Couldn’t serve my girlfriend last night cause she was to “drunk”. She wasn’t at all, very embarrassing to do that to someone who hasn’t had many drinks. As locals we will be giving our money else where.
Brian Tietjen
Great pizza highly recommend for another going to the area
Ashley Perssico
Blue Stone is a must every time we are in the Waitsfield area. For years they had this amazing vegetarian pie called Bio-Dome (basil pesto, mozzarella, spinach, fresh tomato, feta, and artichoke hearts) that I truly thought about way too often but on my most recent trip I found out that it's been removed from the menu — devastating BUT the good news is that any pie you get from Blue Stone will be delicious (I opted for a build your own this most recent visit). The staff is awesome, the atmosphere of the restaurant is great, and the location is super convenient if you're in the area for skiing.
This review was made in connection with a Toast promotion.
Veronica Craig
Amazing ! We stayed locally for 1 week and came here 4 nights. Great staff, AMAZING food and pizza , great drinks. Atmosphere was amazing. We're from CT an will be back very soon ! The staff was so friendly and amazing. The bartender was so nice and made conversation. The pizza is amazing and they have great options.
Joshua Gaze
Love the Blue Stone. They really care so I recommend this place - great food and the service has improved. Very nice place to relax; if you’re looking for pizza in town, choose here!
M Riley
Great Food, But Disappointing Service Experience
The food at Blue Stone Pizza is excellent—no complaints there. The flavors, quality, and overall experience of the meal itself were top-notch. However, my visit was overshadowed by an extremely rude and discourteous staff member who made the experience far less enjoyable.
While he did apologize, it honestly wasn’t enough to make up for the way he handled the situation. When you’re paying for a meal, you expect not just great food but also a welcoming and respectful atmosphere. It’s unfortunate because this place has so much potential, but service matters just as much as what’s on the plate.
I’d love to come back for the food, but I sincerely hope management takes service seriously—one bad interaction can ruin an otherwise fantastic experience.
Brenda Rivera
Great food and drinks
Shawn Straffin
Kept trying and thinking it was just a bad night. Crust is undercooked, bland, flavorless and sloppy presentation. Three times and same every time. Once I brought it to the waitress’s attention and she said “if you wanted it cooked longer , next time you come let us know”… So I brought my whole untouched pizza to the kitchen and had them throw it in the oven for me.
gene miller jr.
Ok first off the staff is amazing. The food?........you will not be disappointed. Ordered the maple ginger soy,spicy dry rub and the Buffalo drum sticks then added the blue stone pizza. Everything was nothing short of filling and amazing. I highly recommend this place!!!
Amber Weston
The gluten free pizza at Bluestone is amazing and as a person with celiac disease and it nice to have somewhere local that I can grab a pizza and not have to worry about getting gluten poisoning by accident or cross contamination. The restaurant atmosphere is also cool and low key and the full bar and outdoor seating is also a huge plus.
I came here with high hopes but unfortunately left disappointed. While the service was average, the main letdown was the quality of the meals. We ordered a burger and a pizza, which arrived at different times—something I wouldn’t have minded if the food had been served hot.
Instead, both dishes were room temperature at best. The burger was lukewarm, and the fries were outright cold. As for the pizza, it was barely warm and felt as though it had been sitting out. It’s a shame because, if served hot and fresh, I believe the food could have been much better.
Overall, the dining experience fell short of expectations.
Dylan Saposnick
Great vibes here. Employees were great and enjoyable. The food was amazing. highly recommend the chicken wings. We sat on the outdoor porch with the heaters on and it was great. Will be back here again on my next sugarbush trip. Great beer list as well.
Slick S
Visiting from out of state. Looking to get good size portions for a good price. Ordered a "double wide burger" with fries, as it sounded like a big burger, but was just average size. Burger was good, had a tasty bun, and bacon was the highlight. Three strips and they were nice and crispy. Could've use more toppings like lettuce and tomato to bulk it up, as it wasn't super filling. Thankfully, they hooked up the fries, and those were better than most take out fries I have. Decent meal, but for over $20 I was expecting to be full, but ate more afterwards. Good service upon pickup, but parking is tight.
Parking: There's a one or maybe two car parking on the left side, for pick up customers.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries
Ren R
Nice patio with heat, good food and friendly people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White License Plate Pizza, Small Pizza Pizza
Richard Minczuk
Enjoyed our Buffalo chicken pie vey much. Looking forward to returning.
Couldn’t serve my girlfriend last night cause she was to “drunk”. She wasn’t at all, very embarrassing to do that to someone who hasn’t had many drinks. As locals we will be giving our money else where.
Great pizza highly recommend for another going to the area
Blue Stone is a must every time we are in the Waitsfield area. For years they had this amazing vegetarian pie called Bio-Dome (basil pesto, mozzarella, spinach, fresh tomato, feta, and artichoke hearts) that I truly thought about way too often but on my most recent trip I found out that it's been removed from the menu — devastating BUT the good news is that any pie you get from Blue Stone will be delicious (I opted for a build your own this most recent visit). The staff is awesome, the atmosphere of the restaurant is great, and the location is super convenient if you're in the area for skiing.
This review was made in connection with a Toast promotion.
Amazing ! We stayed locally for 1 week and came here 4 nights. Great staff, AMAZING food and pizza , great drinks. Atmosphere was amazing. We're from CT an will be back very soon ! The staff was so friendly and amazing. The bartender was so nice and made conversation. The pizza is amazing and they have great options.
Love the Blue Stone. They really care so I recommend this place - great food and the service has improved. Very nice place to relax; if you’re looking for pizza in town, choose here!
Great Food, But Disappointing Service Experience
The food at Blue Stone Pizza is excellent—no complaints there. The flavors, quality, and overall experience of the meal itself were top-notch. However, my visit was overshadowed by an extremely rude and discourteous staff member who made the experience far less enjoyable.
While he did apologize, it honestly wasn’t enough to make up for the way he handled the situation. When you’re paying for a meal, you expect not just great food but also a welcoming and respectful atmosphere. It’s unfortunate because this place has so much potential, but service matters just as much as what’s on the plate.
I’d love to come back for the food, but I sincerely hope management takes service seriously—one bad interaction can ruin an otherwise fantastic experience.
Great food and drinks
Kept trying and thinking it was just a bad night. Crust is undercooked, bland, flavorless and sloppy presentation. Three times and same every time. Once I brought it to the waitress’s attention and she said “if you wanted it cooked longer , next time you come let us know”… So I brought my whole untouched pizza to the kitchen and had them throw it in the oven for me.
Ok first off the staff is amazing. The food?........you will not be disappointed. Ordered the maple ginger soy,spicy dry rub and the Buffalo drum sticks then added the blue stone pizza. Everything was nothing short of filling and amazing. I highly recommend this place!!!
The gluten free pizza at Bluestone is amazing and as a person with celiac disease and it nice to have somewhere local that I can grab a pizza and not have to worry about getting gluten poisoning by accident or cross contamination. The restaurant atmosphere is also cool and low key and the full bar and outdoor seating is also a huge plus.
Restaurantji Recommends
I came here with high hopes but unfortunately left disappointed. While the service was average, the main letdown was the quality of the meals. We ordered a burger and a pizza, which arrived at different times—something I wouldn’t have minded if the food had been served hot.
Instead, both dishes were room temperature at best. The burger was lukewarm, and the fries were outright cold. As for the pizza, it was barely warm and felt as though it had been sitting out. It’s a shame because, if served hot and fresh, I believe the food could have been much better.
Overall, the dining experience fell short of expectations.
Great vibes here. Employees were great and enjoyable. The food was amazing. highly recommend the chicken wings. We sat on the outdoor porch with the heaters on and it was great. Will be back here again on my next sugarbush trip. Great beer list as well.
Visiting from out of state. Looking to get good size portions for a good price.
Ordered a "double wide burger" with fries, as it sounded like a big burger, but was just average size. Burger was good, had a tasty bun, and bacon was the highlight. Three strips and they were nice and crispy.
Could've use more toppings like lettuce and tomato to bulk it up, as it wasn't super filling.
Thankfully, they hooked up the fries, and those were better than most take out fries I have.
Decent meal, but for over $20 I was expecting to be full, but ate more afterwards. Good service upon pickup, but parking is tight.
Parking: There's a one or maybe two car parking on the left side, for pick up customers.
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries
Nice patio with heat, good food and friendly people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White License Plate Pizza, Small Pizza Pizza
Enjoyed our Buffalo chicken pie vey much. Looking forward to returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...