The Pizza Box

For context, we give Windy City Pizza a 9. Jet’s Pizza a 9. Sal’s NY Slice and Ynot a 8. We’d give Pizzabox a 5. It was salty and lacked pizza sauce. Won’t be ordering from here again.

If you haven’t been here yet it’s an ABSOLUTE MUST… No chain pizza places for this Jersey Guy!!! The Pizza Box is AWESOME!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They overcharged me the last time I was there! Will not return!

I know they overcharged me on my last to go order. No tip, no return, and definitely no recommendation! We should be able to give 0 stars. Brother's was a lot better!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pizza was okay and half salad is good size. One thing we liked the most was that it is a Mom and pop restaurant and you can tell they are patriots.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

As someone who grew up in Jersey (by way of Brooklyn), I have a deep appreciation for walking into a pizza joint and grabbing a slice. No fuss, no wait, no whole-pie commitment. That’s exactly what drew me into The Pizza Box. In a city like Virginia Beach, where surprisingly few places serve pizza by the slice, this felt like a rare and welcome find.

I ordered the special: one slice and a half salad for $6.99. It was a solid deal. The salad portion was surprisingly generous, fresh, and well put together. I added a soda and had a full lunch that didn’t break the bank.

The slice itself? Generous in size and definitely looked the part. Crispy edges, a nice fold, and that classic New York-style presentation. But while it looked great, the flavor didn’t quite match the visual. It was fine, just a bit basic. Nothing bad, just nothing that stood out either.

That said, the service was friendly, quick, and unpretentious. And the interior had a fun, proudly patriotic vibe. Think small-town Americana meets pizzeria comfort. It added a little charm that made the experience feel easy and familiar.

Final verdict: It’s not a game-changing slice, but it hits the spot—especially when you’re craving that Jersey-style, grab-a-slice-and-go feeling. Worth a visit, especially for the price and the atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

I'm from up North and also huge Pizza fan. I also owned my own pizzeria moons and moons ago. So it is something I am quite picky about. I saw the sign Mom and Pop place that it was exciting and I have to try it. It was worth it beyond all measure. Truly wonderful experience.

Food: 5

Been to the Pizza Box a few times, but after tonight, we will definitely be making it our first choice for pizza. We like to go out for pizza and eat in and they always make you feel welcome. Friendly and professional young ladies greet you at the front to take your order. The owner will ask how your food was…important to us and part of receiving great service. He cares about what you think. We had garlic knots, always soooo good!!! We also had the pizza box special pizza and a Greek pizza. The crust was crunchy throughout and cooked to perfection. Awesome job! It is nice when you are hungry for something and it is as good or better than you hoped. Service like this is rare now a days, but will definitely bring people like us back, because it MATTERS! Thank you for a nice experience, even on a really hot night. Keep doing a great job. We’ll be back👍

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

I ordered chicken tenders and fries and they were the best chicken and fries ever! I definitely recommend this local restaurant, especially if you are in the area! The service and staff were also very friendly!!

I ordered chicken tenders and fries and they were the best chicken and fries ever! I definitely recommend this local restaurant, especially if you are in the area! The service and staff were also very friendly!!

Such a friendly staff. Elissa and Liz gave us awesome service! Excellent food! Can’t get enough of the garlic knots.

Deluxe pizza was good but not the best I’ve had. Definitely would come back to this place again

Food: 4

This is, without a doubt, the best mozzarella sticks you will ever have. The pizza is amazing as well. But the sticks dude, will blow your mind. I’ve ordered twice so far for delivery. Customer service over phone was great and food was delivered promptly and fresh as all get out. 10/10.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza and burgers in town. Very friendly and have always had a great experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Burgers and tots are always delicious

Food: 5

Service: 5