Proper Fish
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island
(206) 855-5051
Customers' Favorites
Fried Oysters and Fish and Chips
East Coast Lobster Roll
Proper Fish and Chips
British Fish & Chips
Premium Cod Chowder
Chowder of the Day
White Fish Chowder
Minty Mushy Peas
Seafood Chowder
Hand Cut Chips
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Walking about 15 min from the ferry is a cool seafood spot. I ordered chowder and the lobster roll. Chowder was fantastic, one of the best. The roll was good but for me it needed just a bit of mayo and some more seasoning. The fries were not good. They looked good but the texture was just way off and not good at all. Id go back to get the chowder for sure. Its worth the walk by itself.
The serving is massive. Whole cod fish fillet is battered and fried. I loved the crisp on the outside but i wish the batter is a bit lighter as i still found some wet batter inside. The fish i a bit to soft for my liking, however the sauce gave a lovely balance to the rich batterd fish. The restaurant offer both inside and outside seat
You May Also Like
Emmy's Vege House - 100 Winslow Way W
![]()
Vegetarian, Vegan, Asian, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Café Hitchcock - 129 Winslow Way E
![]()
Salad, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar
Seabird - 133 Winslow Way E
![]()
Seafood, Tapas/Small Plates, Cocktail Bar
We ordered the standard British fish and chips, fish 5/5, chips 4/5, tartar sauce 5/5, and mushy peas 4.5/5.