Elliott Bay Pizza & Pub

Elliot Bay Pizza and Pub in Mill Creek is a gem! Their pizza is hands down the best in the area—perfectly crisp crust, generous toppings, and that ideal balance of flavors that keeps you coming back for more. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, making it a great spot for family dinners or meeting up with friends. Their beer selection is solid, with plenty of local brews on tap to pair with your meal. The service is always friendly and attentive, even during busy hours. If you’re in the Mill Creek area and craving pizza, this is the place to go! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am from Michigan and lived in Detroit for years, during which time I had Buddy’s pizza regularly. Buddy’s I believe, is where Detroit style pizza originated. Tonight at Elliot Bay Pizza my husband and I had Detroit style with spicy sausage, meatballs, fresh mushrooms and black olives. It was fabulous. The mushrooms were fresh, the meatballs chunky, and the sausage was sliced like pepperoni. The cheese was melty and plentiful. The crust was not as oily as
Buddy’s which was okay with us. One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long, long time. The beer and wine were equally good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Athena is so attentive and helpful! She’s literally the best and this place serves the best food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We used to order here regularly. The quality has diminished completely over three years. Each time we order, we get a different quality pizza. I finally said no more today. Not only was the order incorrect but it was flat, tasteless, and greasy soggy mess. The crust was hard. Husband's pizza tasted like salt and melted mayonnaise. We are no longer ordering pizza from Elliott Bay.

Food: 1

What a great place! I've had maybe 5 of their subs now and they're all amazing! The beer selection is also great, and the staff are very kind and attentive. I go here at least once a week now, trying all their subs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

$30 for such a disgusting pizza. Not worth it, At All. The pizza was chewy as if you were to be chewing a gum. They used a cheese that is probably not even cheese. When you pick it up it falls apart. Look at the picture .
In my opinion Little Cesar's pizza is much better. The place was Empty. Now I know why. Never again going here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The place has great reviews for pizza but their calzone is below average. I ordered chicken rosemary calzone and although it was crispy on the outside, the chicken was flavorless and tasted a day old. Imagine eating leftover rotisserie chicken, but the part that's dry and has a rotten taste. I spit some out and forced myself to eat the rest with some salt and chili flakes.
I had a cheaper elk burger in Bend and it was sumptuous. This cost me 28 including a tip.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

The female hostess with tattoos hates her job and you can tell. Super rude for no reason 👎 The other hostess wasn't very friendly either. Yikes

Good sandwiches. Beer selection is great 👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

blew up the toilets I didn’t tip the waiter enough or something and he put laxatives in my food

Meet friends here for dinner/beer quite frequently. Absolutely love their pizza and selection of beer. I ALWAYS get the chef salad. It's huge, and so well put together...just love it. Service has always been friendly and on-point.
Came in a couple weeks ago at happy hour and sat at the bar. Asked bartender (we've not seen him before)if he'd please wipe down the bar before we ordered. He never came back. At all. Waited on tables arriving after us and talked with regulars until we left. No wipedown, no water, no nothing. Total bummer.
Hard to come back after that.
Probably look for a new place.

I have been here for an hour waiting on Togo food and the bartender..bless her heart, is too busy to go and get it..it has to be ready by now. I am certain I will be bringing home cold, dead food.

Pizza was good. Menu had a great selection. Service was average. Restaurant seemed clean, but what spoiled the entire experience was to discover that beverages were being stored about 3 feet from the toilet inside of the restroom. On the same shelf below the beverages was a bottle of cleaning chemicals.

Pizza is delicious, but it's frustrating that they charge extra for the specials. They should list the actual price on the menu. It's also annoying that they charge extra for sauces. I don’t mind paying, but it feels cheap that they serve it in a plastic container as if I'm ordering to-go.