Costello's Market

99 Maple St, Middlebury
(802) 388-3385

Recent Reviews Order Online

Mains
Tuna Salad
Our tuna salad on a bed of romaine, cucumber salad, and tomato.
Calamari Dinner
Oyster Po Boy
Shrimp Po Boy
Anipasto Salad
Salami, provolone, mozzarella, banana peppers, roasted peppers, marinated mushrooms, artichokes, and tuna. Dressed with olive oil and balsamic.
Fish and Chips
Tuna Melt
Tomato and cheddar.
Fish Taco
Arugula Goat Cheese Salad
Eggplant caponata, romaine, marinated mushrooms, roasted red peppers, and Vermont goat cheese dressed with olive oil balsamic, and lemon.
Salmon Patty Ciabatta
Salmon patty flavored with dijon and capers. On fresh-baked ciabatta bread with lettuce, tomato, onion, and creole mayo.
Fish Sandwich
Fries and cole slaw.
Caesar Salad
Mixed Garden Salad
Mediterranean Salad
Fresh greens, roasted peppers, onion, cucumbers, mozzarella, olives, tomato, and feta cheese dressing.

Dinner Starters
Calamari
Crispy fried squid with fresh basil aioli.
Misto Verdue
Medley of marinated vegetables.
Shrimp Scampi Salad
Romaine, tomato, and broccoli florets. Topped with shrimp dressed in lemon, garlic, and olive oil.
Caesar Salad
Mixed Garden Salad
Romaine, arugula, tomato, roasted peppers, cucumber, onion, and feta cheese dressing.
Mediterranean Salad
Romaine, arugula, tomato, roasted peppers, cucumber, onion, mozzarella, olives, and feta cheese dressing.
Mussels
Fresh steamed mussels in our marinara sauce.

Dinner Seafood
Fish and Chips
Fries and slaw.
Fried Calamari
Fries and slaw.
Pan-Seared Tuna or Swordfish
Topped with lemon butter and fresh herbs. Served over a medley of fresh roasted vegetables.
Baked Filet of Fish
Topped with a dollop of fresh basil aioli served over medley of fresh roasted vegetables.
Mussels Marinara
Served over pasta.

Dinner Pasta
Roasted Vegetable Pasta
Roasted medley of vegetables in marinara sauce with pasta.
Chicken Parmesan
Over pasta and marinara sauce.
Pork and Pappardelle
Tender pork in marinara sauce with sauteed mushrooms, peppers, and flat wide pasta.
Eggplant Parmesan
Served with pasta and our marinara sauce.
Cheese Lasagna
Cheese Ravioli
Marinara sauce.
Gnocchi Marinara
Gnocchi and cremini mushrooms in marinara sauce with roasted peppers.
Pasta and Marinara
Gnocchi Baby Bella
Gnocchi and cremini mushrooms in marinara sauce with roasted peppers.
Chicken Cacciatore
Chicken breast meat in marinara with sauteed mushrooms, peppers, olive, and pasta.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
Photo credit: google
+10 photos
Photo credit: google
+9 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

This place is an amazing hidden gem! The fresh fish, salads, and many other goodies are top tier 👌 😋 I sadly should have gotten a larger size of the broccoli salad because oh my goodness!!! Even better, the owner is so kind and enjoyable to interact with! Definitely give them a try if you haven't already!
May 2025
This is a total gem of a deli and specialty store. The sandwiches and other handmade food is excellent. The owners are very friendly and totally hands on in everything they do. Any neighborhood would be very lucky to have a Costello's so Middlebury, Vermont is privileged like no other.
May 2025
Great little market, we got three sandwiches and four drinks 60$. The woman at the counter was very pleasant and easy to talk to while we waited for our food. Everyone enjoyed their food!
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Stone Leaf Teahouse - 111 Maple St
Tea Rooms
American Flatbread - 137 Maple St
Pizza, American, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian
Noonie's Deli - 137 Maple St
Deli, American

Costello's Market

99 Maple St, Middlebury, VT 05753
(802) 388-3385