Was here in November 2024 having dinner with a childhood friend and was waiting on by Cierra & left a very positive review of the restaurant & Cierra. Was here on Friday, May 23, 2025 and back to Tomato Bros. Again, good food, drinks & atmosphere, but Cierra was our server again and remembered us from last November. We were honestly very touched she remembered us. I hope that the management appreciates Cierra for how she positively represents the best of Tomato Bros. Will be back again!
Jaden Iris
Okay, just really expensive for what you get.
Laurie Jannuzzi
We eat at Tomato Brothers every time we come to town. We had it delivered to the Best Western Plus. It was delivered about 20 minutes which can be a good thing or a bad thing. The food was terrible and almost seemed like it was old food sitting around. My husband and I were sick all night and will never eat at Tomato Brothers again or get a delivery.
Kay \u0026 Jer Scott
Always good food. The bread is the best and the salad. Good date spot in the valley.
Steve Meachum
Great food and d great service.
Brad Hollenbeck
Excellent bite size.
Todd MacIntyre
We had a fantastic lunch here. The staff was very friendly, and the Italian food was delicious! We visited with two young kids, and they enjoyed drawing with crayons on the paper tablecloth that gets put down. They also have a kids menu for some smaller portion options. We would definitely go back!
Brian Fox
Has always been my favorite place to go but after my last several visits that is not the case any longer. They have changed up how they make some of the dishes (steak mazithra, blackened chicken) . Changes are not good in my opinion and would not order them again.
Jeffrie Bond (J.Bond)
Great!! Rebecca exceptional!! UPDATE: It's a Happy Day! There IS none better.
We had a 5pm reservation on 4/16. Service was friendly and there was plenty of parking available. Now let's get down to the details of the poor review. The chicken piccata... Who serves an Italian dish over mashed potatoes? No one, because that's not how it's done as it should be served over pasta especially at the price you are asking for it. (This is true with most of the Italian dishes served here.) Next, it should never be that bland and don't be so cheap with the capers. Sorry I likely won't be back.
Richie Rich
First time here and was greeted nice and professional. Lots of seating and a bar. Ordered the Steak Myzithra : linguini sautéed in brown butter with onions,mushrooms,spinach, fire roasted tomatoes, and Myzithra cheese on top. Bread is served with garlic butter. The steak was perfectly cooked, very soft and the flavor was supreme! Price was a little on the high side at 28$ yet I feel worth the money. They also have pizza,pasta, and hot sandwiches. Being from the town that created the Stromboli; I believe I will try this next visit. One thing to note: if you want to try a side with a meatball, I was told it doesn’t come with gravy unless you order it as the appetizer item. I was already ordering a meal so didn’t want a heavy app. Disappointed with that.
michael brcic
The Wednesday wine specials really topped off a goid dinner
Paula McNeeley
We ordered a half and half wood fired pizza, and it was so delicious that I dont think we had any leftovers. Great service also. I would definitely go back if it were in my home state and near Salem. 7th
Great Italian and American food
Was here in November 2024 having dinner with a childhood friend and was waiting on by Cierra & left a very positive review of the restaurant & Cierra. Was here on Friday, May 23, 2025 and back to Tomato Bros. Again, good food, drinks & atmosphere, but Cierra was our server again and remembered us from last November. We were honestly very touched she remembered us. I hope that the management appreciates Cierra for how she positively represents the best of Tomato Bros. Will be back again!
Okay, just really expensive for what you get.
We eat at Tomato Brothers every time we come to town. We had it delivered to the Best Western Plus. It was delivered about 20 minutes which can be a good thing or a bad thing. The food was terrible and almost seemed like it was old food sitting around. My husband and I were sick all night and will never eat at Tomato Brothers again or get a delivery.
Always good food. The bread is the best and the salad. Good date spot in the valley.
Great food and d great service.
Excellent bite size.
We had a fantastic lunch here. The staff was very friendly, and the Italian food was delicious! We visited with two young kids, and they enjoyed drawing with crayons on the paper tablecloth that gets put down. They also have a kids menu for some smaller portion options. We would definitely go back!
Has always been my favorite place to go but after my last several visits that is not the case any longer. They have changed up how they make some of the dishes (steak mazithra, blackened chicken) . Changes are not good in my opinion and would not order them again.
Great!! Rebecca exceptional!! UPDATE: It's a Happy Day! There IS none better.
Restaurantji Recommends
A go to place
We had a 5pm reservation on 4/16. Service was friendly and there was plenty of parking available. Now let's get down to the details of the poor review. The chicken piccata... Who serves an Italian dish over mashed potatoes? No one, because that's not how it's done as it should be served over pasta especially at the price you are asking for it. (This is true with most of the Italian dishes served here.) Next, it should never be that bland and don't be so cheap with the capers. Sorry I likely won't be back.
First time here and was greeted nice and professional. Lots of seating and a bar. Ordered the Steak Myzithra : linguini sautéed in brown butter with onions,mushrooms,spinach, fire roasted tomatoes, and Myzithra cheese on top. Bread is served with garlic butter. The steak was perfectly cooked, very soft and the flavor was supreme! Price was a little on the high side at 28$ yet I feel worth the money. They also have pizza,pasta, and hot sandwiches. Being from the town that created the Stromboli; I believe I will try this next visit. One thing to note: if you want to try a side with a meatball, I was told it doesn’t come with gravy unless you order it as the appetizer item. I was already ordering a meal so didn’t want a heavy app. Disappointed with that.
The Wednesday wine specials really topped off a goid dinner
We ordered a half and half wood fired pizza, and it was so delicious that I dont think we had any leftovers. Great service also. I would definitely go back if it were in my home state and near Salem. 7th
Loading...