98 MIll
98 Mill St, St Johnsbury
(802) 424-1545
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
You need to go there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a Musician, I have enjoyed many Performances there this year, and I always look forward to the great food and friendly Staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the second time I’ve ever been here. The first time was about a year ago, maybe more. The food then was great! I cannot say the same for this time around. We got fried pickles and stuffed mushrooms for appetizers. The pickles were great! The mushrooms were undercooked and filled with a basic ricotta cheese. For my entree I got the lone star double stack, it wasn’t terrible. But there wasn’t a lot of flavor and the fries tasted old! For my s/o entree, he got the mill street bavette steak and was highly dissatisfied. The meat was highly undercooked, the brussel sprouts were highly overcooked and the fries once again were not fresh at all! If it weren’t for our great server, Addy, this would be getting a one star review. We hope that if we decide to return one day that the food will be exceptionally better
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Fantastic food with dog friendly outdoor river-view seating. I've eaten here a bunch of times and keep coming back. The one HUGE negative: they only have one bathroom and there can easily be a 20 minute line for it. Insane. Ridiculous.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
A full house on all counts from me. I can highly recommend the prawn & sweetcorn chowder, lobster ravioli in garlic sauce & shrimp & escalope with truffle fries. Sorry, no room for dessert. Good ales and wine. Great service from our server Taylor. Reasonable prices for great food! Easy parking. I would highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very cool renovated turn of the century mill with great Italian food + American lunch classics, like burgers and fried chicken sandwiches. I believe all of the food is made from scratch. The outside patio could use some candels or lanterns for ambiance. I will change my review to 5 stars once they switch to Heinz ketchup. Definitely coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good, I especially liked the Parmesan truffle fries.
I am from out of state and needed a family event catered over Memorial Day weekend. I reached out to 98 Mill and Robin was extremely helpful assisting me to plan the menu. The food delivery and set up had no added cost. The food was delicious, hot, and plentiful. We received many compliments from our guests on the food. We also stopped by the restaurant for dinner the night before the event and loved the food and atmosphere. I highly recommend 98 Mill for dinner or to cater a buffet.
Have been here several times with my kids. Some times we go and it's a 1 star and others a 3. I've had seafood come out cold, wait staff forget about drinks and not come out until food was ready. They seem to sit around and chat with each other a lot. Portions on meals is not consistent and EVERY time we have gone the hostess, is never there to seat people and typically somewhere around the bar chatting where he can't even see the door and if people walked in. Last night I watched a group of 6 stand by the door for 10 min before he ever went to greet them and was again sitting and socializing around the bar. Very frustrating for someone that use to work in the industry to watch the hostess start the experience off bad and then to have a waitress be forgetful abd you can literally see your drink sitting at the bar for 15 min before ever realizing she dropped the ball on that one.
Almost good but when i ordered salmon it said it would only come with lemons and such. It came with cheese. There was no mention of cheese on the menu, luckily i have only an adversion to cheese and not an allergy but in the future they should list ALL ingredients for the saftey of customers along with common courtesy
Restaurantji Recommends
Edit: I told my parents about how great this food was, the portions were huge when I was dining in person a few weeks ago. Then I get this tiny portion of Steak Gorgonzola..... now my parents never want to eat there.... 28 bucks for this..... feel free to contact me, but for now its staying at 2 stars.
Super friendly staff, AMAZING food (Steak Gorgonzola is SUPER GOOD), beautiful atmosphere, and perfect lighting. Plenty of street parking. Super popular place and is very busy!
The only place in town...good
Today May 10th, 2025 I placed an order here and the customer service was terrible. A worker there was willing to argue me down about some cold ssa fries, I arrived within the time period the staff told me my food would be ready! Who in there RIGHT MIND would cook Fries for a meal 20 minutes before the person arrive? I’ll rather have the customer wait 2-3 mins for fresh fries than argue them down about some 20-30 minute old, Don sat out, mushy, gooey, soggy, cold, below 0 fries. Fries was old as the building and she caught an attitude because I paid my hard earned money and wanted fresh hot fries. I wasn’t asking for a burger remake, nothing extra only fresh fries.
Emma is always top shelf service at the bar and Hectar can cook the best ever anything but tonight's Bavette steak wasn't dinner it was an experience in dining pleasure.
Great place! Server was super nice and the food was delicious! 100% recommend!
Loading...