Proper Fish
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island
(206) 855-5051
Customers' Favorites
Fried Oysters and Fish and Chips
East Coast Lobster Roll
Proper Fish and Chips
British Fish & Chips
Premium Cod Chowder
Chowder of the Day
White Fish Chowder
Minty Mushy Peas
Seafood Chowder
Hand Cut Chips
Menu
Photos
+64 photos
+63 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My sister loved the fish tacos and onion rings! I tried fried oysters for the first time (but I've never had oysters). They were fishier than I expected, but thats prob how they were supposed to taste.
Was influenced by Instagram and came here for lunch while visiting Bainbridge for the day. The Lobster roll was so very good - great bread and good amount of filling. The fish & chips however were pretty lackluster with high prices. Additionally service was underwhelming (and we got there before the rush) - they were very kind and polite but forgot several items.
My family and I visited Bainbridge Island and had to visit Proper Fish for their British styled fish n chips. I’ve visited London before and Proper Fish does a great job in matching Britain’s Fish n chips even down to their mushy peas. Their lobster roll was delicious. A bit pricey especially for its sandwich size, but they were generous with their lobster portion and it’s to be expected for lobster to be expensive. Their chowder of the day was also delicious and filled...
You May Also Like
Emmy's Vege House - 100 Winslow Way W
![]()
Vegetarian, Vegan, Asian, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Café Hitchcock - 129 Winslow Way E
![]()
Salad, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar
Seabird - 133 Winslow Way E
![]()
Seafood, Tapas/Small Plates, Cocktail Bar