Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

14 College St, Middlebury
(802) 388-3371

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Blair Heagerty

They stop serving at the deli an hour before they close. Heads up there. They are also currently short staffed and will be closed for a few days coming up soon, so call before you go ❤️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Michael Andonucci

Fabulous local bakery. These are very serious bread bakers who also do great pastries, panini, and coffee. I had a cortado and was *not* disappointed!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Panini, Panini

Sabrina Lois

Gluten Free Sandwiches and Salad

It's small and you can buy sandwiches and salads, and they also make gluten-free pita bread. A celiac can eat.

For the United States, they are not as friendly as other places, but at least they take care of you if you are celiac. Then you have to make a living to be able to eat somewhere, because the tables are busy and dirty, because if you don't pick it up, no one will, and since there are customers who don't pick up their things...well, you have to do it. to you if you want to sit.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Sangeeta

Not the same since it was sold a couple years back but still good, I love their breakfast panini. Stick to the pastries and the sandwiches though… the espresso is not good.

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jeanne Flaherty

Lovely breakfast. I ordered an orange almond croissant, delicious! The coffee is good and strong. (The way it should be.)?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

E Le

Was a nice place and was presented well, that was about it, service was sub-par at best, they forgot our order and were very rude when we brought it to their attention, This is my first ever negative food review due to how egregious the service was, will be going to the Italian place next time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Allen Carpenter

I asked for no mayo, you skipped the horse radish and put mayo on my Midwestern.
Both of your places seem to be Wholly incompetent.
I know you're busy but getting right should be priority.
If you can't do this , what other things, like hygiene and food prep don't you get right?!

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 3

Alison Hall

The bread is unbelievably expensive especially for the quality, which as many have noted, is subpar.

Amy Kato

We were there over the holiday, it was busy and smells were amazing. The croissants were so flakey and filled with ham and cheese. The apple pastry was by far my favorite. The staff were super nice.🍎🍏

Tyler Day

Love the sandwiches (especially breakfast) and pastries. Always a good stop for a bite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sticky Bun, Croissant, Otter Creek Sub, Vermonter, Panini, Half Sandwich, Breakfast Panini

linda bowden

Great pastries and deli sandwiches!

Martina Baade

Really delicious “real” bread, incredibly lavishly topped! The visit is worth it just because of the price-performance ratio. Highly recommended!

Chase

Tried the Otter Creek "Sub" and it was a nice take on a regular sandwich, the hot peppers and pickles were overpowering the "Italian oil". Decent baguette. Croissants were sold out, so might have to come back and try those. Chai latte was ok. The let down was when I paid for my order to go, the minimum tip option was 18% which came out to $4.96. I changed it to $2 and the cashier gave me a dirty look, and grabbed back the machine and handed me a "buzzer" as if I just spat in their faces. Tipping by % should be reserved for waiters/waitresses who provide an extensive service throughout a dining experience, and depends on the quality of service.

Elmbar

Delicious paninis. I had the ham and brie and my husband got the Cuban panini. The raisin oatmeal cookie was great, too and it was huge we simply shared one. Excellent selection of coffees/drinks, and not far from the waterfalls. We came on a Sunday and street parking was not a problem. Because it was a Sunday they closed at 2 PM. Glad we made it!

Sam Cone

Breakfast sandwich will get the job done maple cheese danish was great busy lil spot good stop

Loading...