Amazing food and location. Beautiful space and impeccable service. We were a large party and in middle of the main dining room. In the future I would ask to be seated in a quieter side room so that we could hear everyone at the table. Older members of our group had a difficult time hearing anyone not seated directly next to them.
Craig M
I did not think to take pictures. Here’s why. We had a dinner party of 9, on Saturday night, Feb 17, 2024. The second you walk in the door, you are greeted with a cozy fire in the fireplace, in a quaint living room type area. You are greeted promptly and coats were taken. We walked over to the bar and had a few drinks. Also a very cozy area, great seating. Fantastic drinks. Once we had a drink, we moved into our dining area, which was in the library, again very cozy, lovely fireplace with a warming fire. The folks taking care of us were wonderful. We all had different things on the menu, from several appetizers, warm bread with a delightful olive oil garlic dip and more drinks. Our meals were varied and I won’t explain them all here, but they were ALL amazing. Dessert was equally fantastic. We sat for about three hours enjoying ourselves and were not rushed out. So, to end how I started, we did not take pictures because we were so engrossed in our evening, enjoying drinks and food as well as such a homey, comfy environment. I would totally recommend dining here. Put the phone down and just enjoy where you are!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CynthiaW
Our server Sara was outstanding. Articulate and kind. I think the only thing I'd pass on is that in the main dining room when all the tables were full, the noise level became so overwhelming that we all felt like leaving. We had finished our meal and had enjoyed the evening though. Also, my husband is a vegetarian and there was only one dish that was fully a vegetarian dish. Perhaps more selections for vegetarians.
REDS
Second visit to Jessica's and dinner was once again, excellent. Staff was very friendly and sommelier very informative. Party of five (four out-of-state visitors) enjoyed our visit. I resisted the (awesome) Duck Two Ways this visit, in favor of the Red Snapper w/green chutney and polenta (a special of the day) which was a winner! Delicious wine.
Alana K
Spectacular food, attentive staff and wonderful wine recommendations in a sophisticated and friendly atmosphere. Favourites from the dinner menu were the chowder, the halibut entrée (!!!) and the sticky date pudding dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
VermontTransplant
We were pleasantly surprised by Jessica's food. The clam chowder was excellent and the red snapper special was very good. My wife felt the scallops, while tasty, were a tad overdone and her maple creme brulee was good. I had a cake/ice cream option that was good but too large. The atmosphere is nice and cozy. While the service wasn't the best we've ever had, it was perfectly fine for a busy Valentine's Day night in Vermont nd we weren't rushed at all. Our one minor gripe was that it took a long time to get the bottle of wine that we ordered. It turned out they were out of it and brought a couple of other options for us. The wine list is extensive but we might just do glasses next time. Jessica's isn't cheap but we would go again for special occasions.
Katy Mackey
Food was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Liver Pate Appetizer, Caesar Salad, Duck Two Ways
Beth Marr
Super dinner. Gave us our fav table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brussels Sprout Salad
cocowireless
Jessica's is a total gem in the sweet town of Middlebury, Vermont. Food creative and delicious with an attentive service. Lovely Inn with a modern touch. Particularly loved the bar with knowledgable female bartender who is charming, professional and creates delicious and inventive cocktails. Highly recommend the Halibut and Steak Frites. Thank you to Matthew and his great team for a memorable meal and also accommodating our late breaking additional guest on a busy night.
PeteL
My wife and I made our first visit to Jessica's while celebrating our anniversary. We both agreed it was the best meal we've had in ages. Literally every single bite was amazing. Loved the setting as well. Can't wait to return!
Delicious food, outstanding service, impeccable atmosphere and creative cocktails. My partner had the blue cheese crusted tenderloin which was phenomenal. My liver pate and caesar salad were very good. Wine list is extensive and had a really nice orange wine by the glass. The front library room is cozy with a warm fireplace and a fantastic mix of contemporary art and historical artifacts.We were too tired to hang out in the bar and enjoy some of their cocktails from the resident mixologist; if you are there on a Friday, be sure to join their weekly cocktail event.As guests in the Inn, we also had breakfast (included) which was excellent, and featured wild blueberry pancakes and homemade granola.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Liver Pate Appetizer, Side Belgian Fries, Caesar Salad, B&B
Samantha Jackman
The steak special was delicious and the bartender was able to accommodate a special request. Great staff, helpful service. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Belgian Fries, Caesar Salad, Sorbet
jonathanc
"I love the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room in a friends home. I definitely would return to try more dishes. Service was well-timed and friendly, wines were affordable."
SophieS
We celebrated our 40th wedding anniversary at Jessica's and had a thoroughly lovely evening. The food was a creative combination of delicious flavours, the staff were charming - Maia has a beautiful gentle energy and the hosts were warm and welcoming. We were seated near the fire place, the mantlepiece was decorated for Christmas. It was all excellent. I would thoroughly recommend.
Joshua McKee
Everything was perfect!!!! The food was amazing (highly recommend the two-way duck), drinks were great, and our server, Sarah, was the best! Thank you for providing us with an amazing night!!!!!
Amazing food and location. Beautiful space and impeccable service. We were a large party and in middle of the main dining room. In the future I would ask to be seated in a quieter side room so that we could hear everyone at the table. Older members of our group had a difficult time hearing anyone not seated directly next to them.
I did not think to take pictures. Here’s why. We had a dinner party of 9, on Saturday night, Feb 17, 2024. The second you walk in the door, you are greeted with a cozy fire in the fireplace, in a quaint living room type area. You are greeted promptly and coats were taken. We walked over to the bar and had a few drinks. Also a very cozy area, great seating. Fantastic drinks. Once we had a drink, we moved into our dining area, which was in the library, again very cozy, lovely fireplace with a warming fire. The folks taking care of us were wonderful. We all had different things on the menu, from several appetizers, warm bread with a delightful olive oil garlic dip and more drinks. Our meals were varied and I won’t explain them all here, but they were ALL amazing. Dessert was equally fantastic. We sat for about three hours enjoying ourselves and were not rushed out. So, to end how I started, we did not take pictures because we were so engrossed in our evening, enjoying drinks and food as well as such a homey, comfy environment. I would totally recommend dining here. Put the phone down and just enjoy where you are!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our server Sara was outstanding. Articulate and kind. I think the only thing I'd pass on is that in the main dining room when all the tables were full, the noise level became so overwhelming that we all felt like leaving. We had finished our meal and had enjoyed the evening though. Also, my husband is a vegetarian and there was only one dish that was fully a vegetarian dish. Perhaps more selections for vegetarians.
Second visit to Jessica's and dinner was once again, excellent. Staff was very friendly and sommelier very informative. Party of five (four out-of-state visitors) enjoyed our visit. I resisted the (awesome) Duck Two Ways this visit, in favor of the Red Snapper w/green chutney and polenta (a special of the day) which was a winner! Delicious wine.
Spectacular food, attentive staff and wonderful wine recommendations in a sophisticated and friendly atmosphere. Favourites from the dinner menu were the chowder, the halibut entrée (!!!) and the sticky date pudding dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were pleasantly surprised by Jessica's food. The clam chowder was excellent and the red snapper special was very good. My wife felt the scallops, while tasty, were a tad overdone and her maple creme brulee was good. I had a cake/ice cream option that was good but too large. The atmosphere is nice and cozy. While the service wasn't the best we've ever had, it was perfectly fine for a busy Valentine's Day night in Vermont nd we weren't rushed at all. Our one minor gripe was that it took a long time to get the bottle of wine that we ordered. It turned out they were out of it and brought a couple of other options for us. The wine list is extensive but we might just do glasses next time. Jessica's isn't cheap but we would go again for special occasions.
Food was excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Liver Pate Appetizer, Caesar Salad, Duck Two Ways
Super dinner. Gave us our fav table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brussels Sprout Salad
Jessica's is a total gem in the sweet town of Middlebury, Vermont. Food creative and delicious with an attentive service. Lovely Inn with a modern touch. Particularly loved the bar with knowledgable female bartender who is charming, professional and creates delicious and inventive cocktails. Highly recommend the Halibut and Steak Frites. Thank you to Matthew and his great team for a memorable meal and also accommodating our late breaking additional guest on a busy night.
My wife and I made our first visit to Jessica's while celebrating our anniversary. We both agreed it was the best meal we've had in ages. Literally every single bite was amazing. Loved the setting as well. Can't wait to return!
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food, outstanding service, impeccable atmosphere and creative cocktails. My partner had the blue cheese crusted tenderloin which was phenomenal. My liver pate and caesar salad were very good. Wine list is extensive and had a really nice orange wine by the glass. The front library room is cozy with a warm fireplace and a fantastic mix of contemporary art and historical artifacts.We were too tired to hang out in the bar and enjoy some of their cocktails from the resident mixologist; if you are there on a Friday, be sure to join their weekly cocktail event.As guests in the Inn, we also had breakfast (included) which was excellent, and featured wild blueberry pancakes and homemade granola.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Liver Pate Appetizer, Side Belgian Fries, Caesar Salad, B&B
The steak special was delicious and the bartender was able to accommodate a special request. Great staff, helpful service. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Belgian Fries, Caesar Salad, Sorbet
"I love the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room in a friends home. I definitely would return to try more dishes. Service was well-timed and friendly, wines were affordable."
We celebrated our 40th wedding anniversary at Jessica's and had a thoroughly lovely evening. The food was a creative combination of delicious flavours, the staff were charming - Maia has a beautiful gentle energy and the hosts were warm and welcoming. We were seated near the fire place, the mantlepiece was decorated for Christmas. It was all excellent. I would thoroughly recommend.
Everything was perfect!!!! The food was amazing (highly recommend the two-way duck), drinks were great, and our server, Sarah, was the best! Thank you for providing us with an amazing night!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5