Honestly their cake pops are amazing the best I've ever had. Highly recommend it's soooo delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Atkins
You made my husband's 50th one to remember. The level of design and ornaments were perfect! You and your staff are extremely talented!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenny Sanders
They made my daughter‘s wedding cake and it was absolutely beautiful. It was just like the picture we had showed them.
John Wilson
Absolutely fantastic. Must be where they got the name. Everything from my first outreach by email to phone call to ordering was excellent communication. I'd never done this before so I had a little trepidation. Payment was easy, as was pickup. But the big test, the reveal, was absolutely fantastic! The birthday girl (Mom's 80th) was overjoyed with the aesthetics of the cake, its presentation, and, of course, the taste. We're still eating it 3 days later! There's nothing to improve! Just keep doing what you're doing. You were the highlight of the event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma Behman
Jessi and her bakery were an absolute dream to work with for our family's wedding! As the impromptu wedding helper, I was so grateful for her kindness, flexibility, and patience, especially since we had some last-minute details to finalize. She went above and beyond to design and bake a stunning cake for the bride and groom, just as they wanted, even when things felt a little scattered.
On the wedding day, Jessi checked in with me, set up the cake beautifully, and made sure everything was perfect. And oh my goodness, the cake itself was incredible! Seriously one of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted (I had multiple slices - whoops!). Guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious it was!
Jessi’s thoughtfulness, talent, and dedication made such a difference. I traveled in for this wedding, but I’m already tempted to make a special trip back just to order another cake from her. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers delicious flavors, beautiful designs, and heartwarming service, Simply Caketastic is it. Thank you for making the day even sweeter!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jasmine Szekely
I LOVED the cupcakes I got from Simply Caketastic for my baby shower over the weekend. We made sure to purchase sample cupcakes a couple weeks ahead of time to try out different flavors. We decided on Lavendar with vanilla buttercream, carrot cake with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate on chocolate and lemon with lemon buttercream. They honestly were the best cupcakes I've ever had. Friendly atmosphere, very helpful, skilled. I was really happy with my purchase. They've gained a customer for life, and a few others because everyone was asking where we got them.
Jasmine Little
I LOVED the cupcakes I got from Simply Caketastic for my baby shower over the weekend. We made sure to purchase sample cupcakes a couple weeks ahead of time to try out different flavors. We decided on Lavendar with vanilla buttercream, carrot cake with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate on chocolate and lemon with lemon buttercream. They honestly were the best cupcakes I've ever had. Friendly atmosphere, very helpful, skilled. I was really happy with my purchase. They've gained a customer for life, and a few others because everyone was asking where we got them.
Jeanann Smith
Ordered a cake for a Bachelorette Party. The cake looked great. However.. I understand why they used fondant, but I asked them not to. And the cake did not taste good. It was wickedly sweet, and dry. So dry that the end was rock hard.
Food: 2
Service: 5
Madre's Cocina
I had the pleasure of tasting these cupcakes for the first time this weekend and wow!
I do a lot of cupcake tasting and as of now I can say these are my new favorite. I tasted a few different flavors and they all did not disappoint.
The frosting was so light and creamy and not too sweet 🤤💜
The cake itself was so... I don't even know how to explain how yummy it was. 😋
Kudos to the baker.
Julie Pabroa
Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious—every bite was perfect! The bakery owner, Jessi, was incredibly kind and accommodating throughout the whole process. We couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out. We highly recommend this bakery—it’s officially our favorite shop from now on!
They made me a beautiful baby shower cake and a year later we're coming back for our wedding cake!
Chelsey Lee
Jessi the owner is an absolute gem! Her and her staff were able to put together thee most beautiful sweet 16 cake for my daughter with just a couple days notice. Not only did my daughter love how beautiful the cake was, her and everyone there loved how moist and yummy it was. The red raspberry filling was so tasty. I would highly recommend Simply Caketastic for your custom cake needs!! Thanks again Jessi and staff we loved the cake.
Matt Mobbin
I used to love buying cakes here, but after our recent purchase creativity & quality has really gone downhill. I hope they can turn things around, but will no longer be purchasing cakes for my friends or family here. We pre-ordered the cake two weeks in advance; even forgot to put any writing on the cake. In times past this place has hit the mark, but this last cake for $170 was a big dud; baffled by the egregious disregard for quality and creative freedom.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Eagle Mountain Country Wedding Venue
Jessica and crew are caring and dedicated to ensure your choice of dessert comes out as you wished for! Thank you for ensuring our guests enjoy your labor of love at Eagle Mountain Venue in Arlington, Smokey Point 🍰
Sincerely,
Kim McLaughlin-Esquivel
206-679-4098
Robert Lechtenberg
Jessi is such an amazing person! Her team is super friendly and genuinely care about helping people.
Honestly their cake pops are amazing the best I've ever had. Highly recommend it's soooo delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You made my husband's 50th one to remember. The level of design and ornaments were perfect! You and your staff are extremely talented!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They made my daughter‘s wedding cake and it was absolutely beautiful. It was just like the picture we had showed them.
Absolutely fantastic. Must be where they got the name. Everything from my first outreach by email to phone call to ordering was excellent communication. I'd never done this before so I had a little trepidation. Payment was easy, as was pickup. But the big test, the reveal, was absolutely fantastic! The birthday girl (Mom's 80th) was overjoyed with the aesthetics of the cake, its presentation, and, of course, the taste. We're still eating it 3 days later! There's nothing to improve! Just keep doing what you're doing. You were the highlight of the event!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessi and her bakery were an absolute dream to work with for our family's wedding! As the impromptu wedding helper, I was so grateful for her kindness, flexibility, and patience, especially since we had some last-minute details to finalize. She went above and beyond to design and bake a stunning cake for the bride and groom, just as they wanted, even when things felt a little scattered.
On the wedding day, Jessi checked in with me, set up the cake beautifully, and made sure everything was perfect. And oh my goodness, the cake itself was incredible! Seriously one of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted (I had multiple slices - whoops!). Guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious it was!
Jessi’s thoughtfulness, talent, and dedication made such a difference. I traveled in for this wedding, but I’m already tempted to make a special trip back just to order another cake from her. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers delicious flavors, beautiful designs, and heartwarming service, Simply Caketastic is it. Thank you for making the day even sweeter!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I LOVED the cupcakes I got from Simply Caketastic for my baby shower over the weekend. We made sure to purchase sample cupcakes a couple weeks ahead of time to try out different flavors. We decided on Lavendar with vanilla buttercream, carrot cake with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate on chocolate and lemon with lemon buttercream. They honestly were the best cupcakes I've ever had. Friendly atmosphere, very helpful, skilled. I was really happy with my purchase. They've gained a customer for life, and a few others because everyone was asking where we got them.
I LOVED the cupcakes I got from Simply Caketastic for my baby shower over the weekend. We made sure to purchase sample cupcakes a couple weeks ahead of time to try out different flavors. We decided on Lavendar with vanilla buttercream, carrot cake with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate on chocolate and lemon with lemon buttercream. They honestly were the best cupcakes I've ever had. Friendly atmosphere, very helpful, skilled. I was really happy with my purchase. They've gained a customer for life, and a few others because everyone was asking where we got them.
Ordered a cake for a Bachelorette Party. The cake looked great. However.. I understand why they used fondant, but I asked them not to. And the cake did not taste good. It was wickedly sweet, and dry. So dry that the end was rock hard.
Food: 2
Service: 5
I had the pleasure of tasting these cupcakes for the first time this weekend and wow! I do a lot of cupcake tasting and as of now I can say these are my new favorite. I tasted a few different flavors and they all did not disappoint. The frosting was so light and creamy and not too sweet 🤤💜 The cake itself was so... I don't even know how to explain how yummy it was. 😋 Kudos to the baker.
Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious—every bite was perfect! The bakery owner, Jessi, was incredibly kind and accommodating throughout the whole process. We couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out. We highly recommend this bakery—it’s officially our favorite shop from now on!
Restaurantji Recommends
They made me a beautiful baby shower cake and a year later we're coming back for our wedding cake!
Jessi the owner is an absolute gem! Her and her staff were able to put together thee most beautiful sweet 16 cake for my daughter with just a couple days notice. Not only did my daughter love how beautiful the cake was, her and everyone there loved how moist and yummy it was. The red raspberry filling was so tasty. I would highly recommend Simply Caketastic for your custom cake needs!! Thanks again Jessi and staff we loved the cake.
I used to love buying cakes here, but after our recent purchase creativity & quality has really gone downhill. I hope they can turn things around, but will no longer be purchasing cakes for my friends or family here. We pre-ordered the cake two weeks in advance; even forgot to put any writing on the cake. In times past this place has hit the mark, but this last cake for $170 was a big dud; baffled by the egregious disregard for quality and creative freedom.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jessica and crew are caring and dedicated to ensure your choice of dessert comes out as you wished for! Thank you for ensuring our guests enjoy your labor of love at Eagle Mountain Venue in Arlington, Smokey Point 🍰 Sincerely, Kim McLaughlin-Esquivel 206-679-4098
Jessi is such an amazing person! Her team is super friendly and genuinely care about helping people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...