The only redeeming part of this entire ordeal was Carson, the cashier — genuinely the coolest guy in the building. Polite, friendly, and trying his absolute best while the rest of the operation falls apart around him. I’d hire him tomorrow.
Everything else? A complete disaster.
The pizza tasted exactly like underfunded school cafeteria pizza — my daughter called it immediately. The chicken fingers were even worse: dry, flavorless, and cooked with the enthusiasm of someone counting the minutes until their shift ends. And despite all that mediocrity, they have the nerve to never answer the phone. Calling ahead is an illusion; you’re shouting into the void.
And the final insult? It cost FIFTY-ONE DOLLARS. For food this bad, that price borders on performance art.
Mountain Dick Pizza is the place you go only when everywhere else is closed, sold out, or buried under a snowbank. If you’re coming to Jay Peak, pack dinner, bring snacks, order a pizza from two towns over — anything but this.
The food blows, the service is worse (again, except Carson), and the bill will make you angry all over again.
Carson deserves hazard pay.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Emily Solomon
I have had the pizza a few times at events and it was okay. Nothing spectacular. Atmosphere and service were both great! Pizza is just mediocre.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Sal
We weren’t staying at the resort but when we searched pizza near me (Westfield) we found this place. Wasn’t difficult to find, once you park and walk up the ramp to the side entrance from outside the hotel. We were 2nd in line, Lin moved quickly and our food was ready in 17 min (maybe 15 😃) We weren’t staying far so food was still hot when we arrived, didn’t expect red onion but it was perfect. The buffalo chicken wrap was a flavored warps and I did t expect the bag of chips, nice. It was $38 for a large 2 topping, and the wrap. If we are back in the area and staying this close to Jays peak we’d come here for pizza again. Scored low on atmosphere only because it was a small dining area, maybe it’s more take out than eat in since we were too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
David Powell
Not too bad for mountain pizza. I am a pizza cook and I must say it was pretty delicious. The pizza cook there was very friendly to conversate with. I think his name was Sean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza
Michael Fuoco
Not sure why Mountain Dick's gets so many mediocre reviews. The pizza wasn't mind-blowing, but it was actually pretty solid — definitely better than expected. Plus, the guys behind the counter were super friendly, which made the experience even better.
Robert Tennant
After a day of snowboarding, skiing, ice skating, or water park fun, the pizza is quick and tasted good, which is all you can want and expect from a resort restaurant. I wouldn't just go to Jay to eat there but it's good when you are already there...
Abdul Ahmad
Friendly staff, food was okay. Very noisy with all the school kids.
Hidden Treasures
The pizza is fairly decent but not the greatest A large is $18 but and everything pizza large is $20 The problem I had is I ordered a bud light and was charged $9 when I asked was that correct because they charged me for an Allagash beer . I thought it was a mistake The worker told me it was correct and it not there problem
There beer menu is covered by a piece of electrical tape on prices but the take out menu show $6 not $9
Even at the water park a domestic beer 16 ounces is $7 dollars
So go to the bar at the water park or but beer from the store
$9 is a rip off for an American Beer
Chris Verges
Take an Amazon shipping box, dry out the cardboard, and add the most flavorless sauce and cheese on top. It’s convenient and probably kids are fine with it, but it isn’t “pizza”.
Maxim Mohan
Overall good food and good service, although long waiting time near 8 pm to 9 pm. Not bad for a hotel restaurant.
Thin crust pizza with more than ample toppings was very good.. We were there during a very busy period but yet the staff who seem to be spearheaded by a young man named Drew never missed a beat and kept a smile on his face.. I say give him a try more than a value for the price!!
Brian Doyle
Great little pizzeria onsite at the Jay Peak resort. Pizza was tasty and the prices were quite reasonable for a resort based restaurant.
Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas and other sides.
Kid-friendliness: Family ambiance.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp from the restaurant entrance as well as from the hotel lobby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Sanderson
I have eaten pizza all across this nation, and as far as the plain cheese served here I would rate it as a 2.5 star out of 5. It's not bad just not great, as it lacks almost any real flavor. Both the cheese and sauce are lackluster. The meat lovers pizza is good and would give it a rating of 3.5 out of 5. Overall I do believe that it is overpriced for the size and quality of the pizza, (in fairness the remoteness of the shop may partially justify the cost) the staff were nice and it's a cool little restaurant space. Overall I would skip. Not bad not great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Warren S
Nice thin crust pizza, made fresh (20 minutes) with ample toppings. Accessible from the stairs to the Tram and from 1st floor of Hotel Jay. $20 for a large 16” pizza. A serve yourself type joint with about 8 tables.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Adam Bellmore
The pizza was good but it is a little bit pricy but you are at Jay Peak
The only redeeming part of this entire ordeal was Carson, the cashier — genuinely the coolest guy in the building. Polite, friendly, and trying his absolute best while the rest of the operation falls apart around him. I’d hire him tomorrow.
Everything else? A complete disaster.
The pizza tasted exactly like underfunded school cafeteria pizza — my daughter called it immediately. The chicken fingers were even worse: dry, flavorless, and cooked with the enthusiasm of someone counting the minutes until their shift ends. And despite all that mediocrity, they have the nerve to never answer the phone. Calling ahead is an illusion; you’re shouting into the void.
And the final insult?
It cost FIFTY-ONE DOLLARS.
For food this bad, that price borders on performance art.
Mountain Dick Pizza is the place you go only when everywhere else is closed, sold out, or buried under a snowbank. If you’re coming to Jay Peak, pack dinner, bring snacks, order a pizza from two towns over — anything but this.
The food blows, the service is worse (again, except Carson), and the bill will make you angry all over again.
Carson deserves hazard pay.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I have had the pizza a few times at events and it was okay. Nothing spectacular. Atmosphere and service were both great! Pizza is just mediocre.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
We weren’t staying at the resort but when we searched pizza near me (Westfield) we found this place. Wasn’t difficult to find, once you park and walk up the ramp to the side entrance from outside the hotel.
We were 2nd in line, Lin moved quickly and our food was ready in 17 min (maybe 15 😃)
We weren’t staying far so food was still hot when we arrived, didn’t expect red onion but it was perfect. The buffalo chicken wrap was a flavored warps and I did t expect the bag of chips, nice. It was $38 for a large 2 topping, and the wrap. If we are back in the area and staying this close to Jays peak we’d come here for pizza again.
Scored low on atmosphere only because it was a small dining area, maybe it’s more take out than eat in since we were too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Not too bad for mountain pizza. I am a pizza cook and I must say it was pretty delicious. The pizza cook there was very friendly to conversate with. I think his name was Sean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza
Not sure why Mountain Dick's gets so many mediocre reviews. The pizza wasn't mind-blowing, but it was actually pretty solid — definitely better than expected. Plus, the guys behind the counter were super friendly, which made the experience even better.
After a day of snowboarding, skiing, ice skating, or water park fun, the pizza is quick and tasted good, which is all you can want and expect from a resort restaurant. I wouldn't just go to Jay to eat there but it's good when you are already there...
Friendly staff, food was okay. Very noisy with all the school kids.
The pizza is fairly decent but not the greatest
A large is $18 but and everything pizza large is $20
The problem I had is I ordered a bud light and was charged $9 when I asked was that correct because they charged me for an Allagash beer . I thought it was a mistake
The worker told me it was correct and it not there problem
There beer menu is covered by a piece of electrical tape on prices but the take out menu show $6 not $9
Even at the water park a domestic beer
16 ounces is $7 dollars
So go to the bar at the water park or but beer from the store
$9 is a rip off for an American Beer
Take an Amazon shipping box, dry out the cardboard, and add the most flavorless sauce and cheese on top. It’s convenient and probably kids are fine with it, but it isn’t “pizza”.
Overall good food and good service, although long waiting time near 8 pm to 9 pm. Not bad for a hotel restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
Thin crust pizza with more than ample toppings was very good.. We were there during a very busy period but yet the staff who seem to be spearheaded by a young man named Drew never missed a beat and kept a smile on his face.. I say give him a try more than a value for the price!!
Great little pizzeria onsite at the Jay Peak resort. Pizza was tasty and the prices were quite reasonable for a resort based restaurant.
Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas and other sides.
Kid-friendliness: Family ambiance.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp from the restaurant entrance as well as from the hotel lobby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have eaten pizza all across this nation, and as far as the plain cheese served here I would rate it as a 2.5 star out of 5. It's not bad just not great, as it lacks almost any real flavor. Both the cheese and sauce are lackluster. The meat lovers pizza is good and would give it a rating of 3.5 out of 5. Overall I do believe that it is overpriced for the size and quality of the pizza, (in fairness the remoteness of the shop may partially justify the cost) the staff were nice and it's a cool little restaurant space. Overall I would skip. Not bad not great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Nice thin crust pizza, made fresh (20 minutes) with ample toppings. Accessible from the stairs to the Tram and from 1st floor of Hotel Jay. $20 for a large 16” pizza. A serve yourself type joint with about 8 tables.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The pizza was good but it is a little bit pricy but you are at Jay Peak
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza, Meat Lovers, Garlic Bread
Loading...