7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newfane

“There were 7 weary traveler's in our party looking for good food late on a Friday night. And, we found it at the Fat Crow! Hostess was so kind & welcoming, our waitress was attentive, knowledgeable & helpful, the drinks were excellent & the food was awesome!! People in our group had salads, steaks, seafood & pizza...all were delicious. So happy we found this gem!“

“Absolutely love it here. My husband and I took a drive and stopped here for breakfast. He had the omelet and I had a breakfast sandwich, and was incredibly kind to let me have a sweet treat for my birthday. Thank you all so much and we will be back for sure. ❤️“

“Excellent pizza, grinders, pasta, and salads—balance in the menu, there is. The food arrives swiftly, often within 10–15 minutes, proving that fast service does not mean shortcuts taken. Consistency, they have mastered.

Favorites among our crew remain the classic cheese and pepperoni pizzas, chicken and eggplant parmesan grinders, and personal cheese pizzas perfect for young Padawans. Even the baklava delivers a sweet finish worthy of a victory celebration.

Owners and staff alike are welcoming and hands-on, working together like a well-trained Jedi council to ensure every order is done right. Reliable, flavorful, and worth returning to—recommend this place, I do. May your appetite be strong and your slices plentiful.“

“If you are, as I am, partial to flavorful thin crust pizza that does not have an excessive amount of cheese, this is the place for you. There are, as usual, plenty of options, but I tried plain, plain with mushrooms and pizza fungus and they were delicious. Not super dougy and generously sized. A moderate number of beers on tap. There are other items on the menu, but I haven't tried them. I expect that they too are well prepared. Lots of parking, plenty of room inside and outdoor seating with a spectacular view overlooking miles of rolling hills.

One caution - be careful of the turn in when approaching from the east. It comes up quickly and is very sharp.“

“Delicious beverages and pizza with lovely picturesque views!“

“Top notch NY pizza, good bar selection, and friendly staff. We've been many times and their thin crust pizza is the best!!

6/16/20 - Happy Father's Day to all! Ramunto's is OPEN for dine-in and we had an AMAZING breakfast this morning. I had a killer bacon, egg, and cheddar calzone with a short stack and M had the Ramunto's Benedict. Needless to say, we've got enough for breakfast tomorrow. If you're in the area on the weekend, you've GOT TO try their breakfast! Rest of the day they've still got the best NY thin crust outside of Brooklyn! Peace

2/2/2026 - We dropped in for our favorite thin, crisp crust, extra pepperoni pizza for lunch. YUM! BEST EVER!!“

“Was supposed too stop elsewhere for lunch, but it was closed! Went here for lunch and had a cheeseburger grinder, grape crush soda and a slice of cheese cake. The food was awesome 👌. We'll stop there again when we're in the area!“