Amelia Wynn Winery Bistro

Came here for an appetizer and tasting before my birthday. It was delicious! The grilled octopus was to die for! The bread was perfect for dipping. We enjoyed a $22 wine tasting with generous pours relative to the area! I definitely recommend :) Food came out fast and we enjoyed it on their patio!

The service here sucked. The workers whispered, never spoke up. Very unfriendly! They are not super dog friendly and tried to order a pup cup they wouldn’t let me just order a burger patty. Burger was mediocre. Wine was amazing. Over all the service was not a good experience for me. But this wine I’ll order to go.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Ordered five steaks the most disgusting steaks we’ve ever eaten,and very expensive 😡

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Wine was really good! But the bread is a joke….tasted like my middle school’s cafeteria bun that was made weeks ago, thankfully the other app was tastier. The staff was not friendly which made the atmosphere very uninviting.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

As a visitor from out of town, I was genuinely excited to explore the charm of Bainbridge Island. Up until our lunch at Amelia Wynn, the day had been a lovely experience. Unfortunately, our visit to this restaurant was disappointing.

We waited about 20 minutes to be seated, which was understandable. However, once we were at our table, the service went downhill quickly. I mentioned to the staff that my friend would be joining shortly after moving her car due to time restrictions, but it took quite a while before anyone came by to greet me or offer water. The atmosphere felt cold and unwelcoming, and I didn’t feel like we were genuinely cared for as guests.

Throughout the meal, the service remained impersonal. When our appetizer was brought to the table, the server didn’t greet us, ask if we needed anything, or even smile he simply placed the dish on the table and walked away. It felt dismissive and rude, as if we were an inconvenience.

I also observed the bartender speaking curtly to a couple of women who came in to inquire about the wine tasting, which added to the overall sense that hospitality was lacking. While I will say the food itself was quite good, we were never checked on or asked how everything was during our meal.

Customer service is a huge part of the dining experience, and sadly, that’s where Amelia Wynn fell short. The staff appeared disengaged, and the vibe made us feel unwelcome. Where I come from, we’d say, “Bless your heart” and in this case, it’s not meant kindly.

There’s potential here, but the lack of warmth and hospitality was disappointing. I hope the management takes this feedback to heart and re-evaluates the guest experience, because the food deserves better service to match.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Great food. Great Service. Lovely evening

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The ambiance and food selection were excellent. I really liked the octopus with the side ingredients. It was a nice surprise when the waiters brought my friend a complimentary dessert for her birthday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My wife is a wine afficianado and rates this restaurant very highly. I enjoyed the food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

it was unimaginably delicious. we ate a burger and a green salad with chicken - special thanks to the chef! if we are here again - we will definitely come again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Excellent dining experience for a vacation! Walked in off the street and was pleasantly surprised!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steaks, lamb chops were all quite average. Grilled octopus was very nice. Service was just average given restaurant not that busy. The wine was quite good though. Not a memorable meal.

In LOVE with this place 😊💓 LOVE language? Ambiance, quality, and energy.
Ambiance.. amazing. The perfect, cozy green corner in the main downtown area.
Quality… insane… from the staff to the food.. so welcoming, fresh, local and delightful.
Energy… welcoming!! Greeted by kindness… this place light, bright cheerful, delicious and very beautiful.

I was lucky enough to meet Simone & Nick 💓🙏🏻 both made my day. absolutely the best.

1000 stars ⭐️

Stopped to do a wine flight here. I love local stops. Owner very nice. Highly recommend. Love the outside seating.

Really delicious food. Highly recommend all of their salads - they’re super fresh and tasty.

Amelia Wynn is such a wonderful place to be. Honestly words don't accurately describe my love for this restaurant, but i will do my best.

The food is beyond incredible! My wife and I ordered the Scallops for dinner and it was to die for. We will definitely be back to get the Scallops. We also had brussell sprouts as appetizers, and a lemon posset for dessert. They were absolutely amazing.

The employees take the experience to another level. The executive chef is extremely talented and our server Blakely was wonderful.

I promise that you will enjoy your time at Amelia Wynn.