This woman is nothing short of amazing! I got a cake made by her for my daughter's 10th birthday and it has been the best one yet! I told her was that I wanted a capybara cake, my daughter's favorite color is blue, and she could do whatever she wanted. I was thinking for the price, I'll probably get some cute capybara sticker on the cake with blue icing. I would have never guessed that she would make an actual capybara out of rice krispy treats!!!! My daughter loved it and the cake was delicious!!! If you need a cake for a special occasion from someone who truly values their customers' wishes and has true creativity, look no further than Casey's Cakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Jon Blankenship
Great as usual
Stacie Daulton Booth
All I can say is “OH MY GOODNESS!” My armadillo cake was absolutely AMAZING and perfection! It was a masterpiece and I didn’t want to cut into it. The cake was also very tasty and moist! Cannot get over it! Thank you so much!
Lori Salyers Pfountz
Casey has been making cakes for us for almost 20 years! Her cakes are beautiful, delicious, and affordable. She has nailed every themed cake I have requested! Helpful tip-she books fast! Reserve your cake at least 3 months in advance! 🩷
Kayleigh McDonald
Love love love. The price, the quality, the customer service all INCREDIBLE. I cannot recommend them enough.
Kayleigh Burke
Casey’s Cakes made 120 cupcakes, a 2 tier naked cake and a frozen tier for us for our wedding last weekend. She was incredible every step of the way. She was affordable, she was kind and her food was INCREDIBLE. I’ll edit this once I have a photo of the cake from my photographer but I could not recommend them enough. I am so glad I was recommended Casey by a friend.
Gretchen Patterson
Exceeded expectations! We ordered a very unique cake and Casey DELIVERED! It was a beautifully intricate cake and it tasted DELICIOUS! It came out perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Taylor O'Toole
Casey made my wedding cake and it was AMAZING! It was beautiful and just like we discussed, and it was so delicious! All of our guests, and my husband and I, thoroughly enjoyed it! Casey was also super easy to work with and was great in communication with me.
Taylor O'Toole Barger
Casey made my wedding cake and it was AMAZING! It was beautiful and just like we discussed, and it was so delicious! All of our guests, and my husband and I, thoroughly enjoyed it! Casey was also super easy to work with and was great in communication with me.
Ruby Aikawa
When called to ask about a birthday cake, she was very rude. Will not reach out in the future.
Our wedding cake and cupcakes were absolutely stunning!!! Not only did that look amazing but they tasted amazing as well. I would recommend Casey’s Cakes to anyone looking for a beautiful and tasty cake ❤️
Carolyn Comber
Casey made our wedding cake and it was absolutely amazing! Our guests kept telling us how much they enjoyed it and commented that it was so light and fluffy. The buttercream was delicious, and didn't taste artificial like some of the cakes you get at a store. Everything was made from quality ingredients and it all the components were home made, but presented so professionally. The process for ordering our cake was also so smooth. Casey prepared about 2 dozen cupcakes with so many flavors for u to try and did not charge us for the tasting, which I thought was really generous. It was really fun getting to taste all the options. In the end, our cake matched our vision perfectly, and we thoroughly enjoyed it on our wedding day. We definitely will be ordering more cakes from Casey for future events. I highly recommend her cakes for your wedding or party.
Jeffrey Barnes
Amazing!!!!!!! Love Casey!!!!
Jack Campbell
We hired Casey for our wedding cake and we couldn’t be more happy about it! She did so much for us and at such a fair value (I honestly think she should charge more)! From the cake testing to the flower decoration, we were satisfied with every aspect. Don’t shy away from using her for any events you have! She also makes a mean birthday cake for kiddos!
This woman is nothing short of amazing! I got a cake made by her for my daughter's 10th birthday and it has been the best one yet! I told her was that I wanted a capybara cake, my daughter's favorite color is blue, and she could do whatever she wanted. I was thinking for the price, I'll probably get some cute capybara sticker on the cake with blue icing. I would have never guessed that she would make an actual capybara out of rice krispy treats!!!! My daughter loved it and the cake was delicious!!! If you need a cake for a special occasion from someone who truly values their customers' wishes and has true creativity, look no further than Casey's Cakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Great as usual
All I can say is “OH MY GOODNESS!” My armadillo cake was absolutely AMAZING and perfection! It was a masterpiece and I didn’t want to cut into it. The cake was also very tasty and moist! Cannot get over it! Thank you so much!
Casey has been making cakes for us for almost 20 years! Her cakes are beautiful, delicious, and affordable. She has nailed every themed cake I have requested! Helpful tip-she books fast! Reserve your cake at least 3 months in advance! 🩷
Love love love. The price, the quality, the customer service all INCREDIBLE. I cannot recommend them enough.
Casey’s Cakes made 120 cupcakes, a 2 tier naked cake and a frozen tier for us for our wedding last weekend. She was incredible every step of the way. She was affordable, she was kind and her food was INCREDIBLE. I’ll edit this once I have a photo of the cake from my photographer but I could not recommend them enough. I am so glad I was recommended Casey by a friend.
Exceeded expectations! We ordered a very unique cake and Casey DELIVERED! It was a beautifully intricate cake and it tasted DELICIOUS! It came out perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Casey made my wedding cake and it was AMAZING! It was beautiful and just like we discussed, and it was so delicious! All of our guests, and my husband and I, thoroughly enjoyed it! Casey was also super easy to work with and was great in communication with me.
Casey made my wedding cake and it was AMAZING! It was beautiful and just like we discussed, and it was so delicious! All of our guests, and my husband and I, thoroughly enjoyed it! Casey was also super easy to work with and was great in communication with me.
When called to ask about a birthday cake, she was very rude. Will not reach out in the future.
Restaurantji Recommends
Yummy !!
Our wedding cake and cupcakes were absolutely stunning!!! Not only did that look amazing but they tasted amazing as well. I would recommend Casey’s Cakes to anyone looking for a beautiful and tasty cake ❤️
Casey made our wedding cake and it was absolutely amazing! Our guests kept telling us how much they enjoyed it and commented that it was so light and fluffy. The buttercream was delicious, and didn't taste artificial like some of the cakes you get at a store. Everything was made from quality ingredients and it all the components were home made, but presented so professionally. The process for ordering our cake was also so smooth. Casey prepared about 2 dozen cupcakes with so many flavors for u to try and did not charge us for the tasting, which I thought was really generous. It was really fun getting to taste all the options. In the end, our cake matched our vision perfectly, and we thoroughly enjoyed it on our wedding day. We definitely will be ordering more cakes from Casey for future events. I highly recommend her cakes for your wedding or party.
Amazing!!!!!!! Love Casey!!!!
We hired Casey for our wedding cake and we couldn’t be more happy about it! She did so much for us and at such a fair value (I honestly think she should charge more)! From the cake testing to the flower decoration, we were satisfied with every aspect. Don’t shy away from using her for any events you have! She also makes a mean birthday cake for kiddos!
Loading...