I went into this place for the first time and ordered a large pizza. After about 30 minutes, I still hadn't gotten my pizza, so I asked how much longer it would be. One of the guys making and cooking the pizzas blew up at me immediately for asking. He didn't tell me that I just needed to be a little more patient and the pizza would be out soon. He just immediately lost his temper. I sensed some real anger management issues here. Once I got and ate the pizza, I thought it was fine. However, I won't be coming back. This is way too much drama for a pizza.
Deborah Rounds
We had the pizza combo (2 slices of cheese and drink for 9.00) and one slice of buffalo chicken and one slice of pickle/chicken/bacon pizza. So good. Never thought I’d eat pizza with pickle but wow…it was so yummy! You also need to try the chocolate chip cream cake! To die for!!! All around great restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice NY Style, Pickle Pizza Slice, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pizza by the Slice, Buffalo Chicken Slice
April Davidson
Friday was our first time in and we both loved it. Highly recommend and will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Tiffany Kahley
We stayed at a hotel nearby and the kids had a taste for pizza. We asked the desk clerk what the best local pizzeria was and we were recommended Bellisimo Pizza.The Pizza was incredible ? we had several slices (one was pickle? It was so bomb) and some wings. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was very chill. Will 100% be back next time we visit Williamsburg.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza by the Slice
Doug Smith
Maybe the best pizza and wings in Williamsburg. Wings are smoked and given a fantastic slather of sauce. We had the suicidal chicken pizza and wow. The crust is amazing and the spice was delicious.Such a great lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza by the Slice
bernabe collado
This place has the best pizza. I have been coming here for about 15 years. Showing it off to visiting family and friends, but for the past few years, they have been dealing with open time issues. Need to fix this problem. Opening from 3pm to 7pm is not working. Im here now at gray wolf lodge on a Saturday, and they are closed. It's making me look bad with visiting family. Please get back to opening on regular hours.... this is not a bad review. I'm just getting tired of Hyping, you guys so family and friends. Army working around this area in coming for lunch and you guys are close. Please get your Stuff straight an open for regular hours.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Stephens
Excellent pizza and garlic knots. Great personalities. Terrific service. I loved this place!Vegetarian options: There is Pizza Roma and Margherita pizza... nothing vegan, though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Scott Brubaker, Jr.
Love supporting other local small business owners. Love supporting locally owned options in the food industry. Love supporting others in the community who have been through a rough time. But supporting this place is EASY. GREAT pizza and GREAT service. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan S.
It's true that the Pizza Belt stretches from Philadelphia to Boston. Outside that Belt, it's tough to find good pizza. You'll find it at Bellissimo, which is competitive with any pizzeria you'll find in North Jersey or Long Island.
Bnes Dad
I never would’ve thought that I would’ve enjoyed eating something sweet on a pizza nothing sweet, ever belongs on a pizza, but then I went to Bellissimo‘s and ordered some sort of sausage wonderfulness that made me believe that sweet peppers and sausage go on pizza. Always trust his words to have the best pizza.
On a normal day this place is good: great pizza. But the last two times I went there, they were closed, out of the blue. The soft drinks in cans, without ice or a cup, are horribly overpriced, insulting so. The check out lady is by-the-book "nice," but inflexible and prone to correcting customers--a bad habit in my book.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Tim Wilde
The hype is real! One of, if not the, best pizza in Williamsburg, this is a great stop for anyone coming from the north and looking for your familiar pizza. Great range of slices and pies.Hours are relatively short and they do run out of dough, especially on Friday nights - it's worth a call to order ahead or at least check that they haven't run out, especially if you're coming from far away.Totally worth it once you get here though, even though they have terrible taste in baseball (let's go Red Sox!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Roma
David M.
Good food it was delicious but a bit pricey for a couple of slices of pizza but they have a lot of options and
Timmi
this was my first time going to this place after hearing a lot of people recommend it. and if I were whoever reading this, I would make it a point to go too! first off, everyone at the counter was very friendly. they spoke to everyone like they’ve known each other their whole lives. and the pizza was the best I’ve had in a long time. I’m simple so I just got a slice of cheese, the garlic knots, and the suicidal chicken pizza. everything was fire! from the grease that dripped off, to the homemade marinara. that chicken pizza tho… it’s hot, it’s spicy, it’ll clear your sinuses (but it won’t make you have a upset tummy. Lol )more than likely I’ll be back next weekend ?
The best pizza in Williamsburg, Va! I stumbled upon this place and decided to give it and I am glad I did. The pizza definitely has that New York feel.
I went into this place for the first time and ordered a large pizza. After about 30 minutes, I still hadn't gotten my pizza, so I asked how much longer it would be. One of the guys making and cooking the pizzas blew up at me immediately for asking. He didn't tell me that I just needed to be a little more patient and the pizza would be out soon. He just immediately lost his temper. I sensed some real anger management issues here. Once I got and ate the pizza, I thought it was fine. However, I won't be coming back. This is way too much drama for a pizza.
We had the pizza combo (2 slices of cheese and drink for 9.00) and one slice of buffalo chicken and one slice of pickle/chicken/bacon pizza. So good. Never thought I’d eat pizza with pickle but wow…it was so yummy! You also need to try the chocolate chip cream cake! To die for!!! All around great restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice NY Style, Pickle Pizza Slice, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pizza by the Slice, Buffalo Chicken Slice
Friday was our first time in and we both loved it. Highly recommend and will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
We stayed at a hotel nearby and the kids had a taste for pizza. We asked the desk clerk what the best local pizzeria was and we were recommended Bellisimo Pizza.The Pizza was incredible ? we had several slices (one was pickle? It was so bomb) and some wings. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was very chill. Will 100% be back next time we visit Williamsburg.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza by the Slice
Maybe the best pizza and wings in Williamsburg. Wings are smoked and given a fantastic slather of sauce. We had the suicidal chicken pizza and wow. The crust is amazing and the spice was delicious.Such a great lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza by the Slice
This place has the best pizza. I have been coming here for about 15 years. Showing it off to visiting family and friends, but for the past few years, they have been dealing with open time issues. Need to fix this problem. Opening from 3pm to 7pm is not working. Im here now at gray wolf lodge on a Saturday, and they are closed. It's making me look bad with visiting family. Please get back to opening on regular hours.... this is not a bad review. I'm just getting tired of Hyping, you guys so family and friends. Army working around this area in coming for lunch and you guys are close. Please get your Stuff straight an open for regular hours.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza and garlic knots. Great personalities. Terrific service. I loved this place!Vegetarian options: There is Pizza Roma and Margherita pizza... nothing vegan, though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Love supporting other local small business owners. Love supporting locally owned options in the food industry. Love supporting others in the community who have been through a rough time. But supporting this place is EASY. GREAT pizza and GREAT service. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's true that the Pizza Belt stretches from Philadelphia to Boston. Outside that Belt, it's tough to find good pizza. You'll find it at Bellissimo, which is competitive with any pizzeria you'll find in North Jersey or Long Island.
I never would’ve thought that I would’ve enjoyed eating something sweet on a pizza nothing sweet, ever belongs on a pizza, but then I went to Bellissimo‘s and ordered some sort of sausage wonderfulness that made me believe that sweet peppers and sausage go on pizza. Always trust his words to have the best pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
On a normal day this place is good: great pizza. But the last two times I went there, they were closed, out of the blue. The soft drinks in cans, without ice or a cup, are horribly overpriced, insulting so. The check out lady is by-the-book "nice," but inflexible and prone to correcting customers--a bad habit in my book.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
The hype is real! One of, if not the, best pizza in Williamsburg, this is a great stop for anyone coming from the north and looking for your familiar pizza. Great range of slices and pies.Hours are relatively short and they do run out of dough, especially on Friday nights - it's worth a call to order ahead or at least check that they haven't run out, especially if you're coming from far away.Totally worth it once you get here though, even though they have terrible taste in baseball (let's go Red Sox!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Roma
Good food it was delicious but a bit pricey for a couple of slices of pizza but they have a lot of options and
this was my first time going to this place after hearing a lot of people recommend it. and if I were whoever reading this, I would make it a point to go too! first off, everyone at the counter was very friendly. they spoke to everyone like they’ve known each other their whole lives. and the pizza was the best I’ve had in a long time. I’m simple so I just got a slice of cheese, the garlic knots, and the suicidal chicken pizza. everything was fire! from the grease that dripped off, to the homemade marinara. that chicken pizza tho… it’s hot, it’s spicy, it’ll clear your sinuses (but it won’t make you have a upset tummy. Lol )more than likely I’ll be back next weekend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza Slice NY Style, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
The best pizza in Williamsburg, Va! I stumbled upon this place and decided to give it and I am glad I did. The pizza definitely has that New York feel.