11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rutland

“Been going to this place since i was a kid and will never stop going as long as Emily is still there. She remembers my order- even my crazy calzone requests. Her customer service is top tier, i even offered her a job at my families business. I’ve seen her deal with some rude customers and she handles them with grace and professionalism. Idk what Stromboli is either queen don’t sweat it.“

“Love their food! The only thing that sucks is the prices went up. But so did the prices of everything else in life.... I guess you can look at it that way. They do have delivery,which is what we most always do. The driver is usually the same person and he's wonderful! But, so is any other one that might deliver!!!“

“We have been twice so far and plan to go back when we visit Castleton again. The food and beer is amazing. They also have the best staff. We even brought the dog last time we went and they gave her a nice cold bowl of water and a pup cup. I highly recommend eating here.“

“I traveled 1,300 miles and ate here. The staff and food were beyond top notch. One of them little slices of heaven that everyone should enjoy“

“Yesterday was the best pizza experience of my life!!! I ordered an incredible deal they were promoting. The pizza was amazing! The store staff was truly great with the quality of my pizza, the readiness of my pick up time and the friendliness of the entire team!!! Lastly, the first time I ordered for a pick up, I entered the store with my 4 legged side kick. The manager was superb! He kindly told me that they don't allow dogs in the store. Then he told me that he would bring me my pizza to my car as soon as it was done. I appreciate the positive attitude and smiles of the associates at this store!!!“

“Great hole in the wall pizza shop, This isn’t Neapolitan apizza from the nyc area, its chicago style tavern pizza “dont confuse with Chicago deep dish” which has a thin crispy crust and cut into squares. The sauce, and cheese and toppings are high quality and tasty. They even use the nice cup pepperoni. I took my wife and kids on Friday during peak hours, service was very friendly, did take some time for the food to be served but it was expected, Their chicken cutlets are also made on premise and amazing i had their chicken parm grinder, wife had the vodka sauce chicken, both tasted great and had very generous servings.

Would go again“

“I came in about 45 minutes before closing and was met with a smile and friendly greetings. My pizza was done quickly and was hot and delicious. The staff was a step above courteous and I’d certainly eat here again.“

“Delicious food. Friendly staff. I'd give them a perfect 5 star rating!“

“Cara Mia's for the win! Got a pizza delivered and there was an incident that involved my 3 yr old slamming the door on the pizza guy and me dropping a pizza. 🤦🏼‍♂️ They called back and sent another Pizza. ❤️🍕 As a business owner, I appreciate this kind of gesture immensely. 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Best Grinders in the world, and I’ve been around at 92. Recently changed hands, better telephone service. Lived nearby for 11 years, now many hours away, but worth the trip, especially after a day of traveling home to take a well wrapped large Italian hot grinder out of the cooler and feast. Stays fresh and tasty.“

“We ordered 25 pizzas for a work party. They were ready for pick up on time, and the price was very reasonable. The only issue was an employee running her mouth about a local business in the kitchen area loud enough to be heard by customers.“