Mystic Restaurant & Bar

4928 Main St, Manchester Center
(802) 768-8086

Recent Reviews

Jon Schwartz

Such a treat. Authentic feeling Italian in a small mountain town. Excellent cocktails, wine list favors northern Italian wines, and the pasta is all handmade. Really enjoyed my evening here and highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Z L

This place is so amazing! We came in the evening and the food was just spectacular and our waitress was so nice. I loved the dim lighting atmosphere and everything about our experience was so memorable! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paige Erickson

Nothing could’ve been

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grill Cheese

Ino

Delicious food! Excellent chef at Mystic 802! Bartender was great! She executed consistent and well balanced cocktails each and every time. Probably the best restaurant in that area, definitely worth checking out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nancy Koziol

Pasting my copy from over on Yelp. TL; DR it's freaking amazing and delicious and awesome but we had a couple that were hardcore making out down the bar from us and it was killing the vibe.This spot has been on my to-try list forever. A few months ago I was invited to lunch with a winemaker here and that experience was exceptional (but not what everyone is going to experience) so I bumped it up higher on the list.They are open on Monday nights and for a short time I was working in hospitality and living in a town where NADA is open on Monday nights so Kris and I headed up route 7 to try this. I'm so glad we did.We didn't have a reservation but were able to get seated at the bar instantly. The staff was great and quick and fun, kind of picking up on the vibe of the guests and being more or less chatty depending.The lighting is gorgeous and the space has got a great, elegant but casual vibe. You can tell tremendous care is taken with their food and beverage program. We started with a cocktail before each enjoying a pasta dish with wine. I had to get their house-made pistachio icecream to finish because I never say no to pistachio icecream.Right-priced and just an excellent choice. Deducted one star because there was a couple sitting down the bar from us that was MAKING OUT. I'm not talking a little affection on date night. I'm talking foreplay. I get that the customer is always right but as a diner, on the short side of an L-shaped bar, I couldn't help but see it and I personally think they should have been asked to stop. Sometimes you have to let peole know their behavior isn't a good fit. Yes, it's dimly lit and romantic but no one wants to watch people licking each others molars.Looking forward to going back and will continue to even if people are making out every time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nolan Rochler

The food is undoubtably great but the service is what makes the experience. Caroline and Ray were phenomenal. I’ve never seen a team serving effort executed so flawlessly. No overlap, never missed a beat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ruth H.

The rude hostess caused us to leave the restaurant this evening. Kindness and welcome should be at the top of your list.

Susan M.

Excellent food, great service and lovely decor. The pasta dishes are calling me back!

Joel Rissinger

One of the best dining experiences I've ever had. And I've been cooking for 16

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Carpaccio

Carmen Bellacasa

We always stop through this town and try a new lunch place. This was a pleasant surprise. The food is fresh, house made and amazing. Worth the stop.

Carol H.

Pricey and elegant . Our server never told us about specials. I only knew by hearing another server at the next table. I had the spaghetti with crab. It was delicious, the crab was very fresh and there was plenty of it. It was nicely spiced and I had enough to share with my husband. We ordered the scallop appetizer, I didnt know the scallops would be uncooked. I like alot of raw fish but scallops raw, I just couldn't do. My husband also did not know they were raw but he did eat them. Im not sure I will go back. It is very expensive and maybe a just bit too fancy for me.

Aimee Haftel

Very rude and wouldn't seat us with our children.

Marilyn T.

It's a bit pricey, but worth it! We went for lunch and sat at cozy window seat. We had the tuna rice bowls and Ghost Story cocktails. The drinks were $21 each, but sooo yummy and came in a decanter that filled your glass with smoke. The tuna bowls were also delicious and just the right amount to satiate without feeling too full. Our server was lovely and attentive!

Rick Kranzley

EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS! Needed a good experience after difficult day. Monday was not the day to havegood options since many establishments were closed. Found Mystic. Can't say enough. Drinks were exceptional. Loved Ghost Story Manhattan. Menu had excellent variety. Hard to decide. Made the right choice... so did my wife! Wait staff was attentive and friendly. Alex was special.This is a must for Manchester dining!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bonnie B.

We were there for dinner this evening, food was amazing from appetizers to dessert and we had a wide variety. Service was fantastic with just enough fun. The only concern is that it was just a little on the loud side. Sending love for a memorable evening.

Load More