Gus's New York Pizza Yorktown

It looks like this place was sold off and is changing to a different restaurant. I'll always miss the staff here, hopefully they got transferred to the other locations.

Internet and outlet access. Friendly staff and accommodating to park it and study a few hours. Food is always great.

I totally forgot to take a picture but it was so tasty!!! Ordered a large supreme pizza no mushrooms and the crust was on point. Also got a cheese calzone with meatballs....so delicious especially with the chunky marinara. Customer service was on point and the young girl who took my to-go order was so sweet and helped me choose what to get because it was first time. All in all my family and I are quite pleased

I’ve been a regular at Gus’s for years. But recently when I came there was a lot of arguing in the back, a young lady mikayla handled things well although the arguing made orders slow, I was upset about the arguing yet impressed by her customer service. I wasn’t going to mention it before but when I came back days later there was another incident where a small frail young lady was sweeping my feet as if I wasn’t in her sight, with nothing as little as an apology. As I said I’ve been a regular but these incidents just about did it for me.

This is the best hidden secret in Newport News..The pizza is superb and hand crafted daily..Everything is made fresh and you can tell when you take a bite of the pizza

Vegetarian options: Since this is a pizza place you can choose to get a veggie pizza.

As a contingent worker I deliver from all kinds of places some good, some ratchet as hell . This place is on time. Never heard a complaint from a customer and their service is on time and the food is delicious! Give them a try.

Well I ordered from what I thought was a new calzone restaurant called Brooklyn Calzone and it turns out it’s just Gus’s pizza, using a different name for the same sub par product. I paid $11.99 for a salad that wasn’t even large enough to feed one person and a calzone with no ricotta cheese and unmelted mozzarella. I had to pay extra for the few ounces of marinara and thank god I did because I might have choked on the dry burnt material acting as crust.

Had an online order that was supposed to be for the 6500 location in York town near the Harley Davidson store. System screwed up so System sent it to this location. Was probably 20mins late or so to pick the food up. Place looked depressing. Dark. No music. No sound on the TVs. Got back with the food as it was a carry out order. They forgot salad dressing on 2 orders and ranch for the 3rd order. Also first time visiting this location and will not be back.

Do yourself a favor and eat in or pick up if you plan on choosing them. Their prices on UE under at least 3 different names are all absurd. Rancher's sub 10.99 is 21$ on UE. Rooftop Sandwiches, The Wing Shack, Francesco Pasta Restaurante, The Craft Pizza.... sheesh, just sell it all under your own name and stop screwing customers limited to delivery platforms.

So I ordered chicken Parmigiano & Meat Lover's Stromboli with mozzarella sticks, everything tasted awful... I know it was busy but Damn.. I could've made all this myself way better! Never going back and I'm sure they could care less. Terrible food.

The pizza and customer service was Great. But the rest of the food ehhh....not so much.

Ordered the sausage pizza. You get about 2 pieces of sausage per slice… subs were good. Only reason for the 3 stars

The grilled chicken over salad was the best thing we ate here. The chicken is well marinated and cooked to perfection. I would have given this place five stars, but unfortunately the pizza was horrible. Hard to call that pizza. To be fair, we are from the New York City area and are used to eating real pizza. But still - it's cardboard.

It's ok but its far from being a true new York style pizza .

Great local sandwich and pasta place. Food is consistently good. Definite local favorite.