Unfortunately I may never know if this is really a good pizza place. Waited over 30 minutes after calling in the order for a pick up pizza. The first pizza I was handed was not mine, I checked. Still had to wait a bit longer for “mine”, which was also wrong, toppings on the wrong side, etc. I almost left with it, but then thought it was unfair TO ME to be charged over $34, for the wrong pizza AND wasting my time. When I asked for a refund or a coupon of some sort, it sounded like I was being offered (the right) complimentary pizza on another day- “just call it in and ask for Milton”. But then she took the one pizza I did have today away….????? So, I’m expected to call in again, on another day, wait some more and hope I get the right pizza that I already paid for? How is that fair? I think it’s only fair to at least try to show your customers some sort of ‘appreciation for their time’ if you charge high, get it wrong AND make them wait longer than promised. Maybe that’s just me…
Service: 1
James Taylor
Great food, even greater operator/owner. My go to place for all food...
Best pizza in Quinton!! Friendly family owned environment and we order from here regularly. I always request the pizza with no corn meal on the bottom and the owner is gracious enough to do it. They also have great appetizers and salads!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Garlic Knots, Tiramisu, White Pizza with Feta Cheese, Salad, White Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Casey G
We have been in Quinton for a couple years and I've waited to make this review. I waited to hopefully have my review carry the weight of that time and experience. Miltons is consistently good quality, food and service. Over several orders, various spots in their menu, we're happy to continue patronizing Milton's for our favorites and look forward to finding more must haves. Pizza, subs, calamari, pasta, salads. It's all great.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Garlic Knots, Milton Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Fried Calamari, Sausage, Lasagna, Tiramisu, Salad, White Pizza, Pepperoni Roll, Steak, Cheese Pizza, Pizza Steak Sub, Italian Sub, Onion Rings, New York Giant Pizza
John Fleming
I had Milton's pizza one time a few years ago and I don't really remember how it was. Today we ordered a large, extra cheese pizza.Wait time was about 30 minutes or so, and we enjoyed a white claw from the convenience store at the gas station right next door while we waited.Took the pizza home, and I thought it was excellent. It was cooked correctly, the crust was really nice and it had a lot of cheese on it the way I like it.I'm usually a fan of Brothers Pizza in Providence Forge, but I would say Milton's has definitely pulled ahead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Mike Joyce
The food never disappoints. I had a medium cheese pizza and an order of garlic knots 4 meatballs. Their tiramisu sells out quickly. Family ate the whole thing. Food is fresh and delicious.
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pineapple Bacon Pizza, French Fries, Sausage, Salad, Steak, Italian Sub, Onion Rings
Kirby Gong
Popped in for a quick bite. Took about 15 min to get 4 slices and some onion rings. Food was good with generous portions, prices were very fair. Just a note: only outdoor seating available right now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Onion Rings
Equana Bailey
My go to for
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jonathan T.
Tried this place as we were traveling back home. I prefer the large pepperoni pizza and a large cheesesteak. Price was pretty decent only spent about 30 bucks on the whole order plus the tip I left Pizza was pretty good, I would say your regular by slice type pizza. Good dough, crust was good had nice cheesy bite and the sauce was flavorful. Cheesesteak was pretty bland but decent enough for the price. When I walked in there was a man at the front he simply looked up then back down didn't greet me, I even said, " what's up man, how you doing". No response, then his son came to take my order. Unfortunately I watched the lady throw my bread in the oven with no gloves on so it was immediately a let down. Also I asked for napkins since we were eating in the car and they had none available. At least the son couldn't find any. You usually eat pizza with your hands so having napkins is a must. I would give this place another chance I know they are trying pretty hard and looks family owned. Customer service is extremely important. So I would recommend working on that. Not the kid though, he did his best more so the adults in there. The shop is connected to a gas station and there is one table inside for people to eat and a couple benches outside. Overall I would order the pizza again if I lived in the area and give them another shot at customer service. They should invest in gloves and napkins. Respectfully
The pizza is fantastic, reminds me of living in the New York area. The other food I don't quite feel is made with the same passion. But I'm a bit of an Italian food snob.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Robin W.
This was the worst pizza we ever tried to eat! Dry, overcooked, very little cheese or sauce! They only have specialty pizzas on menu online. When I called store to ask if we ask for pizza with toppings we liked, they said we could but not available for delivery! Picked up large pizza with 4 toppings = $31. & they expected a tip! No ambiance at all or seating, except outside. It was not edible. So glad there is at least a Pizza Hut in this town... hate to write a bad review, but money is too important these days & we would gladly pay that for a real pizza. Nothing Italian or authentic about this round burnt dry thing!
Frankie Hernandez
I truly enjoy good tasting crusts and sauce that compliment the rest of the topping. It's one of those that you can't stop eating. Pizza, Stromboli, you can't go wrong. I always order takeout. The service is very personal they'll continue seeing me a few time a week. Try it, you'll like it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Robert Partin
Family run business with exceptional food and everyone is friendly and helpful. I would highly recommend them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon Anderson
First time eating here and I enjoyed the Gluten-free pizza very much!Spoke with the owner and he is a super nice man who takes pride in his work!!Can't wait to try the lasagna next time I return.Thank you
Unfortunately I may never know if this is really a good pizza place. Waited over 30 minutes after calling in the order for a pick up pizza. The first pizza I was handed was not mine, I checked. Still had to wait a bit longer for “mine”, which was also wrong, toppings on the wrong side, etc. I almost left with it, but then thought it was unfair TO ME to be charged over $34, for the wrong pizza AND wasting my time. When I asked for a refund or a coupon of some sort, it sounded like I was being offered (the right) complimentary pizza on another day- “just call it in and ask for Milton”. But then she took the one pizza I did have today away….????? So, I’m expected to call in again, on another day, wait some more and hope I get the right pizza that I already paid for? How is that fair? I think it’s only fair to at least try to show your customers some sort of ‘appreciation for their time’ if you charge high, get it wrong AND make them wait longer than promised. Maybe that’s just me…
Service: 1
Great food, even greater operator/owner. My go to place for all food...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in Quinton!! Friendly family owned environment and we order from here regularly. I always request the pizza with no corn meal on the bottom and the owner is gracious enough to do it. They also have great appetizers and salads!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Garlic Knots, Tiramisu, White Pizza with Feta Cheese, Salad, White Pizza, Cheese Pizza
We have been in Quinton for a couple years and I've waited to make this review. I waited to hopefully have my review carry the weight of that time and experience. Miltons is consistently good quality, food and service. Over several orders, various spots in their menu, we're happy to continue patronizing Milton's for our favorites and look forward to finding more must haves. Pizza, subs, calamari, pasta, salads. It's all great.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Garlic Knots, Milton Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Fried Calamari, Sausage, Lasagna, Tiramisu, Salad, White Pizza, Pepperoni Roll, Steak, Cheese Pizza, Pizza Steak Sub, Italian Sub, Onion Rings, New York Giant Pizza
I had Milton's pizza one time a few years ago and I don't really remember how it was. Today we ordered a large, extra cheese pizza.Wait time was about 30 minutes or so, and we enjoyed a white claw from the convenience store at the gas station right next door while we waited.Took the pizza home, and I thought it was excellent. It was cooked correctly, the crust was really nice and it had a lot of cheese on it the way I like it.I'm usually a fan of Brothers Pizza in Providence Forge, but I would say Milton's has definitely pulled ahead.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
The food never disappoints. I had a medium cheese pizza and an order of garlic knots 4 meatballs. Their tiramisu sells out quickly. Family ate the whole thing. Food is fresh and delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Lasagna, Tiramisu
Cozy intimate pizza place. Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pineapple Bacon Pizza, French Fries, Sausage, Salad, Steak, Italian Sub, Onion Rings
Popped in for a quick bite. Took about 15 min to get 4 slices and some onion rings. Food was good with generous portions, prices were very fair. Just a note: only outdoor seating available right now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Onion Rings
My go to for
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tried this place as we were traveling back home. I prefer the large pepperoni pizza and a large cheesesteak. Price was pretty decent only spent about 30 bucks on the whole order plus the tip I left Pizza was pretty good, I would say your regular by slice type pizza. Good dough, crust was good had nice cheesy bite and the sauce was flavorful. Cheesesteak was pretty bland but decent enough for the price. When I walked in there was a man at the front he simply looked up then back down didn't greet me, I even said, " what's up man, how you doing". No response, then his son came to take my order. Unfortunately I watched the lady throw my bread in the oven with no gloves on so it was immediately a let down. Also I asked for napkins since we were eating in the car and they had none available. At least the son couldn't find any. You usually eat pizza with your hands so having napkins is a must. I would give this place another chance I know they are trying pretty hard and looks family owned. Customer service is extremely important. So I would recommend working on that. Not the kid though, he did his best more so the adults in there. The shop is connected to a gas station and there is one table inside for people to eat and a couple benches outside. Overall I would order the pizza again if I lived in the area and give them another shot at customer service. They should invest in gloves and napkins. Respectfully
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza is fantastic, reminds me of living in the New York area. The other food I don't quite feel is made with the same passion. But I'm a bit of an Italian food snob.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
This was the worst pizza we ever tried to eat! Dry, overcooked, very little cheese or sauce! They only have specialty pizzas on menu online. When I called store to ask if we ask for pizza with toppings we liked, they said we could but not available for delivery! Picked up large pizza with 4 toppings = $31. & they expected a tip! No ambiance at all or seating, except outside. It was not edible. So glad there is at least a Pizza Hut in this town... hate to write a bad review, but money is too important these days & we would gladly pay that for a real pizza. Nothing Italian or authentic about this round burnt dry thing!
I truly enjoy good tasting crusts and sauce that compliment the rest of the topping. It's one of those that you can't stop eating. Pizza, Stromboli, you can't go wrong. I always order takeout. The service is very personal they'll continue seeing me a few time a week. Try it, you'll like it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Family run business with exceptional food and everyone is friendly and helpful. I would highly recommend them!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time eating here and I enjoyed the Gluten-free pizza very much!Spoke with the owner and he is a super nice man who takes pride in his work!!Can't wait to try the lasagna next time I return.Thank you
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5