Colonial pie company
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
5203 Center St, Williamsburg
(757) 229-7775
About Colonial pie company
Colonial pie company Reviews
Tonight was our second time coming to the Jamestown Pie Company and once again everything we tried was amazing! This time we had pizza, pot pie, and of course 3 different kinds of pie and a cup of ice cream! I highly recommend this hidden gem!!!
Tried a pecan pie from here this week and my family is officially obsessed! They want me to come back to get another next week. The girl who placed my order could tell I was interested in the coconut custard pie as well but I decided to get pecan because my family does not like coconut so she gave my a slice of coconut custard on the house! That was also AMAZING 🤩 highly recommend and will be coming back SOON
Menu
People in Williamsburg Also Viewed
Colonial Pie Company offers a variety of delicious dishes that leave a lasting impression on visitors. Guests have praised the flavorful Rhubarb pie, Creole pie, and the unique shrimp pizza, which features shrimp and scallops on a perfect crust. The seafood pot pie is also a highlight, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to fresh, made-from-scratch meals. While the food is rated a perfect 10/10, customers should be prepared for longer wait times, often around 45 minutes. Those in a hurry are advised to pre-order to ensure they don’t miss out on the tasty offerings. The atmosphere is pleasant for dining, although some have noted issues with flies when eating outside. The friendly service enhances the overall experience, making Colonial Pie Company a memorable stop for anyone visiting the area.