Schlesinger's Steakhouse

1106 William Styron Square S, Newport News
(757) 599-4700

Recent Reviews

Beth Brooks

Enjoyed dinner from our drinks, appetizer, salads to entrees. Quality of food was very good. Had a great waiter too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Salad

Dirk Todd Jones

We went there for Sunday brunch. The wait staff was amazing, super friendly, professional, and very good at their jobs. The ambiance was good, they had live music, a guitarist playing easy listening tunes. The food is ok, but def not worthy of $45 for the buffet. I thought the bacon and the desserts were pretty good. Unfortunately, the rest... The sausages were like the frozen sausages from the grocery aisle. The home fries were meh. The cheese plate was nothing great; a weak American cheddar and some other bland off the shelf cheeses. I was so unimpressed by the spread that I decided to get an easy win: an omelette. However, how can you mess up an omelette? Don't put enough fixings on it. The omelette was basically folded over eggs with so little else it was also disappointing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Monica Arr.

Bring your own seasoning. Our steaks were cooked perfectly but lacked seasoning…same for the vegetables. Overall we liked our food but we don’t feel like Schlesinger’s lived up to the hype.We were sat in a side room off the main dining area. The tables seemed close but didn’t feel cramped. If you’re thinking that you need to dress up for this restaurant, I don’t think you need to. The decor isn’t super upscale. Jeans and a nice top would work.I don’t think we’ll be returning to Schlesinger’s. It was decent but definitely not worth the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Steak, Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Momo Hlaing

One of the best places to meet friends, family, or business associates.Service is impeccable; food is amazing in taste, quality, and presentation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris B

Great restaurant, with very attentive staff. Food was amazing, if in the area do not hesitate to come to Schlesinger's steakhouse... oh btw.. they have amazing seafood too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes, Steak, Calamari Frita, Seafood Bisque, Steak Schlesinger, Porterhouse

Tara Driggers

This is where you go to get the best drinks and some of the best tasting food in the area! Courtney was fabulous and her recommendations were spot on! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bananas Foster Cheesecake

KevinG

Another great dinner at Schlesinger's. We had the caramel pecan brie as an appetizer. The wife had an 8 oz filet and I had the boneless ribeye. We shared a side of creamed spinach. Everything was cooked as requested and was excellent! A great place to go for a special occasion or just a fine dining experience!

Tish

The meals were absolutely delicious! Our waitress, Hannah, was so attentive/polite and assisted us in making our final meal choices! My Cobb salad with the fresh seafood was an excellent choice - the presentation was so eye appealing that I knew this meal was more than sufficient! Thank you for such a pleasant luncheon experience!

freeman51868

The Sunday brunch was excellent, many choices...really

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Salad, Seafood Trio, Tenderloin Medallions, Entrees, Bananas Foster Cheesecake

KarenNotThatKaren

Old favourite of mine - haven't been there in years. Returned for a birthday celebration dinner. Like everywhere else right now, prices have gone WAY up and the portions have gone down a little. I ordered a Steak Oscar which used to come with a ice cream-sized scoop of lump crab on it, now comes with a smattering of lump crab (basically a garnish). Still VERY good and lovely place to eat, just grossly inflated prices now.

Jerry034

We had the lamb chops and filet. Food was amazing as always. What we absolutely love about Schlesinger's is the constant emphasis on quality and service which makes the dining experience so memorable. Our waitress Kristen was awesome. Had the house Cabernet, Tiramisu for dessert with coffee. Everything was superb. Thanks again for a fine dining experience.

BrittanyP

I originally made a reservation for 2, but called the day before going to add 2 more people and it was done for me with no issues. The place smells fantastic right when you walk in and tables aren't too close together so you and your party have privacy. Most amazing steak I've ever had. Experience was 10/10 as well as service.

T P

A recent experience led me to leave a 1 star review. I still think the manager on duty and the server did a poor job of handling a bad situation. Blaming patrons is never wise or helpful. I am editing my review following a heartfelt conversation with management. The restaurant is concerned with quality both in the food and in the customer experience. I hope to give them another try and hopefully have a better experience.

Kendall Dolan

Super disappointed in our dinner here. My husband and I each got steak and my filet was over cooked and flavorless and his ribeye was all fat. The service was fine, but they upcharged us for every little thing without telling us that it cost extra. We ended up paying $6 to add a couple slivers of onion on my steak and $13 for water for the two of us. Seriously??? Both at the recommendation of our waitress who didn’t mention there was an upcharge. We paid over $200 dollars on dinner for two to end up dissatisfied. This place was not nearly worth the value for the amount you pay. You’d be way better off driving 30 minutes to Le Yaca if you’re looking for a good dinner. We won’t be back here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Raquel Palmer

Steak Schlesinger's is amazing!

Load More