Four Brothers Crab House & Ice Cream Deck

Delicious ice cream with dozens of flavors. I had the mocha and Kahlua flavors. Nice spot to rest while you wait for the ferry.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I have seen mixed reviews here about Four Brothers, but I need to add our extremely positive review. The ice cream was fabulous and the atmosphere was wonderful! Most importantly, the owners were INCREDIBLY patient and understanding when we had a mishap with one of the golf cars we rented. What could have been an extremely horrible afternoon for everyone ended up being less than a nightmare. We were very grateful to them for this. We recommend that you patronize their business on this idyllic and fascinating island!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Slush

The staff was friendly! The crab melt was delicious! The ice cream was also!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

What a nightmare. They have a captive audience or they'd be out of business

You will be disappointed, but there aren't many options. As others have mentioned, a golf cart rental was not available when we arrived. Service was friendly and polite. Food left a lot to be desired. Burger and cheese pizza were rough. I believe this is all pre-made frozen food. It's not like they are cooking. One other thing worth mentioning is that you would think that a restaurant on the edge of the Bay would use more environmentally friendly packaging. For example, our order contained more than four large styrofoam non-recyclable materials. All the waste on the island gets incinerated. Seems like the owners could care less. Hey just burn that plastic. Atmosphere is deplorable.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

We were here this past weekend and they advertise golf cart rentals. When we got there we were told that they no longer offer them anymore. So this is a heads up to anyone looking to go to the island and rent a golf cart that this is no longer available. So plan accordingly.

I don't recommend the actual food unless you go into with the right expectations. It is pool-concession stand type food, nothing great... This is a place to get SLUSHIES or SOFT-SERVE or some sort of frozen treat! Cool down and refresh yourself with a slushy in any flavor imaginable :)We were on the island for 4 days and this was our go to for a mid-afternoon treat. Grab your preferred frozen concoction and park yourself at one of the dock side picnic tables, next to Cameron Evan's Photography, to have nice view of the water.

Kid-friendliness: Outdoor seating, very casual, and what child doesn't like some sort of frozen snack :)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Slush

Stopped here for water, ice cream, and shade. Everything was great. The place has just about everything so you can’t go wrong stopping here.

Nice little food place with outdoor seating area only. I had a burger with all the works with a side of fries it was great but I wish the burger patty itself had a little bit of heat like it was fresh of the grill. The soft serve is to die for! Make sure you get the waffle cone. Lemonade is sweet and refreshing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

This restaurant/rental company leaves a lot to be desired. They advertise bicycles and golf carts for rent in multiple places and on multiple social media platforms. They have ONE golf cart for rent(which was MIA) and a fleet of broken and rusted bikes , all with flat tires. The glowing advertisments about the rental of recreational equipment is blatantly False. Additionally, there is no employee of any type to help with the equipment or to answer questions. Do Not believe what you read about Four Brothers Crab House And Ice Cream Deck. It is a massive case of false advertising!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Nice little food place with outdoor seating area only. I had a burger with all the works with a side of fries it was great but I wish the burger patty itself had a little bit of heat like it was fresh of the grill. The soft serve is to die for! Make sure you get the waffle cone. Lemonade is sweet and refreshing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Cute little burger/ice cream stand. Lots of food options as well as ice cream and other sweet treats. Food was very good! You can also rent bikes and golf carts to explore the island. Friendly staff.

5/5!This was our second restaurant stop on the island and even though they were busy, we had a good experience here at Four Brothers.The Food: Our group went with a "Flatbread Crab Melt", a "Crab Cake Sandwich" and a "Peanut Butter Milkshake". The Flatbread looked a little small and underwhelming when I opened my container, but I was wrong. When holding the slices up, I saw huge amounts of crab on the pizza and it was thick! Portioned very well and very flavorful. The crab cake however, was the star of the show. The Crab cake was incredibly huge and didn't have any other filling besides crab! You don't see that often for a decent price. It was cooked perfectly as well and flavorful. The milkshake was good as well, but it was just like any other. so nothing to write home about.The Service: Service was good! It can get a little busy, but they do their best to get orders out in a timely manner. You just order, and wait for your name to be called at the front window.The Atmosphere: With a window ordering process, you have to wait for your food on their front porch or the tables they have on the outdoor part of their patio. Some spots have shade with umbrellas as well, so that's a plus!Overall, a 5/5! Good food that'll leave you happy and full. Definitely recommend.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Love love ❤❤

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was on this island 25 years ago. It's obvious the island has taken a serious hit from Covid and other hard life events. This is one of two eateries that is hanging tough.If ur looking for a day out, take the ferry ride, have lunch here, just take a stoll through their town.It's not thrilling, exciting, or fast past. If your looking for just an easy day out this is it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4