Shy Guy Gelato

198 St Paul St, Burlington
(802) 355-2320

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Liza Feldman

Gelato- ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+
Atmosphere- ⭐️⭐️
Service- ⭐️
The gelato is amazing, the best I have ever had stateside. The Dubai Chocolate flavor was award winning! 🙌

The atmosphere could be greatly improved by putting out a few umbrellas and cafe tables on the sunny street.

As for service- I think it’s unconscionable to not offer a customer restroom. After a 25 mile bike ride on the Island Line trail and then uphill from the waterfront, we would have loved a pitstop and handwashing before enjoying gelato. Please revisit this policy.

Cigdem Koken Aslan

The best gelato we had in a very long time. Dark chocolate sorbet and honey tahini pistachio are unbeatable.

Stanley Moy

Super cool spot for quality gelato. They rotate their flavors daily but you can’t go wrong with anything they have. Staff is friendly and kind. Great place for a treat on a hot summer day.

Anne Mientka

The gelato itself is wonderful, and I love supporting Burlington businesses. I want to note that the plastic they use to serve samples, and the plastic wrap around the cones, will prevent me from returning until they switch to sustainable materials.

isaac Wasuck

Stop in for a treat! Yes, they're still open and going strong- no thanks to some 'newspaper' that jumped the gun with a 'breaking story'.

Bob Imberman

Terrific little spot! Great flavors and texture. Good on them for focusing and not trying to do too much.

Lauren Bowling

Weekly visitor and I never regret going. There are always freshly made flavors and they always come up with a new twist! This is the best way to get your fruit intake for the day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew Baxley

The creamiest gelato, sorbet, and/or ice cream I have ever had in my life.

Selma Sozen

The best Gelato I had plus very friendly staff. Thank you

Isabel C

Extremely good gelato, exciting flavors, very good value for money, lovely friendly staff. Some of the best ice cream I’ve had in a long time

Kate Henry

These guys flavors are insane and unmatched. I’m always blown away, most recently the raspberry rhubarb sorbet and dark chocolate sorbet combo was out of this world delicious, rich, tart, and fresh.

Jonathan Metcalf

The straciatella was shockingly good. I was in ecstasy.

David McGrath

Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matteo Sansone

I give it Blue Collar 7. Please add mooncheese flavor

Melissa Smith

Excellent gelato, five stars, would recommend

Loading...