Poor Georgie's Bake Shoppe

George made a DELICIOUS apple pie for me! I needed an apple pie for a birthday celebration that was happening on a Sunday evening. George made the pie on Sunday morning and drove to the West End to deliver the pie to me that afternoon. It was still WARM! Everyone at the party LOVED the pie. It was the best apple pie I have ever had! He used three different types of apples and they were wonderful. The crust was unbelievable! I ordered the "monstrous butter crust" topping and...read full review

We recently ordered a peach pie with crumble topping from Poor Georgie’s and it is not an exaggeration to say it was the best peach pie I’ve ever had in my life. I’m serious, people. You cannot go wrong with this little shop. Other desserts we’ve tried are the oatmeal cream pies, lemon bars, and lemon pound cake and they are all amazing.

Update: the double Dutch chocolate cake is OUT OF THIS WORLD.

👉Just wanted to say, belated but still important, I ordered a key lime pie from Poor Georgie's Bakery for father's day for my husband and I was kind of skeptical. I needed it to be dairy free, and in my experience, dairy free usually means gross. Boy, was I wrong!! That key lime pie made pie from Key West look bad!! It. Was. AMAZING. There are no pictures because it was not around for very long! I also ordered some cakes, cookies and lemon bars. All of which were delicious....read full review