Benny Meleto's Pizza
19 E Boscawen St, Winchester
(540) 323-7036
Customers' Favorites
Cheese Pizza Slice and Steak and Cheese Can't Remember Their Name for It
A Slice of Pepperoni Pizza from the 28 Inch Pizza
Cheese Pizza and Mushroom Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza
Wild Bill Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Garlic Mushroom
Slice of Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Menu
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Unfortunately very mid. Cheese tasted cheap, crust was ok, overall a little dry but very affordable and you get a huge slice that’s worth two regular slices of pizza. The place is really cute, and they have a ton of drink options. I wanted to love it, but still on the hunt for a good pizza spot in the area.
Usually, Benny's is the best pizza shop in Winchester. However, the last 3 times I've been here, something has changed first couple of times. I figured maybe employee change? Now, the 3rd time slices are smaller, and they're not the same. The price is the same, but it's off on taste and size? Extremely disappointing
Delicious! Their pizzas are amazing. We had the cheese pizza and the mushroom & garlic pizza. They were cooked to perfection. The dough and crust is the best I have had in the area so far. We visited on a Saturday afternoon and plenty of seats were available. Huge slices for $6 made fresh. Staff were super friendly. Definitely going back!
You May Also Like
Sexi Mexi Burrito Bar - 21 E Boscawen St
![]()
Mexican, Food Trucks, Fusion, Vegan
Water Street Kitchen - 2 S Loudoun St
![]()
Southern, American, New American, Pet Friendly
SabaiThaiWinchester Restaurant - 24 S Loudoun St
![]()
Thai, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian