Mayberry Pizzeria and Icecream

One of the worst Chicago style pizzas I've ever had. They just stacked two pies together, filled the center, and threw sauce on top. What in the world!? It still had my intrigued... But no flavor. Would never go back. Also tried the ice cream. That was better, but about average. It was very sweet... They said it was local homemade ice cream, but the container said Blue Bunny right on it. I guess this place is faking it to make it. Sad to have to write a review like this. Pictures prove I'm not making this up.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

We stopped in to get icecream & Nikki was very sweet. She has a very warm/friendly personality and definitely made it a great experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Previously had had pizza from here that was awful. Decided to give another chance & order something different. Had to leave before order arrived. Accidentally dropped my card. Got charged anyway. Went back to collect my card but wouldn't refund. Later I called & had to make a second trip to get refund.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

I don't know who cooked my pizza, but it was terrible. The crust was hard in some places and soft in others. When I picked up a slice it fell apart in my hands. Usually the pizza there is great but not this time. If the main cook leaves I will never go back.

Absolutely the best pizza and wings BY FAR in this area. Coming down from New York we struggled to find good pizza.
Juan is a great chef and also very nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza! Fast, friendly service. I was a little afraid to try it since they just opened but the food and service was great! Unfortunately have to edit the review. Pizza seems to have changed since they first opened. Still ok but not as good as before.

Their hours state until 9, so at 8 we headed the 30 min out to get some ice cream. When we arrived at 830 they were inside cleaning and doors locked. What a waste of time and gas. Disappointed!!

Took my four year old here for the first time two weeks ago. We had the deep dish Sicilian and by gosh was it delish! It was an experience we won’t forget. Between the quality of the food and the service, Mr. Juan turned first time customers into customers for life ? We finished our dine in experience with a chocolate milk shake to go. A little on the pricy side but oh so mouth watering!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas and More, Milkshakes Malts & Floats

My family flew in from Florida and we stumbled upon this place to eat dinner and we were NOT disappointed. The recipes are all homemade and their meat lovers pizza was loaded and delicious. If we ever come back to visit we’re making this our place to dine again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent pizza!!! We ordered a "take and bake" pizza and it was the best!!! Bake at home and it was so hot and fresh. Definitely ordering again soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I were in a hurry on Sunday evening to make an appt and the owner of Mayberry Pizzeria did everything he could to get our sandwiches out quickly and get us on our way. The Philly Cheese Steak was great! And customer service was exceptional! We will be going back again to try the pizza.

Great pizza!

Looking for a Gluten free pizza? Definitely stop at Mayberry Pizzeria awesome crust and delicious sauce.

Pretty cool little place to stop in for some hand dipped ice cream.

My wife and two sons came for ice cream. This is a small business with hand dipped Hershey ice cream. We got a banana split for our oldest son. We got a smaller banana split and two sundaes. Very good treat. Our server was very friendly and helpful. We really appreciate the great service.