Proper Fish
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island
(206) 855-5051
Customers' Favorites
Fried Oysters and Fish and Chips
Fish and Chips and Clam Chowder
British Fish \u0026 Chips
East Coast Lobster Roll
Proper Fish and Chips
British Fish & Chips
Premium Cod Chowder
Chowder of the Day
White Fish Chowder
Minty Mushy Peas
Menu
Photos
+72 photos
+71 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I have no doubt that at some point the food was amazing. But when we went it was just ok I think because imthey don't have time to take the care they probably once did. The frys were great but the fish was bland.
Ridiculously enormous piece of fish. I got cod chowder too because I'm a chowder hound and ended up taking half the fish home to be another meal. Fish had great flavor and it came out fast. The fries are unique and delightful, I loved the stout texture. The chowder was also nice, it was mild and creamy with good flavor. I'll absolutely be back.
The Seattle area has a LOT of seafood options, but Proper Fish is one of the best! They’re consistently high quality. It can take a while to get your food if they’re busy, but it’s well worth the wait.
You May Also Like
Emmy's Vege House - 100 Winslow Way W
![]()
Vegetarian, Vegan, Asian, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Café Hitchcock - 129 Winslow Way E
![]()
Salad, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar
Sauce Nouvelle - 278 Winslow Way E #109
![]()
American, Soup, Salad, Vegan