Celli's Chocolate Chips

Literally, the BEST cookies I have ever had! Not too sweet and just perfect! I tried the Brown Sugar, Chocolate and Chocolate Chip flavors , and all of them were wonderful! The place is also so pretty 😍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Celli's makes wonderful cookies BUT they significantly increased their prices since the last time I was in the store. FORTY dollars for EIGHT cookies. Yup, $40 or $5 a cookie. Unfortunately, that's the end of me as a customer.

I have been wanting to try Celli’s for quite a while after seeing the shop on my daily Starbucks trip, and then on the Today show, but my timing is always off. I had a chance today to stop by while picking up a prescription for my son. I met Gina the owner who offered me a sample of the chocolate sea sat caramel cookie, it was amazing. I bought the classic chocolate chip and the cookie I sampled they were both awesome. Gina was so kind and explained each cookie and the chocolate and extra touches, to top the experience off she even gave me extra cookies with my purchase. I arrived home and my kids devoured the cookies, needless to say this will now be on our weekly cookie shop rotation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookies

Good cookies. Get there early if you want to pick from all the flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookies

Absolutely magical cookies that everyone should try! My husband was gifted “the best cookies ever” and I had to track them down! I’m so glad I did. A true gem of a business here in Williamsburg!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

These are, hands down, the best cookies I have ever eaten! Other "specialty" cookie shops rely on high sugar content and flashy flavor profiles that never deliver. Celli's Chocolate Chips focuses on the perfect balance between flavor, texture and sugar content. They are able to keep their prices competitive while using higher quality ingredients than anyone else in the market. I found absolutely no flaw in all the flavors I've tried.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a hidden gem with exceptional cookies in a wide variety. Ms. Gina's as sweet as her cookies!

This is a hidden gem with exception cookies in a wide variety. Ms. Gina as sweet as her cookies!

Best cookies in Williamsburg. The cookies are made with love and also the greatest ingredients are used. Such great customer service!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookies

i LOVE this place--I love to pop in to get a random bag of cookies whenever the mood strikes and it is always a delight. The owners are so nice and so friendly. Every cookie is baked with love and you can absolutely taste the high quality ingredients. Every cookie I've tried has been fantastic but the chocolate chip is tried and true!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookies

The best cookies you will ever have! My family and I really enjoyed them. Call in and order ahead for gluten free orders!

The classic chocolate chip cookies are fantastic! You can taste the high quality ingredients, like vanilla extract. The owner Gina is very kind and knowledgeable. My purchase was $16.64 for 4 cookies, which works out to 4.16 each. Definitely more expensive, but I imagine that the store front rent is costly.

I mean, it was a decent chocolate chip cookie, don't get me wrong, but at $4 each they are horrifically overpriced for what they are. At that price point I had very high expectations and expected an exceptional cookie, but I was very let down. It wasn't great or exceptional and, honestly, my own chocolate chip cookies are better and I get 10 for the price of one, even when using Valrhona chocolate. Won't go back and can't recommend.

May be good cookies. BUT they should be sold as GOLD BARS.

Wow what a cookie! Cheaper than Crumbl but knocks Crumbl outta park. Interesting setup for a “cookie shop” but don’t judge until the first bite and that bite will leave you stunned. Now go get yourself a cookie from this magic place!