the staff is friendly, the atmosphere quaint, but the food was not the best. Our first time so we would try it again, but definitely not the soup or steak salad
Wesley Cruse
Came here for a Father’s Day lunch around 1 pm. We didn’t realize they were closing at 1:30 pm; they said they could seat us right away but that there was likely a 50 min wait for food. This was the first sign something was off—competent restaurants at full capacity should have no problem churning food out of their kitchens at much quicker speeds. Perhaps they had call outs or something, so I can forgive that. Everything after we were seated, though, made me want to forgive Rustlers less and less.
First, service. The waitress seemed less than interested in serving us. Brief, disinterested, lacking enthusiasm. Felt like we were a burden to serve, rather than a joy (and nothing about our presence warranted such an apathetic vibe from her; truly, we were happy to be there and hopeful for a good lunch, content to wait the 50 min because my grandparents like the place).
Second, atmosphere. This is where Rustlers really shines, I think. It’s so cute and cozy. The western theme is awesome, and I love how each part of the restaurant feels like its own little room. Each space comes alive perfectly with tasteful, themed decor.
Third, food. This is on the same level as service. Super underwhelming, if not concerning. I ordered a chicken caesar salad, something so basic that to mess it up is, frankly, embarrassing. There was wilted lettuce, some even so far wilted as to be brown and on the verge of rotten, as well as pieces of Parmesan rind amidst the Parmesan shavings (anyone who knows how to handle parm knows that the rind isn’t for serving). Additionally, their timing on food was really off. Different dishes of our party came out minutes apart and several parts of dishes were cold (cold toast, cold fries). It’s just obvious the kitchen was super unorganized and lacking.
So there you have it. Really dissatisfied, would only go back if dragged there by someone who convinced me to give them another go. And honestly, I do think they’re likely much better than what we experienced. Sadly, all I experienced, however, was the experience of Rustlers feeling very, very rusty.
Daniel Albro
If you like a small town, great atmosphere, nice portion 's, and of course, the staff is great!!!
You need to come up to rustlers for a good meal.
Jeff P
Went there for lunch. Had the Bacon Cheddar Burger w/ waffle fries. The burger was delicious and juicy so make sure to have an extra napkin. The waffle fries were crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Also had a raspberry ice tea to wash it down. The waitress was also amazing, loved her.
Susan Hayes
One of our go-to restaurants in Lynden, WA. Nice variety in the menu but I always have to get the meatball soup! Consistently quality and friendly service.
Rachelle Ramirez Parrish
Alot to see and do! Great place for a date and drink or family dinner to event space. I have used for space for my soms 1st birthday. Many many dinners and lunches All good food but didnt love the kids fish and chips but they offered to re make. Everyone is friendly and fast service. Great desserts and snacks to go. Great place tonput screens down and play I spy with kids or adults :)
Joshua Guyswhite
Good dining. Has lots of different little rooms with booths in them. Keeps the noise level down.
Michael Joseph
The Mrs. and I stopped in last week for a try and the service was warm, friendly, welcoming. And the food was great! I had a burger and my wife got the pot roast - excellent!! Check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Golling
I like the choice to eat in the bar or family rooms! It was a Sunday night, and although it was kind of busy it seemed like they had just ONE server handling both the bar AND the tables in the bar area, so service was a little slower than one might expect- maybe needed more staff? Waffle fries were kinda cold (were they sitting for a while?) Food was good, although the burger patty was kind of thin and NOT cooked medium as requested.
Great little place to eat. The old west vibe is fun and the food is good. Reasonably priced for what you get. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Miller
There fish and chips are in my opinion the best in whatcom country. I'll even say that the coleslaw is good. This is my go to place. The only negative thing is they don't have bud.light on tap and I don't like the hash browns at all.
Excellent food and staff!!!
the staff is friendly, the atmosphere quaint, but the food was not the best. Our first time so we would try it again, but definitely not the soup or steak salad
Came here for a Father’s Day lunch around 1 pm. We didn’t realize they were closing at 1:30 pm; they said they could seat us right away but that there was likely a 50 min wait for food. This was the first sign something was off—competent restaurants at full capacity should have no problem churning food out of their kitchens at much quicker speeds. Perhaps they had call outs or something, so I can forgive that. Everything after we were seated, though, made me want to forgive Rustlers less and less.
First, service. The waitress seemed less than interested in serving us. Brief, disinterested, lacking enthusiasm. Felt like we were a burden to serve, rather than a joy (and nothing about our presence warranted such an apathetic vibe from her; truly, we were happy to be there and hopeful for a good lunch, content to wait the 50 min because my grandparents like the place).
Second, atmosphere. This is where Rustlers really shines, I think. It’s so cute and cozy. The western theme is awesome, and I love how each part of the restaurant feels like its own little room. Each space comes alive perfectly with tasteful, themed decor.
Third, food. This is on the same level as service. Super underwhelming, if not concerning. I ordered a chicken caesar salad, something so basic that to mess it up is, frankly, embarrassing. There was wilted lettuce, some even so far wilted as to be brown and on the verge of rotten, as well as pieces of Parmesan rind amidst the Parmesan shavings (anyone who knows how to handle parm knows that the rind isn’t for serving). Additionally, their timing on food was really off. Different dishes of our party came out minutes apart and several parts of dishes were cold (cold toast, cold fries). It’s just obvious the kitchen was super unorganized and lacking.
So there you have it. Really dissatisfied, would only go back if dragged there by someone who convinced me to give them another go. And honestly, I do think they’re likely much better than what we experienced. Sadly, all I experienced, however, was the experience of Rustlers feeling very, very rusty.
If you like a small town, great atmosphere, nice portion 's, and of course, the staff is great!!!
You need to come up to rustlers for a good meal.
Went there for lunch. Had the Bacon Cheddar Burger w/ waffle fries. The burger was delicious and juicy so make sure to have an extra napkin. The waffle fries were crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Also had a raspberry ice tea to wash it down. The waitress was also amazing, loved her.
One of our go-to restaurants in Lynden, WA. Nice variety in the menu but I always have to get the meatball soup! Consistently quality and friendly service.
Alot to see and do! Great place for a date and drink or family dinner to event space. I have used for space for my soms 1st birthday. Many many dinners and lunches All good food but didnt love the kids fish and chips but they offered to re make. Everyone is friendly and fast service. Great desserts and snacks to go. Great place tonput screens down and play I spy with kids or adults :)
Good dining. Has lots of different little rooms with booths in them. Keeps the noise level down.
The Mrs. and I stopped in last week for a try and the service was warm, friendly, welcoming. And the food was great! I had a burger and my wife got the pot roast - excellent!! Check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I like the choice to eat in the bar or family rooms! It was a Sunday night, and although it was kind of busy it seemed like they had just ONE server handling both the bar AND the tables in the bar area, so service was a little slower than one might expect- maybe needed more staff? Waffle fries were kinda cold (were they sitting for a while?)
Food was good, although the burger patty was kind of thin and NOT cooked medium as requested.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Hash brown tasted funny
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great little place to eat. The old west vibe is fun and the food is good. Reasonably priced for what you get. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There fish and chips are in my opinion the best in whatcom country. I'll even say that the coleslaw is good. This is my go to place. The only negative thing is they don't have bud.light on tap and I don't like the hash browns at all.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Fish, Fish and Chips
It is a very busy restaurant.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Good food and service for this type of restaurant
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries, Salad, Garden Omelette
Loading...