I ordered my first cake from Casey last month for my daughter’s 4th birthday. We’ll definitely be ordering again! Casey took my order less than month out - I’m sure it wasn’t an idea timeline for her - but she happily agreed to squeeze me in and I’m so thankful she did. I gave her some general ideas for a Moana-themed cake and she ran with it. Everything was perfect. It was ready the night before I needed it, the cake was beautiful and I was blown away by the design. She was so kind and it was also an extremely good value for what I got. Thank you, Casey! 10/10 recommend!
Kelcy Walton
Ordered a grooms cake from here. Prompt, affordable, great communication. Highly recommend using Casey!!
Lauren States
Amazing cakes!! She is easy to work with and did I say amazing cakes already? So yummy! 100/10
Rajaa Abouakil
Magical Shrek Cake Experience! We threw a Shrek-themed party for my sister and wanted a cake that captured the fun—and this baker absolutely delivered! From the moment I reached out, the process was seamless. She responded quickly, asked all the right questions, and truly paid attention to every detail. When the cake arrived, it looked even better than the reference photo we sent. Vibrant, playful, and so beautifully made—it stole the show. Guests couldn’t stop talking about it, and my sister was over the moon. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rhonda Jo
Amazing work. Fresh no complaints. Highly recommend
Pamela Durham
Amazing work. Fresh no complaints. Highly recommend
The lemon cake made for my Mother's 99th birthday was beautiful and everyone enjoyed it.
Catherine Dudley
Casey was very easy to work with, communicative, and did exactly as I asked for my son's birthday cake. She was also accommodating when I had to cancel my initial order due to a sudden illness.
The cake was beautifully decorated, and equally as important, delicious! She didn't skimp on the frosting, which I always appreciate. Her pricing is extremely fair and reasonable, as well.
I chose to use her even though the party was 200 miles away because no one in my hometown can compare! I'd absolutely recommend her and hope to purchase more cakes from Casey in the future.
MoNeisha Hughes
This woman is nothing short of amazing! I got a cake made by her for my daughter's 10th birthday and it has been the best one yet! I told her was that I wanted a capybara cake, my daughter's favorite color is blue, and she could do whatever she wanted. I was thinking for the price, I'll probably get some cute capybara sticker on the cake with blue icing. I would have never guessed that she would make an actual capybara out of rice krispy treats!!!! My daughter loved it and the cake was delicious!!! If you need a cake for a special occasion from someone who truly values their customers' wishes and has true creativity, look no further than Casey's Cakes.
All I can say is “OH MY GOODNESS!” My armadillo cake was absolutely AMAZING and perfection! It was a masterpiece and I didn’t want to cut into it. The cake was also very tasty and moist! Cannot get over it! Thank you so much!
Lori Salyers Pfountz
Casey has been making cakes for us for almost 20 years! Her cakes are beautiful, delicious, and affordable. She has nailed every themed cake I have requested! Helpful tip-she books fast! Reserve your cake at least 3 months in advance! 🩷
Kayleigh McDonald
Love love love. The price, the quality, the customer service all INCREDIBLE. I cannot recommend them enough.
Kayleigh Burke
Casey’s Cakes made 120 cupcakes, a 2 tier naked cake and a frozen tier for us for our wedding last weekend. She was incredible every step of the way. She was affordable, she was kind and her food was INCREDIBLE. I’ll edit this once I have a photo of the cake from my photographer but I could not recommend them enough. I am so glad I was recommended Casey by a friend.
I ordered my first cake from Casey last month for my daughter’s 4th birthday. We’ll definitely be ordering again! Casey took my order less than month out - I’m sure it wasn’t an idea timeline for her - but she happily agreed to squeeze me in and I’m so thankful she did. I gave her some general ideas for a Moana-themed cake and she ran with it. Everything was perfect. It was ready the night before I needed it, the cake was beautiful and I was blown away by the design. She was so kind and it was also an extremely good value for what I got. Thank you, Casey! 10/10 recommend!
Ordered a grooms cake from here. Prompt, affordable, great communication. Highly recommend using Casey!!
Amazing cakes!! She is easy to work with and did I say amazing cakes already? So yummy! 100/10
Magical Shrek Cake Experience!
We threw a Shrek-themed party for my sister and wanted a cake that captured the fun—and this baker absolutely delivered! From the moment I reached out, the process was seamless. She responded quickly, asked all the right questions, and truly paid attention to every detail. When the cake arrived, it looked even better than the reference photo we sent. Vibrant, playful, and so beautifully made—it stole the show. Guests couldn’t stop talking about it, and my sister was over the moon. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing work. Fresh no complaints. Highly recommend
Amazing work. Fresh no complaints. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Wedding Cake Naked Cake
Casey is amazing, and so are her prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake, Wedding Cake Naked Cake
The lemon cake made for my Mother's 99th birthday was beautiful and everyone enjoyed it.
Casey was very easy to work with, communicative, and did exactly as I asked for my son's birthday cake. She was also accommodating when I had to cancel my initial order due to a sudden illness.
The cake was beautifully decorated, and equally as important, delicious! She didn't skimp on the frosting, which I always appreciate. Her pricing is extremely fair and reasonable, as well.
I chose to use her even though the party was 200 miles away because no one in my hometown can compare! I'd absolutely recommend her and hope to purchase more cakes from Casey in the future.
This woman is nothing short of amazing! I got a cake made by her for my daughter's 10th birthday and it has been the best one yet! I told her was that I wanted a capybara cake, my daughter's favorite color is blue, and she could do whatever she wanted. I was thinking for the price, I'll probably get some cute capybara sticker on the cake with blue icing. I would have never guessed that she would make an actual capybara out of rice krispy treats!!!! My daughter loved it and the cake was delicious!!! If you need a cake for a special occasion from someone who truly values their customers' wishes and has true creativity, look no further than Casey's Cakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
Great as usual
All I can say is “OH MY GOODNESS!” My armadillo cake was absolutely AMAZING and perfection! It was a masterpiece and I didn’t want to cut into it. The cake was also very tasty and moist! Cannot get over it! Thank you so much!
Casey has been making cakes for us for almost 20 years! Her cakes are beautiful, delicious, and affordable. She has nailed every themed cake I have requested! Helpful tip-she books fast! Reserve your cake at least 3 months in advance! 🩷
Love love love. The price, the quality, the customer service all INCREDIBLE. I cannot recommend them enough.
Casey’s Cakes made 120 cupcakes, a 2 tier naked cake and a frozen tier for us for our wedding last weekend. She was incredible every step of the way. She was affordable, she was kind and her food was INCREDIBLE. I’ll edit this once I have a photo of the cake from my photographer but I could not recommend them enough. I am so glad I was recommended Casey by a friend.
Loading...