Williamsville Eatery

26 Dover Rd, Newfane
(802) 365-9600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Deepak Mirchandani

Their pizza is absolutely brilliant. Super creative menu!

Andrew Allen

Deserve 5 stars on quality of ingredients and service. Prices are way too high. Pizza ok for 2 adults. They didn't cut my pizza which for me made the price even more outlandish. When I buy prepared food it is not my job to do the work. So a fair 4 stars....but that aside....what a great little place, run by great people. Food is delicious.

Mucuy Bolles

Soooo good! I just had the Funky Fungi and Chris has the Roast and Smoke. Incredible flavor and portions. Plus super safe and friendly.

Wendy John

Tasty but pricey. They forgot to cut the pizza... and we were hiking so it was a little awkward but so worth it. 5 stars with proper slicing!

Mark Cohen

We looked up "cozy places to eat" and came across this hidden gem. It was indeed a very cozy restaurant to eat at with a great atmosphere! The pizza was delicious!! We]ve tried tiramisu all over - this one did not disappoint. The staff provided excellent recommendations on food/drinks and suggestions of things to see around the area.

laurie h

Great atmosphere, wonderful menu and friendly staff...overall a great dinner!! We will be back!

John LaMay

This is truly a one of a kind place. It's a locally grown farm to table restaurant in a beautifully renovated old general store built in the 1800's in a beautiful little town! Great food in a warm friendly restaurant! They always make my family feel right at home! Enjoy!!!

Jeffrey Scott Currier

Great place. Great food. Great owner!

Tracy Klatke

Our airbnb host recommended this place and we were so happy that we did. We didn't know that you should have reservations but they accommodated us anyway. This was a dining experience. The pure freshness was something we now crave. Our server, whose mom was from Ada, MN, (I can't recall her name) was exceptional. Highly recommended. We will be back.

Leif Harder

homey and comforting ambiance, curated, locally grown food options, best beer selection, best people and staff. Lori and Glenn have made a wonderful place to eat drink and be merry.

Fitzhugh Corr

Gracious friendly hosts and an interesting menu heavy on local farms' produce.

Jeffrey Currier

What a terrific spot. Walking in the door, it smells and feels like a great little place to eat. Thursday night, pizza night, wood fired, way above average pizza flavor profiles, and a thin and delicious crust. Gourmet salads, same deal. First time I've ever had warm olives as an appetizer. The owner served us, such a happy and grateful vibe. Solid wine and beer list as well. Go! Make reservations, the place is small with limited seating.

Kyle Harder

Every detail is five stars! From the food, preparation, service, wine and beer list, and welcoming environment.

lily lyons

Phenomenal spot. Everything they make is top notch. Seriously, order one of everything just to be sure.

Hannah Leahy

Very cozy and cute good food if it was warm. Waited 1.5 hrs for our meal and it was cold when it came to us. So disappointing. Maybe it was an off night for the Eatery ‍♀️

Loading...