The Pies the Limit Bakery LLC

127 Barnes St, West Rutland
(802) 342-8147

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kaitlin Kapusta

i had a cake made for my sons 1st birthday. it was perfect and tasted delicious!

Elizabeth Tetreault

I have ordered multiple times even before she opened her BEAUTIFUL building and have even taken her cookie decorating classes! However I must say, I drop off my husband at work, look on the page for my next predator…I mean snack…and I go in with a set item in mind but seeing all the beautiful creations in person - I always end up leaving with more than just my one treat for the day lol! Being able to come into the building is a luxury. She worked hard to build not only her strong reputation and repetitive clientele but to also to make her art of baking and cooking more accessible. I’m so proud of her! This had to have been by far no easy task. Anyhow, see you tomorrow. And the next day!

Carol Bassler

I came here with my husband and baby today. There was no wait, the woman cashing us out was so cheery, and the prices reasonable ($11 for two cheesecake bars). The tables were all spotless, and the packaging was thoughtful (waterproof and snap shut for safe transit of goodies.) Both bars were delicious, so we will definitely be back! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE!

Note-There is one step into the front door. It was a non-issue for us. We just parked our stroller outside and kept an eye on it through the window.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly! Came here with a fussy newborn, and didn't feel weird about it at all. Very welcoming and understanding staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob “DoneDidIt” Tanner

Great breakfast sandwiches! The Best in the city.

Gayle Snyder

They made cookies as a favor given to guests at our baby shower! They were beautifully decorated and tasted even better! Absolutely perfect! Thank you so very much!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Gildersleeve

The whoopie pies are delicious! Breakfast sandwich was very good, but would suggest your cook toast the bagels for the sandwich. Not trying to be a grumpy Gus. Just a suggestion. Will definitely come back for more. Wishing you continued success!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Whoopie Pie

Dan Myers

I ordered a cheesecake & a couple pies to take out of town to visit family. They were super delicious! Thought we’d get a couple days out of them but they were so good they got eaten up on the same day we opened everything. Great business! Definitely will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelsey Hawkins

Cupcakes and sugar cookies are absolutely delicious. However, we custom ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday and I don’t think it could ever be topped!! Not only was it so beautiful but it tasted amazing. Thank you so much for creating the perfect cake for us!

Tatiana Goulette

I placed a custom order for a party and everything came out beautifully, surpassed my expectations!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake

Elivia L

Amazing food! My favorite bakery in Town!
Super creative desserts too!
I didn't even know Reese's peanut butter cup cheesecake was a thing!
Definitely worth your time to stop in!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nick Teasean Searles

My sister went when this bakery opened and bought the most wonderful cookies to share with our family. I told her that I should see if there was a room there I could rent so I could eat those cookies all the time. Best cookies I’ve ever had. When I’m back visiting, I’m stopping by. Great addition to Rutland, VT and I hope they do well.

Food: 5

Tony Fletcher

Our local baker bailed on us at the last minute for our wedding cake. After calling around and getting nowhere to hear that there was no way, we were lucky enough to find Mary. She was very positive about everything and not only willing to help in time, but also gave us some great ideas. She was already booked for the day of our wedding, but still took the order. She made sure I knew how to transport the cake with no issues occurring. The cake was absolutely beautiful and a major hit at the wedding, and tasted amazing. We cannot thank her enough and we would recommend The Pies is the Limit Bakery for any event you are planning. Thanks again, Mary! You are the best.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julianne M

Incredibly Tasty and Gorgeous Birthday Cake! Dragon theme Cake and Dinosaur theme Cupcakes were above expectation! All my guest were asking for the bakery!! Will use again for future events! Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeremy Wheeler

Just tried the bakery today and OH MY GOD! Amazing treats with an amazing staff!

Kent Lung Yip

What a lovely bakery, the whoopie pie was very good. Great chocolate flavour and the perfect amount of filling! The bakery has cute vibes and a very good atmosphere in which to sit in and enjoy your coffee and baked goods

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...