Third Place Pizzeria

595 Main St, Castleton
(802) 671-8113

Recent Reviews

Big Willy B.

Exactly what we needed after a day of skiing. Had the Vermonter pizza which was so good. The maple garlic butter was unreal. Also had the Ladka burger which hit the spot so hard. Fried pickles were nice and crispy. Full rack of ribs and poutine to top it all off and we were very happy after an active day. There was also a guitarist playing that Friday night who really contributed to the fun. He came over and played next to us and stopped to chat before the night was over. Awesome small town vibes.

Nicole B.

Awesome pizza and wings compared to any place I've been throughout New England. We love coming here when visiting in town. Maple buffalo for wing/tender flavor and Carolina gold/vermonter are our favs for pizza flavors !

Matthew Willis

A great eatery in Casleton. The wife and I treat this as one of our main go-tos for delicious pub food with great service and atmosphere when we don’t feel like cooking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin Bennett

The cashier was very disrespectful to the waiter as I walked through the door threw a condiment at her and was very rude to her, then proceeded to throw my pizza across the counter. I’m not one to leave reviews but the employees you have working there are very unprofessional and should not be the face to the company.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Alex Rucker (Alex)

Amazing place, luckily got to spend some time here while I was a member of the Boston crusaders! Still think about the vermonter pizza on

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Wings

Sara

The food is genuinely really good most of the time and the deliveries usually come pretty fast, which is nice. However, there have been a few times where food is rather hit or miss, and deliveries take a while, but overall, you'll get that with any good restaurant especially if they're busy that day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Wings

Dale Fredette

I had the burger and fries. It was juicy and cooked to perfection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Adams

Super Friendly staff, Good Burgers and a Fun upbeat atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Michelle Hathaway

Not only is the food amazing, the owner running this business is professional, responsible and a pleasure to work with. The employees are wonderful to talk to as well. You can tell that they care very much about their customers and business and run an amazing business with great tasting food! I hope generations get to enjoy it and wish you all nothing but a successful happy business!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Derek O.

Went here for first time last night..yes I know its a college town..however, if you want to be surrounded by underage kids, bartenders that dont care about it, and people doing whippits at the bar (illegal in the US) then this place is for you. The pizza was not very good, the wrap my wife got, we watched the male server helping dripping sweat onto it..not impressed and will be reporting.

suzy saetta

Very fast, clean, excellent customer service. Would have liked the pie shell a bit more crisp, overall a good pie and the smell will bring you in off of the street ?Vegetarian options: There is something for everyone's taste and likesDietary restrictions: Tell them, but that is whats nice about pizzas, you can have it your way. But, they are more than that.... big menu...check it outParking: Easy to find parkingKid-friendliness: They have kids beverages as well as grown-up beverages

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veggie Pizza

Christian Cabrera

Great Pizza, we're from NJ (now live in VT) and happily brought our family from NJ to enjoy some real deal pizza. Our family said it's better than all the pizza joints in their city. Great service as well, solid staff, everyone hustles and bustles. Definitely a local gem. Robby is a great bartender/server, guy works his butt off! Lovely atmosphere and their weekly events are great. I've caught live music and our family was there for trivia. Well worth the trip.

Tim G.

Well... here we are! In a small quiet college town with no where else to get pizza locally. I'm going to lay it out like this; I have been here twice with my daughter. Both times I could not say were the same. One time fantastic. One time mediocre. I can tell you that as a father of a picky beautiful bratt, if she likes and feels comfortable going to this place, hats off to the people who work there. I'm grateful that this place exists for college students to go eat and enjoy themselves. So regardless if the food is between good and great, support this business as they support their community. Plus, plus... THEY MAKE PIZZA!!!

Craig Jasper

Definitely some of the best food in castleton, their Mac n jack bites are sublime.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak with Mac and Cheese

Amanda Travis

My husband and I went there at 930 PM (granted they close 10 PM). We wanted to sit and eat, but felt pressured to take-out. Ordered a pizza to go. Got back to campsite (rained out at dinner time bad) to discover bottom black-burned, so scraped off tops with fork to eat. So tired at that point we didn't think to take a photo.CLEAN OVEN AND TURN TEMP DOWN A BIT AS NIGHT COMES ON!! Above that, check the bottom before passing off to customer. BLACK!! Burnt taste ruined chicken-bacon-ranch pizza. Otherwise, might have been really good. ? Idk

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 2

Load More