Best broiled seafood platter I have ever consumed! It was well worth its price. A large and tasty portion of flounder, scallops, shrimp and crab cake all seasoned and cooked perfectly. The onion rings were also the best ever!
Jason Deloge
Awesome.......best seafood dinner had in long time.......I had fried flounder and shrimp platter...fries fresh cut .... and side salad added blue cheese crumbles and bacon.... divine......destiny was great server fun gave us lots help and great personality...... hope everyone has a lunch/dinner once in there lifetime......Jason from north Carolina visiting colonial Williamsburg for week....
Wayne Hulstine
I drive a school Bus for Poquoson, and stopped for lunch. It was my first time eating at Capt Herrells, but definitely won't be my last. The service was great and the atmosphere was very nice, clean and quiet. The fresh caught flounder sandwich and fresh cut fries were fantastic ? my compliments.
Steffie A.
I went in here, because people said it was good. I love me some good seafood. The place looked clean. It was dinner time and it was getting semi busy. They sat us down, and we waited for a waitress. It felt like 15 min before she could get our drink order, and by that time we were ready to order. We placed our orders when she took our drink orders. I brought my two kids and my husband. My kids got chicken tenders, fries, and Mac and Cheese. For me I ordered oysters and shrimp. My husband ordered just shrimp. We waited almost an hour for our food, which to me is unacceptable. I understand restaurants are struggling...but all I ask is communication. I can understand why my baby started throwing a tantrum. He had been waiting awhile, and he was hungry. Every time we asked our waitress what was going on she said she would check...and three times she said it will be right up. I was not ok with this. Then we actually received the food. After waiting at least the food was hot, but I was disappointed in the food. It was terrible. The Mac and cheese was flavorless, the batter on the shrimp was terrible and was extremely greasy, the fries were also super greasy...my kids thought the chicken tenders were good, but looking at previous food pics..mour tenders did not look like how they were supposed to look. Ours were just bleh, but my kids were hungry so they ate it. However, I did enjoy the oysters. I know this business must have had a bad day...and they have potential to improve, but everything that happened put me off. I'll eventually come back, but not anytime soon, and hopefully things will be better.
Jennifer Infante
Food and service was great. My crab cake was well broiled and the fries were great. We visited during off peak hours, and our experience felt intimate and special. Thanks for a tasty quick meal as we wrapped up our visit!
Roberto M.
Excellent flounder sandwich, hush puppies, and friendly staff! Highly recommended, looking forward to going back next week!
Christopher Brace
I love that I can get a seafood platter without shrimp. Food was excellent and the portions very generous.
Charles Moss
The food and service were very good. But the dining area inside sounded like a high school gym during a pep rally. Inescapable loudness everywhere.
Cindy Carter
Sister in law and I visited Capt.Harrells today. She had the flounder sandwich. I had the catfish sandwich. We had french fries with both. Both sandwickes were GREAT. Very large portion of flounder on her sandwich. Ashley our server was on top of everything and very pleasant. We will go back.
Miranda Streiler
Walking in it is very clean and has a nice atmosphere.We ordered fish tacos which tasted so fresh! The oysters were also a hit. My son ordered the burger which was a little dry BUT this isn't a burger place, it is fresh seafood so it gets a pass! We recommend all of our out of town visitors to give it a try!
I ate here for the first time. The broiled crab cake was fabulous, the fries were hand-cut and delicious.The waiter was so accommodating, friendly and efficient. I will definitely return and bring others.
Alicia S.
I love everything there. I moved to Atlanta and my daughter brings me crab cakes. Soo soo good!!
Mike Plessinger
A wonderful place for fantastic food with awesome service!
Shawn Gorman
Just discovered this gem last night. The staff was super friendly and the seafood was the freshest I've had in the area. We ordered about 1/4 of the entire menu and everything was perfect.
John Payne
Had a great experience! The food is on point, and the service is perfect. Great selection for cocktails and local beer, the dinner specials work. We will be back.
Best broiled seafood platter I have ever consumed! It was well worth its price. A large and tasty portion of flounder, scallops, shrimp and crab cake all seasoned and cooked perfectly. The onion rings were also the best ever!
Awesome.......best seafood dinner had in long time.......I had fried flounder and shrimp platter...fries fresh cut .... and side salad added blue cheese crumbles and bacon.... divine......destiny was great server fun gave us lots help and great personality...... hope everyone has a lunch/dinner once in there lifetime......Jason from north Carolina visiting colonial Williamsburg for week....
I drive a school Bus for Poquoson, and stopped for lunch. It was my first time eating at Capt Herrells, but definitely won't be my last. The service was great and the atmosphere was very nice, clean and quiet. The fresh caught flounder sandwich and fresh cut fries were fantastic ? my compliments.
I went in here, because people said it was good. I love me some good seafood. The place looked clean. It was dinner time and it was getting semi busy. They sat us down, and we waited for a waitress. It felt like 15 min before she could get our drink order, and by that time we were ready to order. We placed our orders when she took our drink orders. I brought my two kids and my husband. My kids got chicken tenders, fries, and Mac and Cheese. For me I ordered oysters and shrimp. My husband ordered just shrimp. We waited almost an hour for our food, which to me is unacceptable. I understand restaurants are struggling...but all I ask is communication. I can understand why my baby started throwing a tantrum. He had been waiting awhile, and he was hungry. Every time we asked our waitress what was going on she said she would check...and three times she said it will be right up. I was not ok with this. Then we actually received the food. After waiting at least the food was hot, but I was disappointed in the food. It was terrible. The Mac and cheese was flavorless, the batter on the shrimp was terrible and was extremely greasy, the fries were also super greasy...my kids thought the chicken tenders were good, but looking at previous food pics..mour tenders did not look like how they were supposed to look. Ours were just bleh, but my kids were hungry so they ate it. However, I did enjoy the oysters. I know this business must have had a bad day...and they have potential to improve, but everything that happened put me off. I'll eventually come back, but not anytime soon, and hopefully things will be better.
Food and service was great. My crab cake was well broiled and the fries were great. We visited during off peak hours, and our experience felt intimate and special. Thanks for a tasty quick meal as we wrapped up our visit!
Excellent flounder sandwich, hush puppies, and friendly staff! Highly recommended, looking forward to going back next week!
I love that I can get a seafood platter without shrimp. Food was excellent and the portions very generous.
The food and service were very good. But the dining area inside sounded like a high school gym during a pep rally. Inescapable loudness everywhere.
Sister in law and I visited Capt.Harrells today. She had the flounder sandwich. I had the catfish sandwich. We had french fries with both. Both sandwickes were GREAT. Very large portion of flounder on her sandwich. Ashley our server was on top of everything and very pleasant. We will go back.
Walking in it is very clean and has a nice atmosphere.We ordered fish tacos which tasted so fresh! The oysters were also a hit. My son ordered the burger which was a little dry BUT this isn't a burger place, it is fresh seafood so it gets a pass! We recommend all of our out of town visitors to give it a try!
Restaurantji Recommends
I ate here for the first time. The broiled crab cake was fabulous, the fries were hand-cut and delicious.The waiter was so accommodating, friendly and efficient. I will definitely return and bring others.
I love everything there. I moved to Atlanta and my daughter brings me crab cakes. Soo soo good!!
A wonderful place for fantastic food with awesome service!
Just discovered this gem last night. The staff was super friendly and the seafood was the freshest I've had in the area. We ordered about 1/4 of the entire menu and everything was perfect.
Had a great experience! The food is on point, and the service is perfect. Great selection for cocktails and local beer, the dinner specials work. We will be back.