Proper Fish
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island
(206) 855-5051
Customers' Favorites
Fried Oysters and Fish and Chips
British Fish \u0026 Chips
East Coast Lobster Roll
Proper Fish and Chips
British Fish & Chips
Chowder of the Day
Premium Cod Chowder
White Fish Chowder
Minty Mushy Peas
Seafood Chowder
Menu
Photos
+66 photos
+65 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best fish and chips in the Pacific Northwest. Nice atmosphere, we sat in the bar side. Great service. The fried fish is huge and super crispy and tasty and the fries are excellent 👌.
I drove 2 hours each direction from Seattle, and it was worth the trip!
The prices are a bit high, but the amount of food and taste more than makes up for it.
My absolute favorite item was the prawn cocktail, it was a wonderful medley of flavors and textures, there were at least three full shrimp in the glass, along with the one peal and eat prawn on top.
My next favorite was the lobster roll, the pieces of lobster were...
The prices are a bit high, but the amount of food and taste more than makes up for it.
My absolute favorite item was the prawn cocktail, it was a wonderful medley of flavors and textures, there were at least three full shrimp in the glass, along with the one peal and eat prawn on top.
My next favorite was the lobster roll, the pieces of lobster were...
I tried the British-style fish and chips on a busy weekend. It took about 10–15 minutes to place our order, though finding a table was easy. The food arrived in roughly 20 minutes. The fish itself was fresh but mild in flavor; paired with the crisp batter and sauce, it tasted very good and definitely fresh. The portion size was quite large—I couldn’t finish it, so it’s best shared. The fries were standard but freshly made. Overall, it’s a solid choice, though expect...
You May Also Like
Emmy's Vege House - 100 Winslow Way W
![]()
Vegetarian, Vegan, Asian, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Café Hitchcock - 129 Winslow Way E
![]()
Salad, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar
Sauce Nouvelle - 278 Winslow Way E #109
![]()
American, Soup, Salad, Vegan