Sclafani's New York Bagels and Bread

Ordered a bagel “toasted” with cream cheese. They failed to toast it. Also ordered a caramel iced coffee. And they set a cup with ice and syrup on the counter and made me make it on my own. It’s just disappointing that such a simple order was made with such laziness and lack of care for what they’re providing

Scrambled egg on a bagel shouldn't be full of egg whites that were cooked first then stirred around. Get it together. Crack egg into cup or bowl, mix with a fork, then cook. Easy peasy one would think

I love this place. By far the best bagels and lox sandwiches around Winchester.

I was looking for a coffee shop near my car dealership to work for a bit and found this lovely coffee and bakery/bagel shop. For a middle of the day, Friday afternoon, it was packed! I haven't been in this busy of a bagel shop since actually going to New York City! After trying their cranberry bagel with the FOTM keylime cream cheese.... I can see why it was so busy (but still very efficiently run with minimal wait)! Wow, delicious! Also helpful was free wifi and tables to work from while I waited for my car.

Excellent bagels. Great staff.

The price is reasonable, the staff is always super friendly, and the food is always SO GOOD! They never miss!

As a busy local Realtor nothing is more important to me than family time. My kids and I have a Sunday tradition. We hike around Sherando then get brunch at Sclafani’s! This place is always so busy but the staff is truly wonderful. The young lady that greets us is always so kind to my kids and a great person in general. The food is always perfect. Our go to items are bagel sandwiches with sausage egg and cheese, French toast bagels and a loaf of bread to go that makes great garlic bread or meatball subs! This family owned business will not disappoint. Tell them Chris Roszko the local Realtor sent you!

Best bagels in Winchester

The team at Sclafani’s is so attentive, welcoming, and kind. They keep the space clean and moving. They always have the best attitudes and the bagels are always good. There has not been an order we didn’t like! We’ve also ordered for pick up and we’ve ordered large orders ahead of time and everything has turned out correct and good. I highly recommend!

Bagels are delicious- chewy, just like a NY bagel should be. I’ve always had excellent customer service. I love coming here!

Best bagel shop in the area. This a must stop at restaurant if you are in Winchester!

Amazing Bagels and even better customer service!

This place is hands down the best bagel shop in winchester! they workers are so nice and welcoming & the food is always a 10/10! Thank you guys i appreciate you!

High quality ingredients, friendly service, and the BEST bacon egg cheese bagel and honey walnut cream cheese i’ve ever had!! 10/10 will always recommend!!

Delicious bagels, fair prices, quick service! The everything bagel is my favorite. Everything seasoning is on top and bottom of the bagel which is great. My husband loves the jalapeño cheddar cream cheese also. Only feedback would be maybe having an Asiago cheese bagel in the future.