The pizza was impressive and the staff was friendly. I’ll be trying the pasta next.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Zach Heng
Tony's NY Pizza is a slice of heaven for those in search of authentic, mouthwatering pizza and a myriad of Italian delights. This isn't just a pizza shop; it's a taste of New York's pizza tradition with a side trip to Italy, all without leaving Fairfax. With great service and a casual, welcoming vibe, Tony's invites you to kick back, relax, and prepare your taste buds for a journey they won't soon forget.Our pizza pilgrimage began with the Margherita Special, a testament to the power of simplicity. With fresh tomato sauce, sumptuous fresh mozzarella, a drizzle of olive oil, and a sprinkle of basil, this pizza is a love letter to Naples. Each bite is a reminder that when it comes to pizza, sometimes less truly is more.Next up, the Sicilian-style Tony's Special took us on a detour to the bustling streets of Palermo. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions, this thick, square-cut masterpiece is as hearty as it is delicious. It's the kind of pizza that doesn't just fill your stomach; it warms your soul.For the carnivores among us, the Meat Lovers pizza is a dream come true. Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, and bacon come together in a carnivalesque celebration of all things meat. It's a meaty marvel that's so good, it might just convert vegetarians back to the dark (and delicious) side.But Tony's NY Pizza isn't just about pizzas. The Antipasto Italiano is a colorful cavalcade of Italian staples, served with a side of garlic bread that's worth writing home about. The Linguini Alla Posillipo, with its tender clams, mussels, squid, and shrimp in light marinara, transports you to the Amalfi coast with every forkful. And for those who fancy a creamier fare, the Fettucine Mediterraneo, with its luxurious combination of jumbo shrimp, scallops, and crab meat, is like a first-class ticket to culinary bliss.Not to be outdone, the Chicken Parmigiano and Chicken Brunello offer a poultry paradise, while the Ziti Pie turns traditional pasta on its head in the best possible way. The Steak & Cheese Sub is an homage to the classic Philly tradition, served with non-traditional trimmings. While not my favorite of our visit, it's still a solid choice.Dessert at Tony's is the cherry on top of an already fabulous meal. Whether you choose the airy Tiramisu, the classic Cannoli, or the innovative Donut with cannoli filling, each sweet treat is a perfect punctuation mark to a satisfying meal.In essence, Tony's NY Pizza is more than a pizza shop; it's a veritable treasure trove of Italian and New York flavors, served with a side of warmth and welcome. So, if you find yourself in Oakton with a craving for something truly special, make your way to Tony's. It's an experience that's sure to leave you saying, "That's amore!"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Margherita Special
Abdullah Altabtabaei
I enjoyed the cheese steak so much, I had it 2 days in a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kyle J.
Go-to pizza place. The eggplant parm pizza is our favorite, but the others are good too. I tend to like pizzas that clearly have sauce and where the sauce is a little sweeter, which Tony's appears to do well.
Eydie Q.
Really fast and quick service. Ordered the hot Italian sub. Their bread is so good warm. I dined in and this is weird but I loved their mixing of the soda fountain. Perfect ratio of carbonation and syrup. Will definitely come back.
Chris C.
Our family orders from here every Wednesday and the kids love it. Cheesesteaks, tenders and pizza. 5stars.
Liz H.
This is the place for pizza by the slice!! Hard to find really good pizza by the slice but this is the place!! Looking for fresh made entrees? These are made fresh after your order. Give it a try, you won't regret it. Most folks complain about the wait but it is worth it. Do yourself a favor and order in advance.
Tony H.
The best pizza in northern Virginia opened a store in Oakton? No way! Same great food and service you get at the Fair Lakes store, but now in Oakton!! Never heard of it? This is where you go for NY pizza by the slice. When I want to impress someone with pizza, Tony's is the place to go. Feels like the pizza joints in NYC except a lot cleaner. I love this place! For a different type of pie, try your favorite Sicilian style. Try it once and you'll be back. Trust me.
Omar Elorza
It's alright, heard the pizza was supposed to be amazing, well I think k maybe the workers in the back were just rude. Not sure what the deal was and it probably ruined the experience.
This is a solid neighborhood spot. I think it deserves more love than its 3-star rating at the moment. Planning on visiting again whenever we want non-delivery pizza in Oakton. Food: B New York style pizza and the usual menu items from a casual Italian restaurant. We ordered mozzarella sticks and a whole pepperoni pizza. I had low expectations but the mozzarella sticks were very good! Coated in batter, not bread crumbs. The outside was crispy and flavorful and the inside was perfectly gooey. The tomato sauce for dipping was clearly freshly made. Pizza was good. I wasn't expecting Wolfgang Puck, and it hit the spot since it was right out of the oven. Service: B Cashier was a nice guy. Stood by the cash register patiently as we perused the menu. Brought out our food promptly to our table. Ambiance: B Clean and basic. No frills, charm or character but fits the bill of a basic pizzeria. Seems that given the decor, this is probably mainly a takeout place.
James P.
Pretty good pizza and hot subs. We come here pretty often when we want to actually eat in. We find ourselves coming here more often now that Church Street moved and doesn't really offer eat-in options anymore.
M P.
The only good thing I can say about the pizza is they delivered quicker than they said and it was still hot
Jack Belden
Is this what you call a meat lovers
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Luis Carrero
Oakton's hidden gem! Tony’s NY style authentic Italian pizza place has become the heartbeat of the community. From the moment you step in, the aroma of fresh, quality ingredients embraces you. Each slice tells a tale of craftsmanship and passion and the pasta, suns and salads are amazing! The staff feels like family, and the ambiance is as inviting as the flavors are delightful. A true 5-star experience that Oakton is fortunate to savor!
Great salad!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The pizza was impressive and the staff was friendly. I’ll be trying the pasta next.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tony's NY Pizza is a slice of heaven for those in search of authentic, mouthwatering pizza and a myriad of Italian delights. This isn't just a pizza shop; it's a taste of New York's pizza tradition with a side trip to Italy, all without leaving Fairfax. With great service and a casual, welcoming vibe, Tony's invites you to kick back, relax, and prepare your taste buds for a journey they won't soon forget.Our pizza pilgrimage began with the Margherita Special, a testament to the power of simplicity. With fresh tomato sauce, sumptuous fresh mozzarella, a drizzle of olive oil, and a sprinkle of basil, this pizza is a love letter to Naples. Each bite is a reminder that when it comes to pizza, sometimes less truly is more.Next up, the Sicilian-style Tony's Special took us on a detour to the bustling streets of Palermo. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions, this thick, square-cut masterpiece is as hearty as it is delicious. It's the kind of pizza that doesn't just fill your stomach; it warms your soul.For the carnivores among us, the Meat Lovers pizza is a dream come true. Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef, and bacon come together in a carnivalesque celebration of all things meat. It's a meaty marvel that's so good, it might just convert vegetarians back to the dark (and delicious) side.But Tony's NY Pizza isn't just about pizzas. The Antipasto Italiano is a colorful cavalcade of Italian staples, served with a side of garlic bread that's worth writing home about. The Linguini Alla Posillipo, with its tender clams, mussels, squid, and shrimp in light marinara, transports you to the Amalfi coast with every forkful. And for those who fancy a creamier fare, the Fettucine Mediterraneo, with its luxurious combination of jumbo shrimp, scallops, and crab meat, is like a first-class ticket to culinary bliss.Not to be outdone, the Chicken Parmigiano and Chicken Brunello offer a poultry paradise, while the Ziti Pie turns traditional pasta on its head in the best possible way. The Steak & Cheese Sub is an homage to the classic Philly tradition, served with non-traditional trimmings. While not my favorite of our visit, it's still a solid choice.Dessert at Tony's is the cherry on top of an already fabulous meal. Whether you choose the airy Tiramisu, the classic Cannoli, or the innovative Donut with cannoli filling, each sweet treat is a perfect punctuation mark to a satisfying meal.In essence, Tony's NY Pizza is more than a pizza shop; it's a veritable treasure trove of Italian and New York flavors, served with a side of warmth and welcome. So, if you find yourself in Oakton with a craving for something truly special, make your way to Tony's. It's an experience that's sure to leave you saying, "That's amore!"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Margherita Special
I enjoyed the cheese steak so much, I had it 2 days in a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Go-to pizza place. The eggplant parm pizza is our favorite, but the others are good too. I tend to like pizzas that clearly have sauce and where the sauce is a little sweeter, which Tony's appears to do well.
Really fast and quick service. Ordered the hot Italian sub. Their bread is so good warm. I dined in and this is weird but I loved their mixing of the soda fountain. Perfect ratio of carbonation and syrup. Will definitely come back.
Our family orders from here every Wednesday and the kids love it. Cheesesteaks, tenders and pizza. 5stars.
This is the place for pizza by the slice!! Hard to find really good pizza by the slice but this is the place!! Looking for fresh made entrees? These are made fresh after your order. Give it a try, you won't regret it. Most folks complain about the wait but it is worth it. Do yourself a favor and order in advance.
The best pizza in northern Virginia opened a store in Oakton? No way! Same great food and service you get at the Fair Lakes store, but now in Oakton!! Never heard of it? This is where you go for NY pizza by the slice. When I want to impress someone with pizza, Tony's is the place to go. Feels like the pizza joints in NYC except a lot cleaner. I love this place! For a different type of pie, try your favorite Sicilian style. Try it once and you'll be back. Trust me.
It's alright, heard the pizza was supposed to be amazing, well I think k maybe the workers in the back were just rude. Not sure what the deal was and it probably ruined the experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a solid neighborhood spot. I think it deserves more love than its 3-star rating at the moment. Planning on visiting again whenever we want non-delivery pizza in Oakton. Food: B New York style pizza and the usual menu items from a casual Italian restaurant. We ordered mozzarella sticks and a whole pepperoni pizza. I had low expectations but the mozzarella sticks were very good! Coated in batter, not bread crumbs. The outside was crispy and flavorful and the inside was perfectly gooey. The tomato sauce for dipping was clearly freshly made. Pizza was good. I wasn't expecting Wolfgang Puck, and it hit the spot since it was right out of the oven. Service: B Cashier was a nice guy. Stood by the cash register patiently as we perused the menu. Brought out our food promptly to our table. Ambiance: B Clean and basic. No frills, charm or character but fits the bill of a basic pizzeria. Seems that given the decor, this is probably mainly a takeout place.
Pretty good pizza and hot subs. We come here pretty often when we want to actually eat in. We find ourselves coming here more often now that Church Street moved and doesn't really offer eat-in options anymore.
The only good thing I can say about the pizza is they delivered quicker than they said and it was still hot
Is this what you call a meat lovers
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Oakton's hidden gem! Tony’s NY style authentic Italian pizza place has become the heartbeat of the community. From the moment you step in, the aroma of fresh, quality ingredients embraces you. Each slice tells a tale of craftsmanship and passion and the pasta, suns and salads are amazing! The staff feels like family, and the ambiance is as inviting as the flavors are delightful. A true 5-star experience that Oakton is fortunate to savor!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5