Cyrus O'Leary's Pies - No retail sales onsite

the banana creme pie taste like it used to much imitation banana extract . it's too much.

I used to love these pies but they made them a third smaller... so it goes.

Purchased a lemon meringue pie for an anniversary celebration. When we cut into it the meringue was like soup under the first layer. Been buying these for years but won't do it again.

I bought the Banana Cream single serve pie. After I had to go through two days of constipation and burping up imitation Banana. It was gross. It tasted like Banana Laffy Taffy and made me feel ill for two full days. This is an awful product full of crap.

bought their peach pie. tasteless and uneatable. hopefully I can return it and get my money back.

Hi, I purchased a Coconut cream pie, here in Titusville Florida at my local Winn Dixie, it was the best I have ever tasted! Thank you for a great job!

I've purchased a few Strawberry Rhubarb pies over the years from QFC in Canyon Park WA.
Saturday July 12 2025 I purchased one and it's bad.
The rhubarb is grainy, crunchy, and the pulp strings are pronounced.

I think the filling wasn't cooked nearly enough or something. It's almost like eating a wilted Celery stick.

Great pies even sugar free

Shop at QFC stores and watch every year for your strawberry /rhubarb pies to come to the bakery!! I found them this week and bought three!! The are as close my moms rhurbarb pies as I can fine!! Keep sending them to my store!! Love them🥧🥧🌺🌺🥰🥰

I purchased the Banana Cream Pie and a Lemon flavored cream pie from Schnucks in St. Louis MO. These are soooo delicious. The banana one tastes like a mix between Banana Laffy Taffy candy and a real banana. They are amazing.

I agree with another reviewer who said their banana cream pie is a CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY. It’s amazing what some people will sell as food. The crust was nowhere near completely baked, and the filling just tasted like chemicals. After scraping it into the trash, the residue on the plates dried into a strange sticky crusty substance that seemed 100% unnatural. No idea why a store in Amish country would sell this garbage.

i've had a couple of these pies and and every time I finish I just kinda go blah. They put way too much pie crust in. I mean this pie I just had, the crust on the top was a quarter inch thick. You get a quarter inch on the bottom and a quarter inch on the top it doesn't leave much space for any kind of filling. look at the picture I included there's a huge amount of crust all around the outside. I taste like some sort of mushy cookie.So if you just want to eat a flour and palm oil crust, this is your pie!
I really don't recommend it.

I've tried the coconut, chocolate chip (?) and the banana cream. The first 2 were amazing, just so creamy and with the perfect flavors - yum. The banana tastes like a cream pie doused with artificial banana - yuck.

So delicious just avoid the banana which I'm going to finish only cuz I need the calories right now.

These pies are Delicious! They are second to none! Will purchase only this brand, as good or better than homemade!

I was not at your business...BUT here in Canada..from our local store Giant Tiger..i just bought a banana flavored cream pie...omg..best pie I've ever eaten..thanks from Nova Scotia Canada