Yummy pastries! It can get crowded sometimes inside but that's to be expected! Make sure if you don't like the way vegan or gluten free pastries taste that you look at the tags because I accidentally ordered a gluten free pastry one time lol! The bread is very good and the danishes are to die for! Super cute ambience in the spring/summer!
Jaclynn W.
Great pastries, sandwiches, cookies, and coffee. If you need a snack, breakfast, or lunch, you can't go wrong. We had the veggie panini special, caramelized onion and mushroom stuffed croissant, and got a variety of assorted sweet items to go (the whoopie pies were incredible!). The bakery was clean and the staff were very polite.
Tyler Day
Love the sandwiches (especially breakfast) and pastries. Always a good stop for a bite.
The smells emanating from this bakery onto the street always entice me and I finally made a stop into this quaint little spot. Space is tight so it's best to know what you want before you get in there, but the employees are super friendly and everything was delightfully tasty!
Chase
Tried the Otter Creek "Sub" and it was a nice take on a regular sandwich, the hot peppers and pickles were overpowering the "Italian oil". Decent baguette. Croissants were sold out, so might have to come back and try those. Chai latte was ok. The let down was when I paid for my order to go, the minimum tip option was 18% which came out to $4.96. I changed it to $2 and the cashier gave me a dirty look, and grabbed back the machine and handed me a "buzzer" as if I just spat in their faces. Tipping by % should be reserved for waiters/waitresses who provide an extensive service throughout a dining experience, and depends on the quality of service.
Elmbar
Delicious paninis. I had the ham and brie and my husband got the Cuban panini. The raisin oatmeal cookie was great, too and it was huge we simply shared one. Excellent selection of coffees/drinks, and not far from the waterfalls. We came on a Sunday and street parking was not a problem. Because it was a Sunday they closed at 2 PM. Glad we made it!
Sam Cone
Breakfast sandwich will get the job done maple cheese danish was great busy lil spot good stop
Noel Cone
The orange almond Croissant is the best Croissant I've ever eaten. I wish I would have gotten half a dozen of them. Absolutely delicious. It was definitely the best thing of several items I sampled there while on vacation.
Leslie A.
Cute place with outdoor seating. Sandwiches are delicious and generous portions so bring your appetite!
Anthony LoFrisco Jr
Cool place with friendly service and an excellent breakfast sandwich but outrageously expensive and you can't have it your way. Wheat toast? Nope. Egg whites? Nope. I don't know a universe where an egg and cheese sandwich should cost $9 and a bacon, egg and cheese sandwich, $11.
Great bakery. Breakfast sandwiches are amazing. The maple cream cheese danish is sooo good. Friendly staff. Everything tastes amazing. Go and get delicious treats.
R K L
It is frequently difficult to find good brunch options when traveling but even more challenging for gluten free diets. The Otter Creek Bakery absolutely covered all the bases. It not only was the perfect choice for a reasonable, tasty brunch but also had excellent gluten free options. An entire section of their bakery case was devoted to GF pastries! We enjoyed a Breakfast Panini with avocado/bacon and a Ham/Egg/Cheese Breakfast Panini with Gluten Free Wrap with our coffees. Could not pass on their Apple Streudel, as well as a GF Raspberry Oat Square for me. Many customers carried out their goodies, but there was also limited seating both inside and outside. The staff was wonderful, and the food portions were huge. We actually took half back to our hotel for afternoon/evening snacks, so the $45 tab which included gratuity was indeed a bargain.
Kaylee Conover
We had a casual daytime wedding at Button Bay State Park of about 85 people and hired Tatiana and the team at Otter Creek to cater the event. We had multiple different types of sandwiches, side salads, and desserts. Everything was really delicious. Tatiana delivered everything and helped set up. My only complaint is that communication was a little difficult, especially via email (phone seemed better) but they are busy and I think still trying to expand their catering business. I would hire them again and highly recommend them for your catering needs.
Alan S.
We were staying for the weekend on Lake Dunmore and it was my wife's birthday. Not a big fan of supermarket cakes. Maybe because of they have about 37 ingredients, one worse than the other. The chocolate cake from Otter Creek was excellent! Moist, tasty, a small fed 8 with a little leftover. The mushroom croissant was also tasty! Happy wife, happy life.
Micah Pratt
Decided to try to grab a great favorite of mine today, The Otter Creek Sub. It wasn’t busy so I went inside. There were only two employees that I could see and the cashier was helping two customers ahead of me so I waited patiently. First of all, I wasn’t greeted upon entering and the cashier never even acknowledged me. I waited a solid 15 minutes and never was asked what I wanted to order. While I was waiting, the cashier answered the phone and took a phone order and proceeded to fire that order ahead of me while I waited, to even be acknowledged. Terrible customer service. I walked out and went somewhere else.
Yummy pastries! It can get crowded sometimes inside but that's to be expected! Make sure if you don't like the way vegan or gluten free pastries taste that you look at the tags because I accidentally ordered a gluten free pastry one time lol! The bread is very good and the danishes are to die for! Super cute ambience in the spring/summer!
Great pastries, sandwiches, cookies, and coffee. If you need a snack, breakfast, or lunch, you can't go wrong. We had the veggie panini special, caramelized onion and mushroom stuffed croissant, and got a variety of assorted sweet items to go (the whoopie pies were incredible!). The bakery was clean and the staff were very polite.
Love the sandwiches (especially breakfast) and pastries. Always a good stop for a bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sticky Bun, Croissant, Otter Creek Sub, Vermonter, Panini, Half Sandwich, Breakfast Panini
The smells emanating from this bakery onto the street always entice me and I finally made a stop into this quaint little spot. Space is tight so it's best to know what you want before you get in there, but the employees are super friendly and everything was delightfully tasty!
Tried the Otter Creek "Sub" and it was a nice take on a regular sandwich, the hot peppers and pickles were overpowering the "Italian oil". Decent baguette. Croissants were sold out, so might have to come back and try those. Chai latte was ok. The let down was when I paid for my order to go, the minimum tip option was 18% which came out to $4.96. I changed it to $2 and the cashier gave me a dirty look, and grabbed back the machine and handed me a "buzzer" as if I just spat in their faces. Tipping by % should be reserved for waiters/waitresses who provide an extensive service throughout a dining experience, and depends on the quality of service.
Delicious paninis. I had the ham and brie and my husband got the Cuban panini. The raisin oatmeal cookie was great, too and it was huge we simply shared one. Excellent selection of coffees/drinks, and not far from the waterfalls. We came on a Sunday and street parking was not a problem. Because it was a Sunday they closed at 2 PM. Glad we made it!
Breakfast sandwich will get the job done maple cheese danish was great busy lil spot good stop
The orange almond Croissant is the best Croissant I've ever eaten. I wish I would have gotten half a dozen of them. Absolutely delicious. It was definitely the best thing of several items I sampled there while on vacation.
Cute place with outdoor seating. Sandwiches are delicious and generous portions so bring your appetite!
Cool place with friendly service and an excellent breakfast sandwich but outrageously expensive and you can't have it your way. Wheat toast? Nope. Egg whites? Nope. I don't know a universe where an egg and cheese sandwich should cost $9 and a bacon, egg and cheese sandwich, $11.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great bakery. Breakfast sandwiches are amazing. The maple cream cheese danish is sooo good. Friendly staff. Everything tastes amazing. Go and get delicious treats.
It is frequently difficult to find good brunch options when traveling but even more challenging for gluten free diets. The Otter Creek Bakery absolutely covered all the bases. It not only was the perfect choice for a reasonable, tasty brunch but also had excellent gluten free options. An entire section of their bakery case was devoted to GF pastries! We enjoyed a Breakfast Panini with avocado/bacon and a Ham/Egg/Cheese Breakfast Panini with Gluten Free Wrap with our coffees. Could not pass on their Apple Streudel, as well as a GF Raspberry Oat Square for me. Many customers carried out their goodies, but there was also limited seating both inside and outside. The staff was wonderful, and the food portions were huge. We actually took half back to our hotel for afternoon/evening snacks, so the $45 tab which included gratuity was indeed a bargain.
We had a casual daytime wedding at Button Bay State Park of about 85 people and hired Tatiana and the team at Otter Creek to cater the event. We had multiple different types of sandwiches, side salads, and desserts. Everything was really delicious. Tatiana delivered everything and helped set up. My only complaint is that communication was a little difficult, especially via email (phone seemed better) but they are busy and I think still trying to expand their catering business. I would hire them again and highly recommend them for your catering needs.
We were staying for the weekend on Lake Dunmore and it was my wife's birthday. Not a big fan of supermarket cakes. Maybe because of they have about 37 ingredients, one worse than the other. The chocolate cake from Otter Creek was excellent! Moist, tasty, a small fed 8 with a little leftover. The mushroom croissant was also tasty! Happy wife, happy life.
Decided to try to grab a great favorite of mine today, The Otter Creek Sub. It wasn’t busy so I went inside. There were only two employees that I could see and the cashier was helping two customers ahead of me so I waited patiently. First of all, I wasn’t greeted upon entering and the cashier never even acknowledged me. I waited a solid 15 minutes and never was asked what I wanted to order. While I was waiting, the cashier answered the phone and took a phone order and proceeded to fire that order ahead of me while I waited, to even be acknowledged. Terrible customer service. I walked out and went somewhere else.