23 Best Italian Restaurants near Colchester

“great pizza at great prices and was able to get gas at a really affordable rate as the gas station is attached and has affordable gas. was a little confusing finding the door to three brothers lol. pizza was quick,hot and fresh!!! staff was very nice and friendly.“

“New York Pizza Oven was a great choice while visiting Colchester/Burlington for the 2022 UVM graduation!“

“What a gem! Portions are generous- definitely come hungry. The prices are very fair considering the quality of the food. While the selection of California wines is a bit limited, the Italian wine list more than makes up for it with some great finds.

The highlight of the night was the osso buco-absolutely melt-in-your-mouth and packed with flavor. Hands down one of the best Italian dishes I've had in Vermont. Highly recommend“

“Thank you, Pascolo! We hosted a rehearsal dinner with you last Friday - you managed our large group of 15 seamlessly and easily! The menu and food were great and your staff warm and welcoming - it was a great experience and all 3 generations had a wonderful time!“

“Excellent Italian food! Staff is very friendly“

“We are so happy we chose Pizzeria Verità to cater our wedding! The food was absolutely incredible—delicious, high-quality, and truly elevated, even though it was pizza. The ingredients were fresh, and our guests loved the interactive aspect of watching the pizzas being cooked right in front of them.

The planning process was seamless from start to finish. Sara was so helpful, super organized, and answered all of my many questions with ease. The whole team went above and beyond to make everything run smoothly, and the food on the day was absolutely perfect.

We couldn’t have asked for a better caterer and would highly recommend Pizzeria Verità to anyone looking for a unique, high-quality, and unforgettable food experience!“

“Neighborhood place. Good food, good service. This type of establishment is disappearing in America. Visit tomorrow.“

“On a road trip from out of state, googled some options and was recommended Jrs from another restaurant that was reservations only tonight; so very happy that’s how it worked out! We called ahead to make sure they had openings and the girl I talked to was very friendly. Upon arrival though they mentioned they don’t take reservations they had a table for 5 ready for us. Coming from out of state with 3 kids of different ages there were a lot of questions about the menu and our waitress Lexi was patient and kind; speaking with them directly and making sure to answer all questions. Drinks were refilled without asking, extra napkins supplied, she kept an eye out and checked in regularly. The food was fantastic as well, but Lexi was superb!“

“My family has been coming here for years. Both my girls worked here and we have always appreciated the level of consistency that Mimmo's food offers. Always fresh, hot and delicious entrees and salads. Most recently I have been sitting at the bar while I wait for my take out order and have had the lovely privilege of being waited on by Simone's partner. She is a fireball with the best customer service skills I have encountered in Vermont or anywhere! Everything she does is to make the customer feel attended to and she does it with the most energetic and positive effort! Mimmo's never disappoints!“

“I went here with my boyfriend 8/9/25 and we had Nia as our server, and she was so lovely and excellent. She was so kind and attentive and sweet, there wasn't a moment where we felt unheard or looked over. She was an absolute doll and even when the kitchen was running a little bit behind she still checked on us regularly and got everything out to us in a timely manner all white being poised an polite. The food was delicious, and we had several people greet us on the way in and told us to get home safe on the way out. They're doing it right!“

“Something about the meatballs in the spaghetti made me not eat them... couldnt tell you why but the wine selection is incredible!!! Please also get a desert, any dessert and also a seasonal appetizer if you would be so inclined. Very vibes tiny teeny dining space, I love it.“

“Best Italian in Colchester area“

“amazing staff and food for my first time 5 ⭐ s“

“Absolutely delicious!!! From appetizer selection to entre. Every special occasion and family group eat outs here from now on.“

“Great pizza and friendly staff. The outdoor dinning is perfect. I think number one pizza in all of Vermont. 😊“

“We order take out every once in a while from Zachary's, and it's always delicious. What gets us to go to the Milton location and get food, hang out, and order drinks, though, is the monthly stand up comedy they host. The stand up routines are funny, and we really look forward to going!“

“I had their pizza and garlic knots and the oh-so-tasty marinara a few years ago and I absolutely hope to visit again someday! would love like a gallon of that marinara!! so good!“

“I am from New Jersey.I remember they had a spot in Woodbridge mall and until recently I believed them to be the alternate to sbarro shopping mall pizza.I was wrongBack home, we had dozens of top notch pizzerias so I never tried them but up here in vermont I can honestly tell youThey make good pie.Easily one of the best New York style pies around.Take that to the bank.“

“Pizza is good, prices are nice compared to other places around. Someone said it is like the domino's of Burlington. That makes sense to me. I only tried cheese pizza and breadsticks. I like the marina dipping sauce they use. We got take-out so I can't rate much else. It serves for a good late night snack too. ?“

“Amazing place, great food.“

“Fun place great pizza! Great location“