Castiglia's Italian Eatery

212 Grocery Ave, Winchester
(540) 723-4650

Recent Reviews

Daniel Nardone

Just leaving a bad review cause I spent 15 minutes deciding what I want, only to call and for them to still be closed Due to covid. Update your websites.

Josh M.

Not a good first impression. We just moved to the area and have been trying all of the local pizza places. This was no good... I called in a pickup and remember to always get the total (rookie mistake). Because when I arrived I was surprised to find out that I was charged $2 for extra pizza sauce and $2 for extra BBQ sauce for the wings. I have never been charged for extra sauce before and $4 at that?! That only scratches the surface... Overall, the pizza was just subpar. I seriously would have preferred nearly anything. The extra pizza sauce was just tossed on top...didn't even looked like it was incorporated until after coming out of the oven. The wings were somewhat redeeming but with a $2 sauce premium it is hard to justify. We shall not be going back.

Abdul

One of the best Italian restaurants. I had their house salad and the Lasagna and they were so good. The staff are friendly and the restaurant is running by a friendly family which makes you feel like home with your family eating. Definitely will repeat my visit there.

Shawn Pallotta

Great dinner. Rare to find Caprese at an Italian restaurant. Well done. Great Primavera with marinara sauce. Great service by the chef and waiting staff. Friendly and nice atmosphere. Great prices and choices!

John T Considine

I had the chicken Marsala with angel hair pasta and it was really amazing! I recommend their house dressing as well. Has a very unique taste that is really wonderful!

Em & m

It was a little hard to find because the sign outside says "Pizzamore". The interior is outdated but the food was fresh and tasted good, and very reasonably priced (except $15 for chicken parm). The waitress wasn't super enthusiastic and didn't have much prepared but it was okay.

Fur trapper

Great food

Beverly Eaton Seabolt

We had a great dinner !! Best lasagna ever and meatballs and spaghetti that pleased the pickiest eater ! Victor the owner and chef, came to our table and greeted us , and shared stories of his homeland and his wonderful menu items !! Do not walk .... RUN to this great local Italian restaurant !

Jessica C.

Not sure what has happened, this used to be my favorite place to get cheesesteak subs. The cheesesteak they have now is tiny and expensive for the size, you used to get a decent amount of fries not anymore.

Mark Todd

The best pizza & the crust is what makes it a pizza. There salad is thr best because of their house Italian dressing the best all around. Very inviting atmosphere.

Jackee Kidza

The calamari & its sauce were

James Rugen

Good food, great people!

Mark J.

The pizza didn't knock my socks off. However, I had a very delicious Italian dish and it was amazing! I can't remember what it was called but it was really good, had tons of butter and flavor, came with a huge basket of garlic bread, and a big salad. You definitely get your money with here! If you are looking for the best bang for your buck, this is it. You'll be full!

Kathie SI Williams

I have made many trips to Pizza Amore since it opened. The food is great. The staff always makes me feel like family. Cannot wait for the restaurant to open again! Enjoy!!!!

Rebecca Johnson Keene

My whole family loves this restaurant! It’s one of the only places around to get fresh salads, overstuffed subs and the desserts are amazing!!

Load More