Took my mom out for a birthday dinner here and everything was great! Penne alla vodka was yummy and mom enjoyed her chicken piccata too. Our server Chelsea was so sweet and made my mom's day a little more special. Nice atmosphere too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt H
I'm giving it a hard 3. We had dinner here. The server was polite, but pretty inattentive, considering they weren't very busy. The food was ok. I had the pizza, which was fine, but my wife's alfredo was runny and almost flavorless, including the chicken.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Seth Bean
Pizza hasn't changed love the cupped pepperoni seafood shippino used to be with a white sauce now red
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adriana Franco
On our road trip from the Finger Lakes to the White Mountains, we pulled off for dinner at Colatina Exit—because road trip rule #27: never hike hungry, never drive hangry.
The pizzas coming out of the kitchen looked amazing, but my body politely reminded me that vegetables exist, so we went with the Burrata Caprese salad instead. It was fresh, creamy, and delicious—basically summer on a plate.
The building itself is charmingly old-school, all warm wood and cozy corners that make you want to stay awhile. The only thing missing? A smile or two from the staff. Let’s just say the service could use a refresher course in “hospitality, but make it friendly.”
If you’re local, this might be a great spot for takeout. If you’re just passing through like us, the food’s good—but the vibe might depend on who’s working that day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Ria St. Pierre
Always a good time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Buckley
Pizza was great but the mussels were better. Nice little restaurant and good service as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jeffrey Meek
Really good food Quick service My grandsons loved the Mac & Cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory Frye
Some of the best pizza I have ever had and the most authentic and delicious tiramisu this side of anywhere.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teddy Hage
Tasty pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Bruce
I usually get the same pizza the manhattan absolutely, delicious.They have had some great drinks in the past to special cocktails. And their bread they serve with every meal with garlic oil.Or cinnamon starts the meal off wonderful.
I’m from the Buffalo, NY area and Colatina is the only place I get pizza from and I’m all the way over in Littleton, NH!! The true food-and-hood technique with amazing crust. They’re also the only place in the area I can find that will put meatballs on a pizza!! 100000/10. Amazing staff as well. If you aren’t a pizza fan, the Chicken Parm is to die for. Amazing sauce!
Donald Slade
Had Special Vermonter Pizza. Great! Had view of golf course out back. Would recommend to a friend.
Charlie D
We just wanted a quick place to eat, didn't expect this at all. We ended up driving almost 2 hours the following weekend just for this. Clean, Consistent, delicious food for a respectable price. The wait staff showed urgency, professionalism all while being nice people. We got the pizza and wings deal which was hard to get 2 weekends in a row just because the whole menu looked amazing. Justified it because we knew we'd be coming back. The restaurant in general was awesome because you aren't sitting on top of others, the booths don't constantly move when someone sits (tables and chairs are an option), it was clean, good lighting, good music! We'll be back!
Melissa Chapman
Wonderful food, great variety of dishes. I have been there many times and always enjoyed it. Staff are very polite and know their stuff 😉
vanessapO7330ZL
I have been going to the Colatina for over 25 years and have always love the atmosphere, staff and the food is amazing. Their 3 bean salas is to die for even for someone who doesn't like 3 bean salad. Everything is fresh and local, I absolutly love it. May I suggest you try the Brussells with carmalized onions carbonara :)
Took my mom out for a birthday dinner here and everything was great! Penne alla vodka was yummy and mom enjoyed her chicken piccata too. Our server Chelsea was so sweet and made my mom's day a little more special. Nice atmosphere too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm giving it a hard 3. We had dinner here. The server was polite, but pretty inattentive, considering they weren't very busy. The food was ok. I had the pizza, which was fine, but my wife's alfredo was runny and almost flavorless, including the chicken.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pizza hasn't changed love the cupped pepperoni seafood shippino used to be with a white sauce now red
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On our road trip from the Finger Lakes to the White Mountains, we pulled off for dinner at Colatina Exit—because road trip rule #27: never hike hungry, never drive hangry.
The pizzas coming out of the kitchen looked amazing, but my body politely reminded me that vegetables exist, so we went with the Burrata Caprese salad instead. It was fresh, creamy, and delicious—basically summer on a plate.
The building itself is charmingly old-school, all warm wood and cozy corners that make you want to stay awhile. The only thing missing? A smile or two from the staff. Let’s just say the service could use a refresher course in “hospitality, but make it friendly.”
If you’re local, this might be a great spot for takeout. If you’re just passing through like us, the food’s good—but the vibe might depend on who’s working that day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Always a good time!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was great but the mussels were better. Nice little restaurant and good service as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Really good food
Quick service My grandsons loved the Mac & Cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Some of the best pizza I have ever had and the most authentic and delicious tiramisu this side of anywhere.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tasty pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I usually get the same pizza the manhattan absolutely, delicious.They have had some great drinks in the past to special cocktails. And their bread they serve with every meal with garlic oil.Or cinnamon starts the meal off wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
I’m from the Buffalo, NY area and Colatina is the only place I get pizza from and I’m all the way over in Littleton, NH!! The true food-and-hood technique with amazing crust. They’re also the only place in the area I can find that will put meatballs on a pizza!! 100000/10. Amazing staff as well. If you aren’t a pizza fan, the Chicken Parm is to die for. Amazing sauce!
Had Special Vermonter Pizza. Great! Had view of golf course out back. Would recommend to a friend.
We just wanted a quick place to eat, didn't expect this at all. We ended up driving almost 2 hours the following weekend just for this. Clean, Consistent, delicious food for a respectable price. The wait staff showed urgency, professionalism all while being nice people. We got the pizza and wings deal which was hard to get 2 weekends in a row just because the whole menu looked amazing. Justified it because we knew we'd be coming back. The restaurant in general was awesome because you aren't sitting on top of others, the booths don't constantly move when someone sits (tables and chairs are an option), it was clean, good lighting, good music! We'll be back!
Wonderful food, great variety of dishes. I have been there many times and always enjoyed it. Staff are very polite and know their stuff 😉
I have been going to the Colatina for over 25 years and have always love the atmosphere, staff and the food is amazing. Their 3 bean salas is to die for even for someone who doesn't like 3 bean salad. Everything is fresh and local, I absolutly love it. May I suggest you try the Brussells with carmalized onions carbonara :)
Loading...