in the area.“

“My daughter brought me a cheese steak to my home in Alexandria and I was like OMG this is awesome.....she told me it was a place in Winchester called Claudio's, well I told her that it is worth a trip for me to travel for such an awesome cheese steak and this was a 2 hr old one at that!! I made the trip this past Sunday with my grandson and stopped into Claudio's, the food, cheesesteak's awesome, onion rings were crispy and flavorful, service was kind, friendly and helpful. The manager on duty was awesome, I told him I traveled from Alexandria just to dine at the Pizzeria and he made sure that we enjoyed are visit! Thank you Claudio's and we will be sure to visit again very soon.“

“Best pizza ever 😍 I eat here all the time because I work at the mall!“

“Rica comida italiana a buen precio , porciones , grandes y un buen servicio al cliente …. Quede encantada de este lugar“

“It’s always so nice having a meal at Ledo’s. The staff and owner are always so nice and personable and the food is so good. Pizza, a salad and a diet Dr Pepper for me usually but I can’t wait to try the wings! I’ve heard they’re really good!!“