The BEST stone fired margherita pizza I have had in my entire life. Cutting the pizza with scissors is such a fun and unique experience.I have eaten marg pizza at many different places in Winnipeg, the twin cities, and Costa Rica and this place takes the cake. Wonderfully cooked with a sauce that falls to none. A must stop when you are in the Seattle area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Margherita
Alejandro Hernandez
If you close your eyes while chewing you are in Italy. Believe me, I lived 20 years in the old country.Staff super kind.
Amanda Walia
We stopped in for lunch this past Saturday after visiting the local Pia The peacekeeper troll near the high school. Was our first time on Bainbridge Island. This will now be our go to lunch/dinner spot when on the island. The food was so delicious! We ordered a Cesar salad, a pizza and the meatballs. The Caesar salad portion was huge, it was so delicious that we devoured the entire thing just between two of us. The meatballs were a huge hit with my 15 month old and the leftovers at the house did not last long. All we have been talking about is the food at this restaurant since Saturday.•I would also like to note how tentative the waitress was with my son. She found us a table where there was space next to us for his stroller and a highchair for him to sit in. She grabbed him crayons and something to color on, and did not mind him making a little mess.•For other families, with Littles, they do have a bathroom with a changing table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita D O C Pizza, Caesar Salad
calebzia
It's a little inconsistent but pound for pound this is the best pizza on the island. Good cocktails
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Fabio Pelosin
The pizzas are pretty good, and they're great with kids too. But I'm giving it 3 stars because there's a 5% extra charge for the house.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita D O C Pizza
Tim S.
Food, service and ambiance is the best. Cool building and local favorite! Real Italian pizza
John Gallup
This place should open a location that could use a pizza place with this level of quality... like Italy ! Great pie !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Order Polpettine, Cipolla Pizza
Megan Mingiano
Ahh actually good Neapolitan pizza! It’s legit! The dough is soft and melt in your mouth. I love the funghi pizza. And you have to have the mezzaluna. They have a good selection of amaro and different wines. It’s an elevated gourmet eating experience serving delicious authentic tasting pizza. Go treat yo self to a great night out.
Amazing Quattro formaggi. As long as you order it without the salad on top.Don’t understand that one. ? nor do I want to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aymen Al-ani
The staff were very friendly and the food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon C.
Visited Bainbridge for the first time and came here for dinner on a recommendation from a coworker and locals. The pizza was okay, we added prosciutto to our order and it was put on top after the pizza was baked. I prefer crispy prosciutto and I should have asked if it was going to be baked. The pizza was thin and the sauce was loose so I needed a fork and knife. We also got an appetizer and it was alright. Lots of veggies but the sauce was a bit intense. Overall the service was nice and the place is cute but I wouldn't go back.
Beth L.
Decided to go to Bainbridge today and treat my spouse to a birthday lunch. Yelped for ideas and thought I would try this place out! The ambiance based on the photos and the Neapolitan style pizza sold me. We walked in around 140 and we told it would be about 25 minutes. Within 10 minutes we got our text that our table for 2 was ready. It wasn't long after we sat down and our waitress walked up and took out drinks order. By then our water glasses were filled. Ordered an Italian Barbera that was delicious! Smooth! I had a second glass! We shared a salad and pizza. We started with the insalata cuoco! The Parmesan salad dressing is wonderful. Highly recommend the salad. It has charcuterie elements in the salad. Could not stop eating it, all the ingredients meshed well. As we were finishing our waitress ask if we were ready for our pizza to be made. We ordered the Funghi, mushrooms and garlic! The garlic made is so flavorful! Yum! Our pizza came with scissors! Have never seem that before! We cut our slices! The food, excellent service and ambience all outstanding. This place was busy the entire time we were there. Highly worth the stop if you are on the island and seeking a meal between shopping! A 5% service charge is included on the total, before the tip, 3 glasses of wine, 1 pizza and a pizza plus service charge and tax cost $103.
Gus Lehman
What a hidden gem with the garage door closed we hadn't noticed it!! Missing it would have been a travesty. Hands down the BEST pizza I have had in WA state. So upset that it's so far away from home. The Cipolla pizza was seriously amazing and I thought I would miss my meat on it, I didn't.Then the service was the best we'd had over our trip. We sat at the bar and between the bartender and the cook we were entertained the whole time and enjoyed watching them create dishes and drinks with expertise. In fact we watched the cook put together a chocolate mousse and ended up getting one too. They topped the mousse with whipped cream and a splash of EVOO and WOW, so good. Went straight to the olive oil store and got some to put on our own desserts. I just can't say enough about this place.
Excellent pizza, difficult to find better even in Italy! Attentive and diligent service. Casual and welcoming atmosphere. I recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A vibrant restaurant. We had pizza and salad. The pizza was absolutely delicious. If you go to Bainbridge Island, you must not miss this restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu Cake, Margherita Pizza
The BEST stone fired margherita pizza I have had in my entire life. Cutting the pizza with scissors is such a fun and unique experience.I have eaten marg pizza at many different places in Winnipeg, the twin cities, and Costa Rica and this place takes the cake. Wonderfully cooked with a sauce that falls to none. A must stop when you are in the Seattle area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Margherita
If you close your eyes while chewing you are in Italy. Believe me, I lived 20 years in the old country.Staff super kind.
We stopped in for lunch this past Saturday after visiting the local Pia The peacekeeper troll near the high school. Was our first time on Bainbridge Island. This will now be our go to lunch/dinner spot when on the island. The food was so delicious! We ordered a Cesar salad, a pizza and the meatballs. The Caesar salad portion was huge, it was so delicious that we devoured the entire thing just between two of us. The meatballs were a huge hit with my 15 month old and the leftovers at the house did not last long. All we have been talking about is the food at this restaurant since Saturday.•I would also like to note how tentative the waitress was with my son. She found us a table where there was space next to us for his stroller and a highchair for him to sit in. She grabbed him crayons and something to color on, and did not mind him making a little mess.•For other families, with Littles, they do have a bathroom with a changing table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita D O C Pizza, Caesar Salad
It's a little inconsistent but pound for pound this is the best pizza on the island. Good cocktails
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The pizzas are pretty good, and they're great with kids too. But I'm giving it 3 stars because there's a 5% extra charge for the house.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita D O C Pizza
Food, service and ambiance is the best. Cool building and local favorite! Real Italian pizza
This place should open a location that could use a pizza place with this level of quality... like Italy ! Great pie !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Order Polpettine, Cipolla Pizza
Ahh actually good Neapolitan pizza! It’s legit! The dough is soft and melt in your mouth. I love the funghi pizza. And you have to have the mezzaluna. They have a good selection of amaro and different wines. It’s an elevated gourmet eating experience serving delicious authentic tasting pizza. Go treat yo self to a great night out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mezzaluna
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing Quattro formaggi. As long as you order it without the salad on top.Don’t understand that one. ? nor do I want to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The staff were very friendly and the food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visited Bainbridge for the first time and came here for dinner on a recommendation from a coworker and locals. The pizza was okay, we added prosciutto to our order and it was put on top after the pizza was baked. I prefer crispy prosciutto and I should have asked if it was going to be baked. The pizza was thin and the sauce was loose so I needed a fork and knife. We also got an appetizer and it was alright. Lots of veggies but the sauce was a bit intense. Overall the service was nice and the place is cute but I wouldn't go back.
Decided to go to Bainbridge today and treat my spouse to a birthday lunch. Yelped for ideas and thought I would try this place out! The ambiance based on the photos and the Neapolitan style pizza sold me. We walked in around 140 and we told it would be about 25 minutes. Within 10 minutes we got our text that our table for 2 was ready. It wasn't long after we sat down and our waitress walked up and took out drinks order. By then our water glasses were filled. Ordered an Italian Barbera that was delicious! Smooth! I had a second glass! We shared a salad and pizza. We started with the insalata cuoco! The Parmesan salad dressing is wonderful. Highly recommend the salad. It has charcuterie elements in the salad. Could not stop eating it, all the ingredients meshed well. As we were finishing our waitress ask if we were ready for our pizza to be made. We ordered the Funghi, mushrooms and garlic! The garlic made is so flavorful! Yum! Our pizza came with scissors! Have never seem that before! We cut our slices! The food, excellent service and ambience all outstanding. This place was busy the entire time we were there. Highly worth the stop if you are on the island and seeking a meal between shopping! A 5% service charge is included on the total, before the tip, 3 glasses of wine, 1 pizza and a pizza plus service charge and tax cost $103.
What a hidden gem with the garage door closed we hadn't noticed it!! Missing it would have been a travesty. Hands down the BEST pizza I have had in WA state. So upset that it's so far away from home. The Cipolla pizza was seriously amazing and I thought I would miss my meat on it, I didn't.Then the service was the best we'd had over our trip. We sat at the bar and between the bartender and the cook we were entertained the whole time and enjoyed watching them create dishes and drinks with expertise. In fact we watched the cook put together a chocolate mousse and ended up getting one too. They topped the mousse with whipped cream and a splash of EVOO and WOW, so good. Went straight to the olive oil store and got some to put on our own desserts. I just can't say enough about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Oven