Shields Tavern

This Tavern, along with the staff, and a waitress who had not only great server skills, but a wonderful side of great attitude to go along with it!!! I was there with my son on Thursday, 10/9/25 and will prayerfully return ASAP!!! The music/singing transported me back to a more genteel era, and as I am a true fan of the years '1732 - 1834;' it was indeed a breath of fresh air!! God bless you all for all you did/do!! Best endeavors, Letitia Cline

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We visited last week with a school group for a colonial dining experience. The fried chicken, potato pudding, vegetables, and biscuit were delicious. The lemonade was also refreshing. However, many of us were quite disappointed with the yellow cake with white frosting and sprinkles that was served for dessert. It did not seem like an authentic colonial dessert, but rather like a grocery store sheet cake. In addition the gluten free guests received a beautiful and delicious Strawberry Cream dessert. For the price we paid, it seems like we should have all received the strawberry dessert listed on the menu. Please serve better desserts for an authentic colonial experience.

We visited this 18th century tavern in historic Williamsburg. The menu was simple and very much in-period. I had the fried chicken which came in a huge serving with mashed potatoes. And my husband got the salad with chicken slices. The servers wore period costumes, and there was a gentleman playing the mandolin and flute. The atmosphere was nice and I really enjoyed the whole 18th century tavern experience

They have an inn too, I believe, but we stayed at a different hotel

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

One of the best and most surprising meals we had during our stay in Williamsburg. The meal is a set menu of salad, dinner rolls, vegetables, potatoes, roast rolls (Beef Olives Another Way) and fried chicken, so your bill is per person with dessert and drinks being an additional charge. With that said, you can get as much as you want, so we all left happily full. The fried chicken was the best we have ever had in our lives! Our kids wanted a second helping of the doughnuts and the strawberry cream was delicious on a hot day. Our server was very knowledgeable in explaining the food and how it was pertinent to the time period, as well as the history of the building and the contents inside. Our only complaint was the A/C wasn't working and it was hot outside, but they had some portable units, fans and windows open to make it more comfortable, and it really didn't hinder our experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken Dinner

They have no beer and call it a tavern with beer mugs on the sign!?!?!? Really disappointing

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loved the experience of 18th century dining. $76. For two all you can eat, with optional dessert. Of course my husband ate the desert before I could snap a picture.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lemonaid was extremely watered down, waiter only checked on us once, tons of flies and spiders all over

The picnic food was delicious with perfect portions for two. This meal was a delight for our 4th of July celebration!

Overall amazing experience, just kind of a nightmare that there isn't a bathroom.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Incredible Mother's Day brunch for my amazing wife. Food was just what we were looking for.

The meal was excellent and filling. Loved the comfortable family style service. Will go again soon. Best fried chicken.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was here with a group with a set menu of a colonial salad, fried chicken, mashed potatoes (potato pudding), and veggies served family style. The strawberry mousse dessert was to die for! A great experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wow! For $29/person, you get a groaning board menu. Bread to start, then salad, next came the fried chicken and beef roll-ups with mashed potatoes and delicious veggies. Drinks were included: tea or soda. Everything was so wonderful! We didn’t have room for dessert, but that was not included in the price anyway.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was excellent! Great variety and very flavorful! Staff and service were top notch! Taylor was exceptional when I had to leave early making sure I was well taken care of. VERY, very happy with everything!

Fish was over cooked and dry. Lamb was very gamey and overcooked and chicken was braised so long the bones were dissolving into the meat so you got shards of bone through the chicken.