The Pies the Limit Bakery LLC

127 Barnes St, West Rutland
(802) 342-8147

Recent Reviews

Amber Townsend

Our wedding cake was everything we had asked for and delicious!!

Elizabeth Tetreault

I order daily often! It started with my daughters birthday cake and then other random events! She even attempted her first banana foster cake for us which was AMAZING!!

Amber P

Mary has become my go to for occasion baked goods! Her work tastes and looks so amazing! She is so sweet and really easy to work with to get your needs met. She also is VERY prompt at getting back to you which is so hard to come across with small businesses these days. Highly recommend!!!

Liz S

Incredible talent!! Perfection in everything I've had from her. Ordering and pick up couldn't be easier. She's super nice to boot! Support your local businesswoman, you won't be disappointed.

Rob Booska

Absolutely the best!! Love her pies and were on our third cake witch is out of this world!!!

Sarah Lewis

Oh. My. Gosh. THIS BAKER HAS SERIOUS SKILL. I ordered 2 dozen cupcakes (red velvet and lemon) for 8 people, we intended to give the second dozen to the neighbors. Let’s just say, 23.5 cupcakes have now been eaten and there is a family battle happening for the remaining ½ cupcake. “Delicious” doesn’t do these cupcakes justice.On a second note, I was going to leave a review yesterday prior to having tried the cupcake because the ordering process and communication from the bakery was absolutely extraordinary. Fast responses to my email and she quickly answered my questions and was able to get my custom order together in less than 48 hours and in a fridge on the front screen porch of the business ready for contactless pickup!I would very much like to give this place more than 5 stars. (Google readers: please know that my rating of 5 stars is inadequate to to express how much I enjoyed this bakery from start to finish!)Perfection. ?‍?

Amber Bowman

I can't say enough positive things about my experience with this bakery. The ordering and pickup process could not have been any more convenient or user friendly. I placed a somewhat last minute order for a birthday cake and not only was she able to fulfill my order on time(on Valentines Day weekend mind you) she far exceeded any expectations I may have had. I ordered a chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, chocolate mousse filling, and chocolate ganache and it was THE best cake my fiancé and I have ever had. I can't wait to get my birthday cake here this June and plan our wedding cake!

Stephanie Taylor

The food and the service are top-notch! Thanks, Mary!

Brenda Burke

Friendly service, great communication, amazing prices, and I love ordering from The Pies the Limit Bakery. This is my favorite bakery to go for all my baked goods, and very delicious! If you have not tried this bakery yet, I highly recommend it...

Chrissy Grace

The absolute best pies, cheesecakes, and well, everything is just amazing! Highly recommend!!

Chrissy Moore

Amazing baked goods and meals. You know it’s good when one of the largest employers in the area orders regularly for their employees.?

Emily Taylor

This is the absolute best bakery around!! She is great to work with throughout the whole process and I swear can read my mind when I’m not 100% sure what to order. Mary makes the most flavorful cheesecakes, perfect cupcakes and cakes, the most delicious pies and sweetest cookies!!! There is nothing that I wouldn’t order from her, she can make any idea into the tastiest reality.

Sam Crockett

Wonderful foodVery kind serviceHighly recommend the apple pies

Jonathan Smith

I got some cupcakes here for my wife's birthday, we enjoyed them immensely.

Cara Elliott

The most delicious desserts, breads & pies you will ever find!!

Load More